Comments on "An Update of the HLS Estimate of the Muon g-2"by M.Benayoun {\it et al.}, arXiv:1210.7184v3
arXiv:1306.6374 · doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-013-2597-1
Abstract
In a recent paper \cite{benayoun} M.Benayoun {\it et al.} use a specific model to compare results on the existing data for the cross section of the process and state conclusions about the inconsistency of the BABAR results with those from the other experiments. We show that a direct model-independent comparison of the data at hand contradicts this claim. Clear discrepancies with the results of Ref. \cite{benayoun} are pointed out. As a consequence we do not believe that the lower value and the smaller uncertainty obtained for the prediction of the muon magnetic anomaly are reliable results.
arXiv comment7 pages,2 figures, comments
References in corpus (20)
- Final Report of the Muon E821 Anomalous Magnetic Moment Measurement at BNL
- Reevaluation of the Hadronic Contributions to the Muon g-2 and to alpha(MZ)
- (g-2)_mu and alpha(M_Z^2) re-evaluated using new precise data
- Updated Estimate of the Muon Magnetic Moment Using Revised Results from e+e- Annihilation
- Precise measurement of the e+ e- to pi+ pi- (gamma) cross section with the Initial State Radiation method at BABAR
- Reanalysis of Hadronic Cross Section Measurements at CMD-2
- Precise Measurement of the e+ e- --> pi+ pi- (gamma) Cross Section with the Initial-State Radiation Method at BABAR
- High-statistics measurement of the pion form factor in the rho-meson energy range with the CMD-2 detector
- rho^0-gamma mixing in the neutral channel pion form factor |F_pi|^2 and its role in comparing e^+ e^- with tau spectral functions
- Confronting Spectral Functions from e+e- Annihilation and tau Decays: Consequences for the Muon Magnetic Moment
- Update of the e^+e^-\toπ^+π^- cross section measured by SND detector in the energy region 400<\sqrt{s}<1000 MeV
- High-Statistics Study of the tau^- -> pi^- pi^0 nu_tau Decay
- Measurement of sigma(e+ e- -> pi+ pi-) from threshold to 0.85 GeV^2 using Initial State Radiation with the KLOE detector
- Measurement of and the dipion contribution to the muon anomaly with the KLOE detector
- The Discrepancy Between tau and e+e- Spectral Functions Revisited and the Consequences for the Muon Magnetic Anomaly
- An Update of the HLS Estimate of the Muon g-2
- Isospin Violation and the Magnetic Moment of the Muon
- Radiative tau decay and the magnetic moment of the muon
- Long-distance radiative corrections to the di-pion tau lepton decay
- Model-dependent radiative corrections to tau- -> pi- pi0 nu revisited