Quantum State Tomography of a Single Qubit: Comparison of Methods

Abstract

The tomographic reconstruction of the state of a quantum-mechanical system is an essential component in the development of quantum technologies. We present an overview of different tomographic methods for determining the quantum-mechanical density matrix of a single qubit: (scaled) direct inversion, maximum likelihood estimation (MLE), minimum Fisher information distance, and Bayesian mean estimation (BME). We discuss the different prior densities in the space of density matrices, on which both MLE and BME depend, as well as ways of including experimental errors and of estimating tomography errors. As a measure of the accuracy of these methods we average the trace distance between a given density matrix and the tomographic density matrices it can give rise to through experimental measurements. We find that the BME provides the most accurate estimate of the density matrix, and suggest using either the pure-state prior, if the system is known to be in a rather pure state, or the Bures prior if any state is possible. The MLE is found to be slightly less accurate. We comment on the extrapolation of these results to larger systems.

15 pages, 4 figures, 2 tables; replaced previous figure 5 by new table I. in Journal of Modern Optics, 2016

References in corpus (6)

• Experimental Quantum State Tomography of Optical Fields and Ultrafast Statistical Sampling
• Fisher Information and entanglement of non-Gaussian spin states
• Tight informationally complete quantum measurements
• Quantum metrology with a scanning probe atom interferometer
• Systematic errors in current quantum state tomography tools
• Optimal error regions for quantum state estimation

Cited by in corpus (27)

• Quantum metrology with nonclassical states of atomic ensembles
• Storage of photonic time-bin qubits for up to 20 ms in a rare-earth doped crystal
• Adversarial quantum circuit learning for pure state approximation
• Direct Reconstruction of the Quantum Density Matrix by Strong Measurements
• Design and experimental realization of an optimal scheme for teleportion of an $n$-qubit quantum state
• Temporal-mode measurement tomography of a quantum pulse gate
• Quantum Teleportation with Imperfect Quantum Dots
• Experimental Demonstration of Logical Magic State Distillation
• Nonlocality, steering and quantum state tomography in a single experiment
• Quantum state tomography of a single electron spin in diamond with Wigner reconstruction
• Quantum state matching of qubits via measurement-induced nonlinear transformations
• Robustness of quantum algorithms against coherent control errors
• Modular Software for Real-Time Quantum Control Systems
• Quantum computing through the lens of control: A tutorial introduction
• Quantum advantage using high-dimensional twisted photons as quantum finite automata
• Hierarchical Verification of Non-Gaussian Coherence in Bosonic Quantum States
• Functional Simulation of Real-Time Quantum Control Software
• Direct Measurement Methods of Density Matrix of an Entangled Quantum State
• Optical reconstruction of collective density matrix of qutrit
• Certified Randomness From Steering Using Sequential Measurements
• Security Analysis of Ensemble-Based Quantum Token Protocol Under Advanced Attacks
• An efficient adaptive MCMC algorithm for Pseudo-Bayesian quantum tomography
• Magic State Injection on IBM Quantum Processors Above the Distillation Threshold
• Quantum phase measurement for two-qubit states in an open waveguide
• A Cooper-pair beam splitter as a feasible source of entangled electrons
• Active Learning for Quantum Mechanical Measurements
• Single Qubit Multi-Party Transmission Using Universal Symmetric Quantum Cloning