Heisenberg uncertainty for qubit measurements
arXiv:1311.0837 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevA.89.012129
Abstract
Reports on experiments recently performed in Vienna [Erhard et al, Nature Phys. 8, 185 (2012)] and Toronto [Rozema et al, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 100404 (2012)] include claims of a violation of Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation. In contrast, we have presented and proven a Heisenberg-type relation for joint measurements of position and momentum [Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 160405 (2013)]. To resolve the apparent conflict, we formulate here a new general trade-off relation for errors in qubit measurements, using the same concepts as we did in the position-momentum case. We show that the combined errors in an approximate joint measurement of a pair of +/-1 valued observables A,B are tightly bounded from below by a quantity that measures the degree of incompatibility of A and B. The claim of a violation of Heisenberg is shown to fail as it is based on unsuitable measures of error and disturbance. Finally we show how the experiments mentioned may directly be used to test our error inequality.
arXiv commentVersion 3 contains further clarifications in our argument refuting the alleged violation of Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation. Some new material added on the connection between preparation uncertainty and approximation error relations
References in corpus (13)
- The elusive Heisenberg limit in quantum enhanced metrology
- Violation of Heisenberg's Measurement-Disturbance Relationship by Weak Measurements
- Experimental demonstration of a universally valid error-disturbance uncertainty relation in spin-measurements
- Uncertainty Relations for Noise and Disturbance in Generalized Quantum Measurements
- Proof of Heisenberg's error-disturbance relation
- How well can one jointly measure two incompatible observables on a given quantum state?
- Violation of Heisenberg's error-disturbance uncertainty relation in neutron spin measurements
- Measuring measurement--disturbance relationships with weak values
- Experimental test of universal complementarity relations
- Near Heisenberg limited atomic clocks in the presence of decoherence
- Noise and disturbance in quantum mechanics
- Sequential measurement of conjugate variables as an alternative quantum state tomography
- A universally valid Heisenberg uncertainty relation
Cited by in corpus (77)
- Entropic Uncertainty Relations and their Applications
- Stronger uncertainty relations for the sum of variances
- Quantum root-mean-square error and measurement uncertainty relations
- One-to-one mapping between steering and joint measurability problems
- Incompatible measurements in quantum information science
- Natural Framework for Device-Independent Quantification of Quantum Steerability, Measurement Incompatibility, and Self-Testing
- Measurement uncertainty relations
- Uncertainty Relations for Angular Momentum
- Continuous-variable entropic uncertainty relations
- Kirkwood-Dirac quasiprobability approach to the statistics of incompatible observables
- Experimental characterisation of unsharp qubit observables and sequential measurement incompatibility via quantum random access codes
- Experimental test of Heisenberg's measurement uncertainty relation based on statistical distances
- Rényi entropy uncertainty relation for successive projective measurements
- Experimental Demonstration of Uncertainty Relations for the Triple Components of Angular Momentum
- Tight state-independent uncertainty relations for qubits
- Operational constraints on state-dependent formulations of quantum error-disturbance trade-off relations
- Tests of Fundamental Quantum Mechanics and Dark Interactions with Low Energy Neutrons -- Extended Version
- On the Role of Information Theoretic Uncertainty Relations in Quantum Theory
- Weighted Uncertainty Relations
- Entropic Energy-Time Uncertainty Relation
- Deriving tight error-trade-off relations for approximate joint measurements of incompatible quantum observables
- State-Dependent Approach to Entropic Measurement-Disturbance Relations
- Implications and applications of the variance-based uncertainty equalities
- Measurement uncertainty relations for discrete observables: Relative entropy formulation
- State-independent preparation uncertainty relations
- Uncertainty and Trade-offs in Quantum Multiparameter Estimation
- Error-Disturbance Trade-off in Sequential Quantum Measurements
- Uncertainty relations from graph theory
- Improving sum uncertainty relations with the quantum Fisher information
- Interferometry of quantum correlation functions to access quasiprobability distribution of work
- Simultaneous measurement of two non-commuting quantum variables: Solution of a dynamical model
- Disturbance in weak measurements and the difference between quantum and classical weak values
- Direct tests of measurement uncertainty relations: what it takes
- Measurement Uncertainty for Finite Quantum Observables
- Uncertainties of genuinely incompatible triple measurements based on statistical distance
- Geometry of Uncertainty Relations for Linear Combinations of Position and Momentum
- Measurement uncertainty relations: characterising optimal error bounds for qubits
- Uncertainty relations: An operational approach to the error-disturbance tradeoff
- Complementary observables in quantum mechanics
- Incompatibility of Observables as State-Independent Bound of Uncertainty Relations
- Universality in Uncertainty Relations for a Quantum Particle
- Necessary and sufficient condition for joint measurability
- Optimal joint measurements of complementary observables by a single trapped ion
- Quantum measurement and uncertainty relations in photon polarization
- Experimental Test of Tight State-Independent Preparation Uncertainty Relations for Qubits
- Entropic uncertainty relations for successive generalized measurements
- Measures of disturbance and incompatibility for quantum measurements
- Uncertainty relation based on Wigner-Yanase-Dyson skew information with quantum memory
- Heisenberg's error-disturbance relations: a joint measurement-based experimental test
- Ascertaining the Uncertainty Relations via Quantum Correlations
- Stronger Error Disturbance Relations for Incompatible Quantum Measurements
- Self-testing of multiple unsharpness parameters through sequential violations of non-contextual inequality
- Experimental evaluation of the non-classical relation between measurement errors using entangled photon pairs as a probe
- Optimal covariant quantum measurements
- On Quantum Uncertainty Relations and Uncertainty Regions
- Inferred-variance uncertainty relations in the presence of quantum entanglement
- Measurement Uncertainty: Reply to Critics
- Neutron optical test of completeness of quantum root-mean-square errors
- Retrievability of information in quantum and realistic hidden variable theories
- Quantum Uncertainty and Error-Disturbance Tradeoff
- Optimizing incompatible triple quantum measurements
- Error-disturbance uncertainty relations in Faraday measurements
- A combined-probability space and (un)certainty relations for a finite-level quantum system
- Simplifying measurement uncertainty with quantum symmetries
- Stronger sum uncertainty relations for non-Hermitian operators
- Tight qubit uncertainty relations studied through weak values in neutron interferometry
- Entropic Approach to Error-Disturbance Tradeoff in Quantum Measurements
- A Generalization of the Functional Calculus of Observables and Notion of Joint Measurability to the Case of Non-commuting Observables
- Entropic Uncertainty Principle and Information Exclusion Principle for multiple measurements in the presence of quantum memory
- Sum uncertainty relations for arbitrary incompatible observables
- Uncertainty-disturbance relations and applications
- Entropic measurement uncertainty relations for all the infinite components of a spin vector
- Linear position measurements with minimum error-disturbance in each minimum uncertainty state
- Single-qubit measurement of Heisenberg uncertainty lower bounds for three incompatible observables
- Experimental test of error-disturbance uncertainty relation with continuous variables
- Optimal simultaneous measurements of incompatible observables of a single photon
- Robust device-independent characterization of sharpness and incompatibility of unsharp instruments