Invention as a Combinatorial Process: Evidence from U.S. Patents

Abstract

Invention has been commonly conceptualized as a search over a space of combinatorial possibilities. Despite the existence of a rich literature, spanning a variety of disciplines, elaborating on the recombinant nature of invention, we lack a formal and quantitative characterization of the combinatorial process underpinning inventive activity. Here we utilize U.S. patent records dating from 1790 to 2010 to formally characterize the invention as a combinatorial process. To do this we treat patented inventions as carriers of technologies and avail ourselves of the elaborate system of technology codes used by the U.S. Patent Office to classify the technologies responsible for an invention's novelty. We find that the combinatorial inventive process exhibits an invariant rate of "exploitation" (refinements of existing combinations of technologies) and "exploration" (the development of new technological combinations). This combinatorial dynamic contrasts sharply with the creation of new technological capabilities -- the building blocks to be combined -- which has significantly slowed down. We also find that notwithstanding the very reduced rate at which new technologies are introduced, the generation of novel technological combinations engenders a practically infinite space of technological configurations.

arXiv commentPress embargo in place until publication

References in corpus (1)

• Topology and Evolution of Technology Innovation Networks

Cited by in corpus (38)

• International Research Collaboration: Novelty, Conventionality, and Atypicality in Knowledge Recombination
• Quantifying patterns of research interest evolution
• The systematic structure and predictability of urban business diversity
• Scientific elite revisited: Patterns of productivity, collaboration, authorship and impact
• Machine Culture
• Tracing technological development trajectories: A genetic knowledge persistence-based main path approach
• Technological novelty profile and invention's future impact
• Exploration and Exploitation of Victorian Science in Darwin's Reading Notebooks
• Technological improvement rate estimates for all technologies: Use of patent data and an extended domain description
• Grand challenges and emergent modes of convergence science
• Classifying Patents Based on their Semantic Content
• Long-run dynamics of the U.S. patent classification system
• Shorter Distances between Papers over Time are Due to More Cross-Field References and Increased Citation Rate to Higher Impact Papers
• Temporal Motifs in Patent Opposition and Collaboration Networks
• Biomedical Convergence Facilitated by the Emergence of Technological and Informatic Capabilities
• Science and Technology Advance through Surprise
• Influence of technological innovations on industrial production: A motif analysis on the multilayer network
• Destructive Creation, Creative Destruction, and the Paradox of Innovation Science
• Evolution of biomedical innovation quantified via billions of distinct article-level MeSH keyword combinations
• Novelty and Foreseeing Research Trends; The Case of Astrophysics and Astronomy
• Scaling Laws for Function Diversity and Specialization Across Socioeconomic and Biological Complex Systems
• Mutual benefits of social learning and algorithmic mediation for cumulative culture
• On the dual nature of adoption processes in complex networks
• Lévy Flights of the Collective Imagination
• The Atlas for the Aspiring Network Scientist
• The mathematical structure of innovation
• Emergence of innovations in networked populations with reputation-driven interactions
• The TAP equation: evaluating combinatorial innovation in Biocosmology
• Time-Dependent Urn Models reproduce the full spectrum of novelties discovery
• On singularities in combination-driven models of technological innovation
• Modelling Singularities in Macroevolution
• Quantitative identification of technological discontinuities using simulation modeling
• Innovation and informal knowledge exchanges between firms
• Exploring the relationship between technological improvement and innovation diffusion: An empirical test
• Big Data driven Product Design: A Survey
• Inter-organisational patent opposition network: How companies form adversarial relationships
• Topic Modeling the Reading and Writing Behavior of Information Foragers
• Inequality in the use frequency of patent technology codes