A critique of recent semi-classical spin-half quantum plasma theories

Abstract

Certain recent semi-classical theories of spin-half quantum plasmas are examined with regard to their internal consistency, physical applicability and relevance to fusion, astrophysical and condensed matter plasmas. It is shown that the derivations and some of the results obtained in these theories are internally inconsistent and contradict well-established principles of quantum and statistical mechanics, especially in their treatment of fermions and spin. Claims of large semi-classical effects of spin magnetic moments that could dominate the plasma dynamics are found to be invalid both for single-particles and collectively. Larmor moments dominate at high temperature while spin moments cancel due to Pauli blocking at low temperatures. Explicit numerical estimates from a variety of plasmas are provided to demonstrate that spin effects are indeed much smaller than many neglected classical effects. The analysis presented suggests that the aforementioned `Spin Quantum Hydrodynamic' theories are not relevant to conventional laboratory or astrophysical plasmas.

arXiv comment11 pages, To appear in Contributions to Plasma Physics. Minor correction on page 3 to electron spin magnetic moment

References in corpus (10)

• Colloquium: Nonlinear collective interactions in quantum plasmas with degenerate electron fluids
• Dynamics of spin 1/2 quantum plasmas
• Novel Attractive Force Between Ions in Quantum Plasmas
• Scalar quantum kinetic theory for spin-1/2 particles: mean field theory
• Vortical Dynamics of spinning quantum plasmas - Helicity Conservation
• On "Novel attractive forces" between ions in quantum plasmas -- failure of linearized quantum hydrodynamics
• On quantum plasma: a plea for a common sense
• Comment on "Spin-Gradient-Driven Light Amplification in a Quantum Plasma"
• Quantum Hydrodynamics
• A critique of recent theories of spin half quantum plasmas

Cited by in corpus (6)

• Theoretical foundations of quantum hydrodynamics for plasmas
• Statically screened ion potential and Bohm potential in a quantum plasma
• Quantum hydrodynamics for plasmas -- a Thomas-Fermi theory perspective
• The ion potential in warm dense matter: wake effects due to streaming degenerate electrons
• Solid state plasmas
• Exchange Coulomb interaction in nanotubes: Dispersion of Langmuir waves