Comment on the paper "Dark matter searches going bananas: the contribution of Potassium (and Chlorine) to the 3.5 keV line" by T. Jeltema and S. Profumo

Abstract

We revisit the X-ray spectrum of the central 14' of the Andromeda galaxy, discussed in our previous work [1402.4119]. Recently in [1408.1699] it was claimed that if one limits the analysis of the data to the interval 3-4 keV, the significance of the detection of the line at 3.53 keV drops below 2 sigma. In this note we show that such a restriction is not justified, as the continuum is well-modeled as a power law up to 8 keV, and parameters of the background model are well constrained over this larger interval of energies. This allows for a detection of the line at 3.53 keV with a statistical significance greater than ~3 sigma and for the identification of several known atomic lines in the energy range 3-4 keV. Limiting the analysis to the 3-4 keV interval results in increased uncertainty, thus decreasing the significance of the detection. We also argue that, with the M31 data included, a consistent interpretation of the 3.53 keV line as an atomic line of K XVIII in all studied objects is problematic.

arXiv comment3 pages, 2 figures

Cited by in corpus (24)

• A facility to Search for Hidden Particles at the CERN SPS: the SHiP physics case
• The Dawn of FIMP Dark Matter: A Review of Models and Constraints
• A White Paper on keV Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter
• Sterile neutrino dark matter: A tale of weak interactions in the strong coupling epoch
• SIMPle Dark Matter: Self-Interactions and keV Lines
• Where do the 3.5 keV photons come from? A morphological study of the Galactic Center and of Perseus
• 3.55 keV photon lines from axion to photon conversion in the Milky Way and M31
• Dodelson-Widrow Production of Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter with Non-Trivial Initial Abundance
• Connecting neutrino physics with dark matter
• Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter and Low Scale Leptogenesis from a Charged Scalar
• A 3.55 keV line from $\text{DM}\to a\to \gamma$: predictions for cool-core and non-cool-core clusters
• The role of the eROSITA all-sky survey in searches for sterile neutrino dark matter
• Scalar field dark matter with spontaneous symmetry breaking and the $3.5$ keV line
• A Couplet from Flavored Dark Matter
• Displaced Vertices from X-ray Lines
• ETHOS - an effective theory of structure formation: formation of the first haloes and their stars
• Local Group star formation in warm and self-interacting dark matter cosmologies
• Checking Potassium origin of new emission line at 3.5 keV with K XIX line complex at 3.7 keV
• Polarization of photons emitted by decaying dark matter
• The Supersymmetric R-Parity Violating Dine-Fischler-Srednicki-Zhitnitsky Axion Model
• Supersymmetric Higgs-portal and X-ray lines
• Can decaying sterile neutrinos account for all dark matter?
• Subdominant Dark Matter sterile neutrino resonant production in the light of Planck
• Cosmological constraints on sterile neutrino Dark Matter production mechanisms