Temporal motifs reveal homophily, gender-specific patterns and group talk in mobile communication networks
arXiv:1302.2563 · doi:10.1073/pnas.1307941110
Abstract
Electronic communication records provide detailed information about temporal aspects of human interaction. Previous studies have shown that individuals' communication patterns have complex temporal structure, and that this structure has system-wide effects. In this paper we use mobile phone records to show that interaction patterns involving multiple individuals have non-trivial temporal structure that cannot be deduced from a network presentation where only interaction frequencies are taken into account. We apply a recently introduced method, temporal motifs, to identify interaction patterns in a temporal network where nodes have additional attributes such as gender and age. We then develop a null model that allows identifying differences between various types of nodes so that these differences are independent of the network based on interaction frequencies. We find gender-related differences in communication patters, and show the existence of temporal homophily, the tendency of similar individuals to participate in interaction patterns beyond what would be expected on the basis of the network structure alone. We also show that temporal patterns differ between dense and sparse parts of the network. Because this result is independent of edge weights, it can be considered as an extension of Granovetter's hypothesis to temporal networks.
8 pages, 3 figures (SI: 20 pages, 18 figures)
References in corpus (5)
- Uncovering the overlapping community structure of complex networks in nature and society
- Structure and tie strengths in mobile communication networks
- Small But Slow World: How Network Topology and Burstiness Slow Down Spreading
- A Poissonian explanation for heavy-tails in e-mail communication
- Calling patterns in human communication dynamics
Cited by in corpus (52)
- Modern temporal network theory: A colloquium
- Inferring Social Status and Rich Club Effects in Enterprise Communication Networks
- Stream Graphs and Link Streams for the Modeling of Interactions over Time
- Daily rhythms in mobile telephone communication
- Bursty Human Dynamics
- Communication with family and friends across the life course
- From seconds to months: multi-scale dynamics of mobile telephone calls
- Division of labor, skill complementarity, and heterophily in socioeconomic networks
- Coupled catastrophes: sudden shifts cascade and hop among interdependent systems
- Randomized reference models for temporal networks
- From calls to communities: a model for time varying social networks
- Effects of temporal correlations on cascades: Threshold models on temporal networks
- Inductive Representation Learning in Temporal Networks via Causal Anonymous Walks
- Opinion Dynamics of Online Social Network Users: A Micro-Level Analysis
- The Role of Gender in Social Network Organization
- Dynamics of organizational culture: Individual beliefs vs. social conformity
- Spatial patterns of close relationships across the lifespan
- Statistically validated mobile communication networks: Evolution of motifs in European and Chinese data
- A comparative analysis of the statistical properties of large mobile phone calling networks
- Tracking Urban Human Activity from Mobile Phone Calling Patterns
- Exploring Temporal Networks with Greedy Walks
- From temporal network data to the dynamics of social relationships
- Universal underpinning of human mobility in the real world and cyberspace
- Triadic motifs in the dependence networks of virtual societies
- Dynamics of Disagreement: Large-Scale Temporal Network Analysis Reveals Negative Interactions in Online Collaboration
- Universal patterns in egocentric communication networks
- The Temporal Event Graph
- Temporal Motifs in Patent Opposition and Collaboration Networks
- Correlations and dynamics of consumption patterns in social-economic networks
- Fast Maximum Likelihood estimation via Equilibrium Expectation for Large Network Data
- Ground truth? Concept-based communities versus the external classification of physics manuscripts
- odeN: Simultaneous Approximation of Multiple Motif Counts in Large Temporal Networks
- Are the different layers of a social network conveying the same information?
- Network structure of thermonuclear reactions in nuclear landscape
- Using Motif Transitions for Temporal Graph Generation
- Link-centric analysis of variation by demographics in mobile phone communication patterns
- Cheating in online gaming spreads through observation and victimization
- Communication cliques in mobile phone calling networks
- Extended -wave pairing symmetry on the triangular lattice heavy fermion system
- Subgraph Isomorphism in Temporal Networks
- Network analysis of the worldwide footballer transfer market
- Higher-order temporal network effects through triplet evolution
- Individual position diversity in dependence socioeconomic networks increases economic output
- Triadic time series motifs
- Temporal Network Motifs: Models, Limitations, Evaluation
- Fundamental Structures in Dynamic Communication Networks
- A sampling framework for counting temporal motifs
- Accurate and Fast Estimation of Temporal Motifs using Path Sampling
- Clean up or mess up: the effect of sampling biases on measurements of degree distributions in mobile phone datasets
- Comparative analysis of layered structures in empirical investor networks and cellphone communication networks
- Seasonal and geographical impact on human resting periods
- Homophilic organization of egocentric communities in ICT services