Comparison of the moments of the Xmax distribution predicted by different cosmic ray shower simulation models
arXiv:1301.5555 · doi:10.1016/j.astropartphys.2013.05.011
Abstract
In this paper we study the depth at which a cosmic ray shower reaches its maximum (\Xmax) as predicted by Monte Carlo simulation. The use of \Xmax in the determination of the primary particle mass can only be done by comparing the measured values with simulation predictions. For this reason it is important to study the differences between the available simulation models. We have done a study of the first and second moments of the \Xmax distribution using the \Corsika and \Conex programs. The study was done with high statistics in the energy range from to \energy{20.4}. We focus our analysis in the different implementations of the hadronic interaction models \Sibyll and \Qgsjet in \Corsika and \Conex. We show that the predictions of the \meanXmax and \sigmaXmax depend slightly on the combination of simulation program and hadronic interaction model. Although these differences are small, they are not negligible in some cases (up to 5 g/cm for the worse case) and they should be considered as a systematic uncertainty of the model predictions for \meanXmax and \sigmaXmax. We have included a table with the suggested systematic uncertainties for the model predictions. Finally, we present a parametrization of the \Xmax distribution as a function of mass and energy according to the models \Sibyll and \Qgsjet, and showed an example of its application to obtain the predicted \Xmax distributions from cosmic ray propagation models.
arXiv commentSubmitted to Astroparticle Physics
References in corpus (15)
- First Observation of the Greisen-Zatsepin-Kuzmin Suppression
- Observation of the suppression of the flux of cosmic rays above 4x10^19eV
- Measurement of the Depth of Maximum of Extensive Air Showers above 10^18 eV
- On astrophysical solution to ultra high energy cosmic rays
- Measurements of the Cosmic Ray Composition with Air Shower Experiments
- One-dimensional Hybrid Approach to Extensive Air Shower Simulation
- Non-linear screening effects in high energy hadronic interactions
- Extensive Air Shower Simulations at the Highest Energies
- Implications of the cosmic ray spectrum for the mass composition at the highest energies
- On the re-summation of enhanced Pomeron diagrams
- First Results of Fast One-dimensional Hybrid Simulation of EAS Using CONEX
- Extragalactic UHE proton spectrum and prediction for iron-nuclei flux at 10^8 - 10^9 GeV
- The Pierre Auger Observatory II: Studies of Cosmic Ray Composition and Hadronic Interaction models
- Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays from Centaurus A: Jet Interaction with Gaseous Shells
- The JEM-EUSO Mission: Status and Prospects in 2011
Cited by in corpus (6)
- Depth of Maximum of Air-Shower Profiles at the Pierre Auger Observatory: Measurements at Energies above 10^17.8 eV
- Depth of Ultra High Energy Cosmic Ray Induced Air Shower Maxima Measured by the Telescope Array Black Rock and Long Ridge FADC Fluorescence Detectors and Surface Array in Hybrid Mode
- Measurement of the Proton-Air Cross Section with Telescope Array's Black Rock Mesa and Long Ridge Fluorescence Detectors, and Surface Array in Hybrid Mode
- Cosmic rays: the spectrum and chemical composition from to eV
- Air Shower Simulation and Hadronic Interactions
- On the parametrization of the distributions of depth of shower maximum of ultra-high energy extensive air showers