The Planck Sunyaev-Zel'dovich vs. the X-ray View of the Coma Cluster
arXiv:1212.3082 · doi:10.1088/2041-8205/763/1/L3
Abstract
The Planck collaboration has recently published precise and resolved measurements of the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect in Abell 1656 (the Coma cluster of galaxies), so directly gauging the electron pressure profile in the intracluster plasma. On the other hand, such a quantity may be also derived from combining the density and temperature provided by X-ray observations of the thermal bremsstrahlung radiation emitted by the plasma. We find a model-independent tension between the SZ and the X-ray pressure, with the SZ one being definitely lower by 15-20%. We propose that such a challenging tension can be resolved in terms of an additional, non-thermal support to the gravitational equilibrium of the intracluster plasma. This can be straightforwardly included in our Supermodel, so as to fit in detail the Planck SZ profile while being consistent with the X-ray observables. Possible origins of the nonthermal component include cosmic-ray protons, ongoing turbulence, and relativistic electrons; given the existing observational constraints on the first two options, here we focus on the third. For this to be effective, we find that the electron population must include not only an energetic tail accelerated to gamma> 10^3 responsible for the Coma radiohalo, but also many more, lower energy electrons. The electron acceleration is to be started by merging events similar to those which provided the very high central entropy of the thermal intracluster plasma in Coma.
arXiv comment6 pages, 3 figures. Accepted by ApJL
References in corpus (40)
- Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
- Observational Evidence of AGN Feedback
- Chandra sample of nearby relaxed galaxy clusters: mass, gas fraction, and mass-temperature relation
- The universal galaxy cluster pressure profile from a representative sample of nearby systems (REXCESS) and the Y_SZ-M_500 relation
- Tracing cosmic evolution with clusters of galaxies
- Shocks and cold fronts in galaxy clusters
- Effects of Galaxy Formation on Thermodynamics of the Intracluster Medium
- Properties of the Intracluster Medium in an Ensemble of Nearby Galaxy Clusters
- Intracluster Medium Entropy Profiles for a Chandra Archival Sample of Galaxy Clusters
- The Evolution of X-ray Clusters and the Entropy of the Intra Cluster Medium
- A Catalog of Galaxy Clusters Observed by XMM-Newton
- Gas entropy in a representative sample of nearby X-ray galaxy clusters (REXCESS): relationship to gas mass fraction
- The Energy Spectrum of Primary Cosmic Ray Electrons in Clusters of Galaxies and Inverse Compton Emission
- A Comparison of Radio and X-Ray Morphologies of Four Clusters of Galaxies Containing Radio Halos
- Measuring the Three-Dimensional Structure of Galaxy Clusters. I. Application to a Sample of 25 Clusters
- X-Ray surface brightness and gas density fluctuations in the Coma cluster
- Acceleration of primary and secondary particles in galaxy clusters by compressible MHD turbulence: from radio halos to gamma rays
- Diffuse Radio Emission in/around the Coma Cluster: Beyond Simple Accretion
- GeV Gamma-ray Flux Upper Limits from Clusters of Galaxies
- Is the gas in cooling-flows multi-phase?
- Nonthermal Bremsstrahlung and Hard X-ray Emission from Clusters of Galaxies
- Studying the Diversity of Type Ia Supernovae in the Ultraviolet: Comparing Models with Observations
- Intracluster and Intragroup Entropy from Quasar Activity
- Probing the origin of giant radio halos through radio and gamma-ray data : the case of the Coma cluster
- Gamma rays from clusters of galaxies
- Turbulence production and turbulent pressure support in the intergalactic medium
- Modelling Shock Heating in Cluster Mergers: I. Moving Beyond the Spherical Accretion Model
- First LOFAR observations at very low frequencies of cluster-scale non-thermal emission: the case of Abell 2256
- Massive and refined: a sample of large galaxy clusters simulated at high resolution. I:Thermal gas and shock waves properties
- Fractional polarization and magnetic fields in the ICM
- Heating and Acceleration of Intracluster Medium Electrons by Turbulence
- A Suzaku Search for Non-thermal Emission at Hard X-ray Energies in the Coma Cluster
- Unveiling the composition of radio plasma bubbles in galaxy clusters with the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect
- Galaxy Clusters, a Novel Look at Diffuse Baryons Withstanding Dark Matter Gravity
- Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effects from Quasars in Galaxies and Groups
- Suzaku Observations of Iron K-lines from the Intracluster Medium of the Coma Cluster
- Structure and History of Dark Matter Halos Probed with Gravitational Lensing
- A Grand Design for Galaxy Clusters: Connections and Predictions
- Supermodel Analysis of Galaxy Clusters
- The Intracluster Plasma: a Universal Pressure Profile?
Cited by in corpus (10)
- Planck 2013 results. XXIX. Planck catalogue of Sunyaev-Zeldovich sources
- Testing chameleon gravity with the Coma cluster
- Measurements and simulation of Faraday rotation across the Coma radio relic
- Constraining gravity by the Large Scale Structure
- Constraining f(R) gravity with PLANCK data on galaxy cluster profiles
- A -gravity model of the Sunyaev-Zeldovich profile of the Coma cluster compatible with {\it Planck} data
- On the universality of MOG weak field approximation at galaxy cluster scale
- The Astrophysics of the Intracluster Plasma
- Turbulence in the SuperModel: Mass Reconstruction with Nonthermal Pressure for Abell 1835
- Witnessing a merging bullet being stripped in the galaxy cluster, RXCJ2359.3-6042