Tunneling time problem: At the intersection of quantum mechanics, classical probability theory and special relativity
arXiv:1303.6181
Abstract
After the review by Hauge and Stovneng the old question of "How long does it take to tunnel through the barrier?" has not still lost its relevance. As before, there is no clear answer to this question even for the one-dimensional completed scattering (OCS). In this paper we show that this seemingly simple question stands alongside with such fundamental problems of quantum mechanics (QM) as the Schrodinger's-cat and and EPR-Bohm paradoxes. Their common feature is that the states of a scattered particle, a radioactive atom and electron EPR-pair represent pure {\it micro-cat} states. It is widely accepted that the EPR-Bohm paradox implies the non-existence of local hidden variables (LHVs), the cat paradox represents a macro-objectification problem and the tunneling time is an observer-dependent quantity whose definitions must be 'operational'. At the same time, according to the probabilistic approach (Accardi, Khrennikov, Philipp, Hess {\it et al.}) to Bell's inequality that underlies the EPR-Bohm experiments, its experimental violation means simply that it contains probability distributions associated with mutually incompatible statistical data. We argue that this approach must be extended onto micro-cat states because they describe, too, mutually incompatible statistical data. The current practice to interpret the squared modulus of a micro-cat state as the probability density should be recognized as erroneous. It is this practice that makes QM incompatible with classical physical theories and, thereby, makes the micro-world 'unspeakable'. The known 'operational' tunneling-time concepts, elaborated in line with this practice, are logically inconsistent. We argue that the TTP and the cat paradox must be solved at the level of single electrons and atoms, without resorting to environment and measurement contexts. We present a new model of the OCS and solve the TTP on its basis.
arXiv comment30 pages, 2 figures; thoroughly rewritten text
References in corpus (20)
- Decoherence, the measurement problem, and interpretations of quantum mechanics
- How much time does a tunneling particle spend in the barrier region?
- Direct measurement of superluminal group velocity and of signal velocity in an optical fiber
- Partial Densities of States, Scattering Matrices, and Green's Functions
- New wine in old bottles: Quantum measurement - direct, indirect, weak - with some applications
- Quantum tunneling time
- The Bell Theorem as a Special Case of a Theorem of Bass
- Tunneling Violates Special Relativity
- Basics of Superluminal Signals
- What is a quantum-mechanical 'weak value' the value of?
- Towards Quantum Information Theory in Space and Time
- Advanced Detection of Information in Optical Pulses with Negative Group Velocity
- Salecker-Wigner-Peres clock and average tunneling times
- Unconventional approach to orbital-free density functional theory derived from a model of extended electrons
- On causality, apparent 'superluminality' and reshaping in barrier penetration
- Interference mechanism of seemingly superluminal tunnelling
- The Local Larmor Clock, Partial Densities of States, and Mesoscopic Physics
- Two-slit Experiment And Wave-Particle Duality
- Larmor times for transmission and reflection
- Wave functions and tunneling times for one-dimensional transmission and reflection