Tunneling Time in Ultrafast Science is Real and Probabilistic
arXiv:1301.2766 · doi:10.1364/OPTICA.1.000343
Abstract
We compare the main competing theories of tunneling time against experimental measurements using the attoclock in strong laser field ionization of helium atoms. Refined attoclock measurements reveal a real and not instantaneous tunneling delay time over a large intensity regime, using two different experimental apparatus. Only two of the theoretical predictions are compatible within our experimental error: the Larmor time, and the probability distribution of tunneling times constructed using a Feynman Path Integral (FPI) formulation. The latter better matches the observed qualitative change in tunneling time over a wide intensity range, and predicts a broad tunneling time distribution with a long tail. The implication of such a probability distribution of tunneling times, as opposed to a distinct tunneling time, challenges how valence electron dynamics are currently reconstructed in attosecond science. It means that one must account for a significant uncertainty as to when the hole dynamics begin to evolve.
arXiv comment11 pages, 4 figures
References in corpus (2)
Cited by in corpus (68)
- Advances in QED with intense background fields
- Experimental evidence for Wigner's tunneling time
- Ionization Time and Exit Momentum in Strong-Field Tunnel Ionization
- Resonance effects in photoemission time delays
- Ptychographic reconstruction of attosecond pulses
- Attoclock revisited on electron tunnelling time
- The attoclock and the tunnelling time debate
- Arrival Time Distributions of Spin-1/2 Particles
- Keldysh-Rutherford model for attoclock
- Dynamics of Tunneling Ionization using Bohmian Mechanics
- Effective potentials from semiclassical truncations
- Quantum Battles in Attoscience -- Tunnelling
- Direct tunneling delay time measurement in an optical lattice
- Under-the-tunneling-barrier recollisions in strong field ionization
- Numerical attoclock on atomic and molecular hydrogen
- All-optical attoclock for imaging tunnelling wavepackets
- Treating Branch Cuts in Quantum Trajectory Models for Photoelectron Holography
- Observation of the Decrease of Larmor Tunneling Times with Lower Incident Energy
- Attosecond Ionization Time Delays in Strong-Field Physics
- Reconciling conflicting approaches for the tunneling time delay in strong field ionization
- Faithful realizations of semiclassical truncations
- Virtual-detector approach to tunnel ionization and tunneling times
- Momentum partition between constituents of exotic atoms during laser induced tunneling ionization
- Controlling quantum numbers and light emission of Rydberg states via the laser pulse duration
- On the quantum tunneling time: Instantaneous, finite or probabilistic?
- Conservation laws for Electron Vortices in Strong-Field Ionisation
- Roles of laser ellipticity in attoclock
- Orientation Dependent Dissociative Ionization of H in Strong Elliptic Laser Fields: Modification of the release time through molecular orientation
- The effect of electron-electron correlation on the attoclock experiment
- Strong-field ionization via high-order Coulomb corrected strong-field approximation
- Tunneling time in attosecond experiments and time-energy uncertainty relation
- Tunneling in attosecond optical ionization and a dynamical time operator
- Canonical Tunneling Time in Ionization Experiments
- Scattering Times of Quantum Particles from the Gravitational Potential, and Equivalence Principle Violation
- Phase-dependent cross sections of deuteron-triton fusion in dichromatic intense fields with high-frequency limit
- Non-Hermitian Hartman effect
- Electron traversal times in disordered graphene nanoribbons
- Statistical Approach to Tunneling Time in Attosecond Experiments
- Electron correlation and short-range dynamics in attosecond angular streaking
- Photoelectron momentum distributions in the strong-field ionization of atomic hydrogen by few-cycle elliptically polarized optical pulses
- Determination of the time scale of photoemission from the measurement of spin polarization
- Dynamically Assisted Tunneling in the Floquet Picture
- Numerical time-of-flight analysis of the strong-field photoeffect
- Intensity dependence of Rydberg states
- Enhancing spin polarization using ultrafast angular streaking
- The role of reflections in the generation of a time delay in strong field ionization
- Delay-time distribution in the scattering of time-narrow wave packets. (I)
- Delay-time distribution in the scattering of time-narrow wave packets (II) - Quantum Graphs
- Sub-barrier recollisions and the three classes of tunneling time delays in strong-field ionization
- Enhanced chiral-sensitivity of Coulomb-focused electrons in strong field ionization
- A General Scenario of Tunneling Time in Different Energy Regimes
- Control of Arrival Time using Structured Wave Packets
- Tunneling ionization in ultrashort laser pulses: edge-effect and remedy
- Superluminal tunneling times without superluminal signaling: Fading of the MacColl-Hartman effect at early times
- Negative transit time in non-tunneling electron transmission through graphene multilayers
- Tunneling time from spin fluctuations in Larmor clock
- Measuring the time a tunnelling atom spends in the barrier
- Electron interaction with the environment in tunnel ionization
- The physics of adiabatic particle number in the Schwinger effect
- Dynamically assisted tunneling in the impulse regime
- Quantum measurements and delays in scattering by zero-range potentials
- Salecker-Wigner-Peres quantum clock applied to strong-field tunnel ionization
- Interplay between Coulomb-focusing and non-dipole effects in strong-field ionization with elliptical polarization
- Magnetic Dichroism in Few-Photon Ionization of Polarized Atoms
- Photoionization of chiral molecules by counter-rotating bicircular laser fields: a chiral attoclock
- Exact energy-eigenstates of the Coulomb-Stark Hamiltonian
- Quantum First Passage Time Problem-A Bohmian Perspective
- Transition time estimation for -function coupling in two state problem: An analytically solvable model