The Compatibility of Flare Temperatures Observed with AIA, GOES, and RHESSI

Abstract

We test the compatibility and biases of multi-thermal flare DEM (differential emission measure) peak temperatures determined with AIA with those determined by GOES and RHESSI using the isothermal assumption. In a set of 149 M- and X-class flares observed during the first two years of the SDO mission, AIA finds DEM peak temperatures at the time of the peak GOES 1-8 A flux to have an average of Tp = 12.0+/-2.9 MK and Gaussian DEM widths of log10(sigma_T) = 0.50+/-0.13. From GOES observations of the same 149 events, a mean temperature of Tp = 15.6+/-2.4 MK is inferred, which is systematically higher by a factor of TGOES/TAIA = 1.4+/-0.4. We demonstrate that this discrepancy results from the isothermal assumption in the inversion of the GOES filter ratio. From isothermal fits to photon spectra at energies of E ~ 6-12 keV of 61 of these events, RHESSI finds the temperature to be higher still by a factor of TRHESSI/TAIA = 1.9+/-1.0. We find that this is partly a consequence of the isothermal assumption. However, RHESSI is not sensitive to the low-temperature range of the DEM peak, and thus RHESSI samples only the high-temperature tail of the DEM function. This can also contribute to the discrepancy between AIA and RHESSI temperatures. The higher flare temperatures found by GOES and RHESSI imply correspondingly lower emission measures. We conclude that self-consistent flare DEM temperatures and emission measures require simultaneous fitting of EUV (AIA) and soft X-ray (GOES and RHESSI) fluxes.

Accepted by Solar Physics Journal

References in corpus (6)

• RHESSI Microflare Statistics II. X-ray Imaging, Spectroscopy & Energy Distributions
• RHESSI Line and Continuum Observations of Super-hot Flare Plasma
• Scaling laws of solar and stellar flares
• The Thermal Properties of Solar Flares Over Three Solar Cycles Using GOES X-ray Observations
• Multi-wavelength observations and modelling of a canonical solar flare
• Decay Phase Cooling and Inferred Heating of M- and X-class Solar Flares

Cited by in corpus (20)

• Global Energetics of Solar Flares: V. Energy Closure in Flares and Coronal Mass Ejections
• Slow-Mode Magnetoacoustic Waves in Coronal Loops
• Global Energetics of Solar Flares: II. Thermal Energies
• Global Energetics of Solar Flares: III. Non thermal Energies
• Accelerated electrons observed down to <7 keV in a NuSTAR solar microflare
• Thermal-nonthermal energy partition in solar flares derived from X-ray, EUV, and bolometric observations
• Constraining Solar Flare Differential Emission Measures with EVE and RHESSI
• Benchmark Test of Differential Emission Measure Codes and Multi-Thermal Energies in Solar Active Regions
• Investigating the differential emission measure and energetics of microflares with combined SDO/AIA and RHESSI observations
• Global Energetics of Solar Flares: IV. Coronal Mass Ejection Energetics
• STIX X-ray microflare observations during the Solar Orbiter commissioning phase
• Solar Flare Arcade Modelling: Bridging the gap from 1D to 3D Simulations of Optically Thin Radiation
• Role of Compressive Viscosity and Thermal Conductivity on the Damping of Slow Waves in the Coronal Loops With and Without Heating-Cooling Imbalance
• Impulsive Heating of Solar Flare Ribbons Above 10 MK
• Statistical Properties of Soft X-ray emission of solar flares
• Where is the chromospheric response to conductive energy input from a hot pre-flare coronal loop?
• Global Energetics of Solar Flares. XI. Flare Magnitude Predictions of the GOES-Class
• Center-to-Limb Variability of Hot Coronal EUV Emissions During Solar Flares
• Non-thermal electron energization during the impulsive phase of an X9.3 flare revealed by Insight-HXMT
• X-ray fine structure of a limb solar flare revealed by Insight-HXMT, RHESSI and Fermi