Lagrangian or Eulerian; Real or Fourier? Not All Approaches to Large-Scale Structure Are Created Equal

Abstract

We present a pedagogical systematic investigation of the accuracy of Eulerian and Lagrangian perturbation theories of large-scale structure. We show that significant differences exist between them especially when trying to model the Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO). We find that the best available model of the BAO in real space is the Zel'dovich Approximation (ZA), giving an accuracy of <~3% at redshift of z=0 in modelling the matter 2-pt function around the acoustic peak. All corrections to the ZA around the BAO scale are perfectly perturbative in real space. Any attempt to achieve better precision requires calibrating the theory to simulations because of the need to renormalize those corrections. In contrast, theories which do not fully preserve the ZA as their solution, receive O(1) corrections around the acoustic peak in real space at z=0, and are thus of suspicious convergence at low redshift around the BAO. As an example, we find that a similar accuracy of 3% for the acoustic peak is achieved by Eulerian Standard Perturbation Theory (SPT) at linear order only at z~4. Thus even when SPT is perturbative, one needs to include loop corrections for z<~4 in real space. In Fourier space, all models perform similarly, and are controlled by the overdensity amplitude, thus recovering standard results. However, that comes at a price. Real space cleanly separates the BAO signal from non-linear dynamics. In contrast, Fourier space mixes signal from short mildly non-linear scales with the linear signal from the BAO to the level that non-linear contributions from short scales dominate. Therefore, one has little hope in constructing a systematic theory for the BAO in Fourier space.

35 pages, 11 figures; v2: fixing technical issue with fig. 1, which some people have

References in corpus (8)

• Improving Cosmological Distance Measurements by Reconstruction of the Baryon Acoustic Peak
• Resumming Cosmological Perturbations via the Lagrangian Picture: One-loop Results in Real Space and in Redshift Space
• Nonlinear Evolution of Baryon Acoustic Oscillations
• A critical look at cosmological perturbation theory techniques
• The Lagrangian-space Effective Field Theory of Large Scale Structures
• Multi-Point Propagators in Cosmological Gravitational Instability
• Reconstructing Baryon Oscillations: A Lagrangian Theory Perspective
• N-point Statistics of Large-Scale Structure in the Zel'dovich Approximation

Cited by in corpus (43)

• The Effective Field Theorist's Approach to Gravitational Dynamics
• The IR-resummed Effective Field Theory of Large Scale Structures
• A Lagrangian effective field theory
• Perturbation theory, effective field theory, and oscillations in the power spectrum
• The Zeldovich approximation
• Reconstruction within the Zeldovich approximation
• On the IR-Resummation in the EFTofLSS
• Lagrangian perturbation theory at one loop order: successes, failures, and improvements
• Cosmological perturbation theory in 1+1 dimensions
• Exploring redshift-space distortions in large-scale structure
• Tests of redshift-space distortions models in configuration space for the analysis of the BOSS final data release
• An analytic implementation of the IR-resummation for the BAO peak
• An $n$-th order Lagrangian Forward Model for Large-Scale Structure
• GridSPT: Grid-based calculation for perturbation theory of large-scale structure
• Matter bispectrum of large-scale structure: Three-dimensional comparison between theoretical models and numerical simulations
• Lagrangian perturbation theory for modified gravity
• Halo Zeldovich model and perturbation theory: dark matter power spectrum and correlation function
• Measuring cosmic velocities with 21cm intensity mapping and galaxy redshift survey cross-correlation dipoles
• Nonlinear reconstruction
• Fast computation of non-linear power spectrum in cosmologies with massive neutrinos
• Clustering in Massive Neutrino Cosmologies via Eulerian Perturbation Theory
• Edgeworth streaming model for redshift space distortions
• sCOLA: The N-body COLA Method Extended to the Spatial Domain
• Accurate predictions from small boxes: variance suppression via the Zel'dovich approximation
• Nonlinear evolution of initially biased tracers in modified gravity
• Cosmology inference at the field level from biased tracers in redshift-space
• Understanding redshift space distortions in density-weighted peculiar velocity
• Nonlinear reconstruction of redshift space distortions
• Convolution Lagrangian perturbation theory for biased tracers beyond general relativity
• Violation of the consistency relations for large-scale structure with dark energy
• N-point Statistics of Large-Scale Structure in the Zel'dovich Approximation
• Screenings in Modified Gravity: a perturbative approach
• Unequal time correlators and the Zeldovich approximation
• Marked correlation functions in perturbation theory
• Grid-based calculations of redshift-space matter fluctuations from perturbation theory: UV sensitivity and convergence at the field level
• Coarse-grained cosmological perturbation theory: stirring up the dust model
• Nonlinear Behavior of Baryon Acoustic Oscillations in Redshift Space from the Zel'dovich Approximation
• Choose to smooth: Gaussian streaming with the truncated Zel'dovich approximation
• Impact of cosmological signatures in two-point statistics beyond the linear regime
• Approximate methods for the generation of dark matter halo catalogs in the age of precision cosmology
• Projection of the gravitational dynamics on a subspace of probability distributions: curl-free Gaussian ansatz
• Lagrangian-space Gaussian ansatz for the matter redshift-space power spectrum and correlation function
• Systematic treatment of non-linear effects in Baryon Acoustic Oscillations