Assessing the influence of the solar orbit on terrestrial biodiversity

Abstract

The terrestrial fossil record shows a significant variation in the extinction and origination rates of species during the past half billion years. Numerous studies have claimed an association between this variation and the motion of the Sun around the Galaxy, invoking the modulation of cosmic rays, gamma rays and comet impact frequency as a cause of this biodiversity variation. However, some of these studies exhibit methodological problems, or were based on coarse assumptions (such as a strict periodicity of the solar orbit). Here we investigate this link in more detail, using a model of the Galaxy to reconstruct the solar orbit and thus a predictive model of the temporal variation of the extinction rate due to astronomical mechanisms. We compare these predictions as well as those of various reference models with paleontological data. Our approach involves Bayesian model comparison, which takes into account the uncertainties in the paleontological data as well as the distribution of solar orbits consistent with the uncertainties in the astronomical data. We find that various versions of the orbital model are not favored beyond simpler reference models. In particular, the distribution of mass extinction events can be explained just as well by a uniform random distribution as by any other model tested. Although our negative results on the orbital model are robust to changes in the Galaxy model, the Sun's coordinates and the errors in the data, we also find that it would be very difficult to positively identify the orbital model even if it were the true one. (In contrast, we do find evidence against simpler periodic models.) Thus while we cannot rule out there being some connection between solar motion and biodiversity variations on the Earth, we conclude that it is difficult to give convincing positive conclusions of such a connection using current data.

22 pages, 12 figures

References in corpus (4)

• Cosmic Rays and Terrestrial Life: A Brief Review
• A ubiquitous ~62 Myr periodic fluctuation superimposed on general trends in fossil biodiversity: II, Evolutionary dynamics associated with periodic fluctuation in marine diversity
• A Bayesian method for the analysis of deterministic and stochastic time series
• A history of the gamma-ray burst flux at the Earth from Galactic globular clusters

Cited by in corpus (12)

• Finding the imprints of stellar encounters in long period comets
• Agatha: disentangling periodic signals from correlated noise in a periodogram framework
• A Goldilocks principle for modeling radial velocity noise
• Radial Migration of the Sun in the Milky Way: a Statistical Study
• Exploring the role of the Sun's motion in terrestrial comet impacts
• Do Periodicities in Extinction -- with Possible Astronomical Connections -- Survive a Revision of the Geological Timescale?
• Gaia reference frame amid quasar variability and proper motion patterns in the data
• Was Proxima captured by alpha Centauri A and B?
• Stellar encounters with giant molecular clouds
• Understanding Fomalhaut as a Cooper pair
• Water transport throughout the TRAPPIST-1 system: the role of planetesimals
• Probabilistic galactic dynamics I - the Sun and GJ 710 with Monte Carlo, linearised and unscented treatments