First direct comparison of non-disrupting neutron star-black hole and binary black hole merger simulations
arXiv:1307.7685 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.88.064017
Abstract
We present the first direct comparison of numerical simulations of neutron star-black hole and black hole-black hole mergers in full general relativity. We focus on a configuration with non spinning objects and within the most likely range of mass ratio for neutron star-black hole systems (q=6). In this region of the parameter space, the neutron star is not tidally disrupted prior to merger, and we show that the two types of mergers appear remarkably similar. The effect of the presence of a neutron star on the gravitational wave signal is not only undetectable by the next generation of gravitational wave detectors, but also too small to be measured in the numerical simulations: even the plunge, merger and ringdown signals appear in perfect agreement for both types of binaries. The characteristics of the post-merger remnants are equally similar, with the masses of the final black holes agreeing within dM< 5 10^{-4}M_BH and their spins within da< 10^{-3}M_BH. The rate of periastron advance in the mixed binary agrees with previously published binary black hole results, and we use the inspiral waveforms to place constraints on the accuracy of our numerical simulations independent of algorithmic choices made for each type of binary. Overall, our results indicate that non-disrupting neutron star-black hole mergers are exceptionally well modeled by black hole-black hole mergers, and that given the absence of mass ejection, accretion disk formation, or differences in the gravitational wave signals, only electromagnetic precursors could prove the presence of a neutron star in low-spin systems of total mass ~10Msun, at least until the advent of gravitational wave detectors with a sensitivity comparable to that of the proposed Einstein Telescope.
arXiv comment13 pages, 9 figures
References in corpus (39)
- Tidal Love numbers of neutron stars
- Constraining neutron star tidal Love numbers with gravitational wave detectors
- Tidal deformability of neutron stars with realistic equations of state and their gravitational wave signatures in binary inspiral
- The Equation of State from Observed Masses and Radii of Neutron Stars
- Detector configuration of KAGRA - the Japanese cryogenic gravitational-wave detector
- The Black Hole Mass Distribution in the Galaxy
- What is the Most Promising Electromagnetic Counterpart of a Neutron Star Binary Merger?
- Measurability of the tidal polarizability of neutron stars in late-inspiral gravitational-wave signals
- Numerical Relativity Using a Generalized Harmonic Decomposition
- Model Waveform Accuracy Standards for Gravitational Wave Data Analysis
- Post-1-Newtonian tidal effects in the gravitational waveform from binary inspirals
- A New Generalized Harmonic Evolution System
- Matter effects on binary neutron star waveforms
- Effective One Body description of tidal effects in inspiralling compact binaries
- Mass Measurements of Black Holes in X-Ray Transients: Is There a Mass Gap?
- Resonant Shattering of Neutron Star Crusts
- A multidomain spectral method for solving elliptic equations
- Black Hole-Neutron Star Mergers: Disk Mass Predictions
- Measurement of the Radius of Neutron Stars with High S/N Quiescent Low-mass X-ray Binaries in Globular Clusters
- Identifying Elusive Electromagnetic Counterparts to Gravitational Wave Mergers: an end-to-end simulation
- Reducing orbital eccentricity in binary black hole simulations
- Harmonic coordinate method for simulating generic singularities
- Simulations of Binary Black Hole Mergers Using Spectral Methods
- Gravitational self-force on a particle in eccentric orbit around a Schwarzschild black hole
- Evolving black hole-neutron star binaries in general relativity using pseudospectral and finite difference methods
- Black hole-neutron star mergers at realistic mass ratios: Equation of state and spin orientation effects
- Periastron Advance in Black-Hole Binaries
- Gravitational and electromagnetic outputs from binary neutron star mergers
- Extracting equation of state parameters from black hole-neutron star mergers. I. Nonspinning black holes
- Precession effect of the gravitational self-force in a Schwarzschild spacetime and the effective one-body formalism
- When can gravitational-wave observations distinguish between black holes and neutron stars?
- Extrapolating gravitational-wave data from numerical simulations
- Simulations of non-equal mass black hole binaries with spectral methods
- Initial data for black hole-neutron star binaries: a flexible, high-accuracy spectral method
- Dynamical Excision Boundaries in Spectral Evolutions of Binary Black Hole Spacetimes
- Numerical relativity confronts compact neutron star binaries: a review and status report
- General relativistic simulations of binary black hole-neutron stars: Precursor electromagnetic signals
- Black hole-neutron star mergers for 10 solar mass black holes
- Suitability of hybrid gravitational waveforms for unequal-mass binaries
Cited by in corpus (60)
- GW190814: Gravitational Waves from the Coalescence of a 23 M Black Hole with a 2.6 M Compact Object
- Observation of gravitational waves from two neutron star-black hole coalescences
- A catalog of 174 binary black-hole simulations for gravitational-wave astronomy
- Neutron star tidal deformability and equation of state constraints
- Effects of the microphysical Equation of State in the mergers of magnetized Neutron Stars With Neutrino Cooling
- Observation of Gravitational Waves from the Coalescence of a Compact Object and a Neutron Star
- GWTC-2.1: Deep Extended Catalog of Compact Binary Coalescences Observed by LIGO and Virgo During the First Half of the Third Observing Run
- Dynamical mass ejection from black hole-neutron star binaries
- Neutron star-black hole mergers with a nuclear equation of state and neutrino cooling: Dependence in the binary parameters
- Extracting equation of state parameters from black hole-neutron star mergers: aligned-spin black holes and a preliminary waveform model
- Numerical Relativity and Astrophysics
- Mergers of binary neutron stars with realistic spin
- Modeling the gravitational wave signature of neutron star black hole coalescences: PhenomNSBH
- Numerical relativity reaching into post-Newtonian territory: a compact-object binary simulation spanning 350 gravitational-wave cycles
- An aligned-spin neutron-star--black-hole waveform model based on the effective-one-body approach and numerical-relativity simulations
- Fast Radio Bursts and Radio Transients from Black Hole Batteries
- Investigating the effect of precession on searches for neutron-star-black-hole binaries with Advanced LIGO
- Light-curve models of black hole - neutron star mergers: steps towards a multi-messenger parameter estimation
- Coalescence of black hole--neutron star binaries
- First Law of Mechanics for Compact Binaries on Eccentric Orbits
- Periastron Advance in Spinning Black Hole Binaries: Gravitational Self-Force from Numerical Relativity
- Reducing orbital eccentricity in initial data of binary neutron stars
- Electromagnetic counterparts of black hole-neutron star mergers: dependence on the neutron star properties
- Aligned spin neutron star-black hole mergers: a gravitational waveform amplitude model
- A brief overview of black hole-neutron star mergers
- Can a black hole-neutron star merger explain GW170817, AT2017gfo, GRB170817A?
- Accuracy of gravitational waveform models for observing neutron-star--black-hole binaries in Advanced LIGO
- Targeted large mass ratio numerical relativity surrogate waveform model for GW190814
- Measuring precession in asymmetric compact binaries
- Improvements to the construction of binary black hole initial data
- A new scheme for matching general relativistic ideal magnetohydrodynamics to its force-free limit
- On accretion disks formed in MHD simulations of black hole-neutron star mergers with accurate microphysics
- Measuring neutron star tidal deformability with Advanced LIGO: a Bayesian analysis of neutron star - black hole binary observations
- Physics in Very Strong Magnetic Fields: Introduction and Overview
- Neutron stars and the dense matter equation of state: from microscopic theory to macroscopic observations
- Nonspinning black hole-neutron star mergers: a model for the amplitude of gravitational waveforms
- Gravitational waveforms for neutron star binaries from binary black hole simulations
- Leveraging gravitational-wave memory to distinguish neutron star--black hole binaries from black hole binaries
- The Black Hole Remnant of Black Hole-Neutron Star Coalescing Binaries
- Numerical-Relativity-Informed Effective-One-Body model for Black-Hole-Neutron-Star Mergers with Higher Modes and Spin Precession
- Statistical and systematic uncertainties in extracting the source properties of neutron star - black hole binaries with gravitational waves
- Distinguishing the nature of ''ambiguous'' merging systems hosting a neutron star: GW190425 in low-latency
- High-accuracy waveforms for black hole-neutron star systems with spinning black holes
- Black hole remnant of black hole-neutron star coalescing binaries with arbitrary black hole spin
- Gravitational waveforms of binary neutron star inspirals using post-Newtonian tidal splicing
- Initial data for black hole-neutron star binaries, with rotating stars
- Systematic effects from black hole-neutron star waveform model uncertainties on the neutron star equation of state
- Black hole-neutron star mergers with massive neutron stars in numerical relativity
- Nuclear physics with gravitational waves from neutron stars disrupted by black holes
- Radius and equation of state constraints from massive neutron stars and GW190814
- Black Hole - Neutron Star Binary Mergers: The Imprint of Tidal Deformations and Debris
- Black Hole-Neutron Star Binaries near Neutron Star Disruption Limit in the Mass Regime of Event GW230529
- Reducing orbital eccentricity in initial data of black hole--neutron star binaries in the puncture framework
- Testing modified gravity with the eccentric neutron star--black hole merger GW200105
- Connecting Numerical Relativity and Data Analysis of Gravitational Wave Detectors
- Tidal deformations of compact objects and gravitational wave emission
- Challenging a binary neutron star merger interpretation of GW230529
- Measuring Hubble Constant with Dark Neutron Star-Black Hole Mergers
- Classical gravitational scattering in the relativistic Kepler problem
- Uncertainty in predicting the stochastic gravitational wave background from compact binary coalescences