No evidence for an early seventeenth-century Indian sighting of Keplers supernova (SN1604)

Abstract

In a recent paper Sule et al. (Astronomical Notes, vol. 332 (2011), 655) argued that an early 17th-century Indian mural of the constellation Sagittarius with a dragon-headed tail indicated that the bright supernova of 1604 was also sighted by Indian astronomers. In this paper it will be shown that this identification is based on a misunderstanding of traditional Islamic astrological iconography and that the claim that the mural represents an early 17th-century Indian sighting of the supernova of 1604 has to be rejected.

arXiv comment7 pages, 6 figures. To appear in Astronomical Notes, vol. 334, issue 5 (2013), DOI number 11721