Quantifying (dis)agreement between direct detection experiments in a halo-independent way

Abstract

We propose an improved method to study recent and near-future dark matter direct detection experiments with small numbers of observed events. Our method determines in a quantitative and halo-independent way whether the experiments point towards a consistent dark matter signal and identifies the best-fit dark matter parameters. To achieve true halo independence, we apply a recently developed method based on finding the velocity distribution that best describes a given set of data. For a quantitative global analysis we construct a likelihood function suitable for small numbers of events, which allows us to determine the best-fit particle physics properties of dark matter considering all experiments simultaneously. Based on this likelihood function we propose a new test statistic that quantifies how well the proposed model fits the data and how large the tension between different direct detection experiments is. We perform Monte Carlo simulations in order to determine the probability distribution function of this test statistic and to calculate the p-value for both the dark matter hypothesis and the background-only hypothesis.

23 pages, 14 figures. v2: matches published version

References in corpus (56)

• Asymptotic formulae for likelihood-based tests of new physics
• Local Kinematics and the Local Standard of Rest
• First results from the LUX dark matter experiment at the Sanford Underground Research Facility
• Inelastic Dark Matter
• The RAVE Survey: Constraining the Local Galactic Escape Speed
• Search for Low-Mass WIMPs with SuperCDMS
• Finding an Upper Limit in the Presence of Unknown Background
• Isospin-Violating Dark Matter
• Galactic Searches for Dark Matter
• Dark Matter Direct Detection with Non-Maxwellian Velocity Structure
• Search for dark matter and large extra dimensions in monojet events in pp collisions at sqrt(s) = 7 TeV
• Search for dark matter candidates and large extra dimensions in events with a jet and missing transverse momentum with the ATLAS detector
• CoGeNT Interpretations
• The Astrophysical Uncertainties Of Dark Matter Direct Detection Experiments
• Generalized Analysis of Weakly-Interacting Massive Particle Searches
• Integrating Out Astrophysical Uncertainties
• Spin-independent elastic WIMP scattering and the DAMA annual modulation signal
• Testing the statistical compatibility of independent data sets
• Likelihood Approach to the First Dark Matter Results from XENON100
• Resolving astrophysical uncertainties in dark matter direct detection
• Low-threshold analysis of CDMS shallow-site data
• Galactic Halo Models and Particle Dark-Matter Detection
• Astrophysical uncertainties on direct detection experiments
• The unbearable lightness of being: CDMS versus XENON
• Search for a heavy top-quark partner in final states with two leptons with the ATLAS detector at the LHC
• Effect of halo modelling on WIMP exclusion limits
• Halo independent comparison of direct dark matter detection data
• Enhancement of NEST Capabilities for Simulating Low-Energy Recoils in Liquid Xenon
• Are direct search experiments sensitive to all spin-independent WIMP candidates?
• Astrophysics independent bounds on the annual modulation of dark matter signals
• Reconstructing WIMP Properties in Direct Detection Experiments Including Galactic Dark Matter Distribution Uncertainties
• Generalized Halo Independent Comparison of Direct Dark Matter Detection Data
• Direct detection of Light Anapole and Magnetic Dipole DM
• Dependence of direct detection signals on the WIMP velocity distribution
• DAMA and CoGeNT without astrophysical uncertainties
• Halo-independent methods for inelastic dark matter scattering
• Inelastic Dark Matter, Non-Standard Halos and the DAMA/LIBRA Results
• A new halo-independent approach to dark matter direct detection analysis
• Model-Independent Determination of the WIMP Mass from Direct Dark Matter Detection Data
• WIMP astronomy and particle physics with liquid-noble and cryogenic direct-detection experiments
• A Bayesian view of the current status of dark matter direct searches
• Taking Halo-Independent Dark Matter Methods Out of the Bin
• Observational constraints on a holographic, interacting dark energy model
• Quantifying Astrophysical Uncertainties on Dark Matter Direct Detection Results
• Model independent determination of the dark matter mass from direct detection experiments
• Light Dark Matter in the light of CRESST-II
• Taming astrophysical bias in direct dark matter searches
• Getting the astrophysics and particle physics of dark matter out of next-generation direct detection experiments
• Improved determination of the WIMP mass from direct detection data
• A systematic halo-independent analysis of direct detection data within the framework of Inelastic Dark Matter
• On the annual modulation signal in dark matter direct detection
• Direct Detection of Light "Ge-phobic" Exothermic Dark Matter
• Parametrizing the local dark matter speed distribution: a detailed analysis
• Form Factor Effects in the Direct Detection of Isospin-Violating Dark Matter
• Update on the Halo-Independent Comparison of Direct Dark Matter Detection Data
• Profile likelihood ratio analysis techniques for rare event signals

Cited by in corpus (40)

• Implications of unitarity and gauge invariance for simplified dark matter models
• A taste of dark matter: Flavour constraints on pseudoscalar mediators
• Dark Matter Searches at Colliders
• Simulated Milky Way analogues: implications for dark matter direct searches
• Simulated Milky Way analogues: implications for dark matter indirect searches
• On the Direct Detection of Dark Matter Annihilation
• On the direct detection of multi-component dark matter: sensitivity studies and parameter estimation
• Model-independent comparison of annual modulation and total rate with direct detection experiments
• Halo-independent tests of dark matter direct detection signals: local DM density, LHC, and thermal freeze-out
• Exploring light mediators with low-threshold direct detection experiments
• Reevaluation of spin-dependent WIMP-proton interactions as an explanation of the DAMA data
• Studying generalised dark matter interactions with extended halo-independent methods
• The Metal-Poor Stellar Halo in RAVE-TGAS and its Implications for the Velocity Distribution of Dark Matter
• What is the probability that direct detection experiments have observed Dark Matter?
• The Past and Future of Light Dark Matter Direct Detection
• Direct detection of non-galactic light dark matter
• Optimized velocity distributions for direct dark matter detection
• Bracketing the impact of astrophysical uncertainties on local dark matter searches
• A novel approach to derive halo-independent limits on dark matter properties
• Halo-independent determination of the unmodulated WIMP signal in DAMA: the isotropic case
• Halo-Independent Direct Detection Analyses Without Mass Assumptions
• Pinning down inelastic dark matter in the Sun and in direct detection
• Assessing Compatibility of Direct Detection Data: Halo-Independent Global Likelihood Analyses
• Halo-independent comparison of direct detection experiments in the effective theory of dark matter-nucleon interactions
• Extended Maximum Likelihood Halo-independent Analysis of Dark Matter Direct Detection Data
• Prospects for detection of target-dependent annual modulation in direct dark matter searches
• Halo-independent tests of dark matter annual modulation signals
• Discretising the velocity distribution for directional dark matter experiments
• Halo-Independent Analysis of Direct Dark Matter Detection Through Electron Scattering
• Updated Constraints on the Dark Matter Interpretation of CDMS-II-Si Data
• On the importance of direct detection combined limits for spin independent and spin dependent dark matter interactions
• Halo-Independent Dark Matter Electron Scattering Analysis with In-Medium Effects
• Halo-independent bounds on the non-relativistic effective theory of WIMP-nucleon scattering from direct detection and neutrino observations
• A halo-independent lower bound on the dark matter capture rate in the Sun from a direct detection signal
• Halo-independent bounds on Inelastic Dark Matter
• Sensitivity of WIMP bounds on the velocity distribution in the limit of a massless mediator
• Extracting Halo Independent Information from Dark Matter Electron Scattering Data
• Halo-Independent analysis of direct dark matter detection data for any WIMP interaction
• Explaining DAMA with proton-philic spin-dependent inelastic Dark Matter (pSIDM): a frequentist analysis
• Effects of Threshold Energy on Reconstructions of Properties of Low-Mass WIMPs in Direct Dark Matter Detection Experiments