Double-winding Wilson loops and monopole confinement mechanisms

Abstract

We consider "double-winding" Wilson loops in SU(2) gauge theory. These are contours which wind once around a loop $C_1$ and once around a loop $C_2$, where the two co-planar loops share one point in common, and where $C_1$ lies entirely in (or is displaced slightly from) the minimal area of $C_2$. We discuss the expectation value of such double-winding loops in abelian confinement pictures, where the spatial distribution of confining abelian fields is controlled by either a monopole Coulomb gas, a caloron ensemble, or a dual abelian Higgs model, and argue that in such models an exponential falloff in the sum of areas $A_1+A_2$ is expected. In contrast, in a center vortex model of confinement, the behavior is an exponential falloff in the difference of areas $A_2-A_1$. We compute such double-winding loops by lattice Monte Carlo simulation, and find that the area law falloff follows a difference-in-areas law. The conclusion is that even if confining gluonic field fluctuations are, in some gauge, mainly abelian in character, the spatial distribution of those abelian fields cannot be the distribution predicted by the simple monopole gas, caloron ensemble, or dual abelian Higgs actions, which have been used in the past to explain the area law falloff of Wilson loops.

arXiv comment12 pages, 12 figures. v2: added references, fixed some misprints

References in corpus (20)

• Periodic Instantons with non-trivial Holonomy
• SU(2) Calorons and Magnetic Monopoles
• Supersymmetric Solitons and How They Help Us Understand Non-Abelian Gauge Theories
• Magnetic bion condensation: A new mechanism of confinement and mass gap in four dimensions
• Monopole action and condensation in SU(2) QCD
• Dual superconductor models of color confinement
• Confining ensemble of dyons
• Vortex Structure vs. Monopole Dominance in Abelian-Projected Gauge Theory
• Fine tuned vortices in lattice SU(2) gluodynamics
• 't Hooft Loops, Electric Flux Sectors and Confinement in SU(2) Yang-Mills Theory
• A detailed study of the Abelian-projected SU(2) flux tube and its dual Ginzburg-Landau analysis
• An SU(2) KvBLL caloron gas model and confinement
• Duality of gauge field singularities and the structure of the flux tube in Abelian-projected SU(2) gauge theory and the dual Abelian Higgs model
• Center Disorder in the 3D Georgi-Glashow Model
• Generation of confinement and other nonperturbative effects by infrared gluonic degrees of freedom
• Cautionary remarks on the moduli space metric for multi-dyon simulations
• The Vortex Structure of SU(2) Calorons
• Confining dyon gas with finite-volume effects under control
• Improved superposition schemes for approximate multi-caloron configurations
• On Chiral Symmetry Breaking, Topology and Confinement

Cited by in corpus (26)

• Confining Dyon-Anti-Dyon Coulomb Liquid Model I
• Confinement from Center Vortices: A review of old and new results
• Connection between centre vortices and instantons through gauge-field smoothing
• Chiral Symmetry Breaking on the Lattice
• 4d ensembles of percolating center vortices and monopole defects: the emergence of flux tubes with N-ality and gluon confinement
• Different faces of confinement
• Center Vortices, Area Law and the Catenary Solution
• A model of random center vortex lines in continuous 2+1-dimensional space-time
• Confining Bond Rearrangement in the Random Center Vortex Model
• Confinement, Holonomy and Correlated Instanton-Dyon Ensemble I: SU(2) Yang-Mills Theory
• $\mathrm{SU}(N)\to \mathrm{Z}(N)$ dual superconductor models: the magnetic loop ensemble point of view
• The Schwinger function, confinement and positivity violation in pure gauge QED
• Confinement on ${\mathbb{R}}^3\times {\mathbb{S}}^1$ and Double-String Collapse
• Ensembles of center vortices and chains: Insights from a natural lattice framework
• Approaching $SU(2)$ gauge dynamics with smeared $Z(2)$ vortices
• Double-winding Wilson loops in the $SU(N)$ Yang-Mills theory
• Double-winding Wilson loops in SU(N) lattice Yang-Mills gauge theory
• Lattice Index Theorem and Fractional Topological Charge
• A first analysis of the ensemble of local maxima of maximal center gauge
• Comment on "Fractional topological charges and the lowest Dirac modes"
• Colorful plane vortices and Chiral Symmetry Breaking in $SU(2)$ Lattice Gauge Theory
• Study of the Emergence of a Gluon Mass Scale from Center Vortices Using a Wave-Functional Formalism
• Center group dominance in quark confinement
• Double-winding Wilson loop in $SU(N)$ Yang-Mills theory: A criterion for testing the confinement models
• Remarks on the Confinement in the $G(2)$ Gauge Theory Using the Thick Center Vortex Model
• Center Vortex vs. Abelian models of the QCD vacuum