Amplitudes for Spacetime Regions and the Quantum Zeno Effect: Pitfalls of Standard Path Integral Constructions
arXiv:1301.4373 · doi:10.1088/1742-6596/442/1/012018
Abstract
We argue that under very general conditions, there is a significant complication in amplitudes for spacetimes regions constructed from path integrals. This is the fact that the concrete implementation of the restrictions on paths over an interval of time corresponds, in an operator language, to sharp monitoring at every moment of time in the given time interval. Such processes suffer from the quantum Zeno effect -- the continual monitoring of a quantum system in a Hilbert subspace prevents its state from leaving that subspace. As a consequence, path integral amplitudes defined in this seemingly obvious way have physically and intuitively unreasonable properties and in particular, no sensible classical limit. In this paper we describe this frequently-occurring but little-appreciated phenomenon in some detail, showing clearly the connection with the quantum Zeno effect. We then show that it may be avoided by implementing the restriction on paths in the path integral in a "softer" way. The resulting amplitudes then involve a new coarse graining parameter, which may be taken to be a timescale $\eps$, describing the softening of the restrictions on the paths. We argue that the complications arising from the Zeno effect are then negligible as long as $\eps >> 1/ E$, where is the energy scale of the incoming state. Our criticisms of path integral constructions largely apply to approaches to quantum theory such as the decoherent histories approach or quantum measure theory, which do not specifically involve measurements. We address some criticisms of our approach by Sokolovksi, concerning the relevance of our results to measurement-based models.
arXiv commentTo appear in proceedings of the 2012 DICE Conference (edited by T.Elze). arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1205.3773
References in corpus (51)
- Classical Equations for Quantum Systems
- A Straightforward Introduction to Continuous Quantum Measurement
- Quantum Mechanics as Quantum Measure Theory
- Quantum Logic and the Histories Approach to Quantum Theory
- The Classical Universes of the No-Boundary Quantum State
- Quantum temporal logic and decoherence functionals in the histories approach to generalised quantum theory
- The No-Boundary Measure of the Universe
- Continuous Histories and the History Group in Generalised Quantum Theory
- Somewhere in the Universe: Where is the Information Stored When Histories Decohere?
- Zeno dynamics yields ordinary constraints
- Comparing Formulations of Generalized Quantum Mechanics for Reparametrization-Invariant Systems
- Sum-over-histories origin of the composition laws of relativistic quantum mechanics and quantum cosmology
- Probabilities in Quantum Cosmological Models: A Decoherent Histories Analysis Using a Complex Potential
- Continuous Time and Consistent Histories
- Decoherence and the theory of continuous quantum measurements
- Time-of-arrival probabilities and quantum measurements
- Arrival Times, Complex Potentials and Decoherent Histories
- Life in an Energy Eigenstate: Decoherent Histories Analysis of a Model Timeless Universe
- Arrival Times in Quantum Theory from an Irreversible Detector Model
- Consistent Probabilities in Wheeler-DeWitt Quantum Cosmology
- Composite absorbing potentials
- Decoherent Histories Approach to the Arrival Time Problem
- Disclosing hidden information in the quantum Zeno effect: Pulsed measurement of the quantum time of arrival
- Barrier traversal times using a phenomenological track formation model
- Decoherent histories analysis of the relativistic particle
- An Operator Derivation of the Path Decomposition Expansion
- Quantum Zeno Effect with the Feynman-Mensky Path-Integral Approach
- Some Identities for the Quantum Measure and its Generalizations
- Invariant Class Operators in the Decoherent Histories Analysis of Timeless Quantum Theories
- The Spacetime Approach to Quantum Mechanics
- Equivalence between the real time Feynman histories and the quantum shutter approaches for the "passage time" in tunneling
- Quantum Arrival Time Formula from Decoherent Histories
- Nearly Instantaneous Alternatives in Quantum Mechanics
- Generalized Quantum Theory of Recollapsing Homogeneous Cosmologies
- Histories quantisation of parameterised systems: I. Development of a general algorithm
- Continuous Quantum Monitoring of Position of Nonlinear Oscillators
- Quantum Arrival and Dwell Times via Idealised Clocks
- Path Integral Analysis of Arrival Times with a Complex Potential
- Minisuperspace Models in Histories Theory
- Feynman Integrals with Absorbing Boundaries
- Finite resolution of time in continuous measurements: phenomenology and the model
- Relativistic Time-of-Arrival and Traversal Time
- Hilbert Spaces from Path Integrals
- Pitfalls of Path Integrals: Amplitudes for Spacetime Regions and the Quantum Zeno Effect
- On the Relationship Between Complex Potentials and Strings of Projection Operators
- Quantum Arrival Time For Open Systems
- Spacetime alternatives in relativistic particle motion
- Quantum probabilities for time-extended measurements
- Spacetime Coarse Grainings in the Decoherent Histories Approach to Quantum Theory
- Position Measurement for a Relativistic Particle: Restricted-Path-Integral Analysis
- Quantum Zeno Effect in the Decoherent Histories