How reliable is Zeeman Doppler Imaging without simultaneous temperature reconstruction?

Abstract

Aims: The goal of this study is to perform numerical tests of Zeeman Doppler Imaging (ZDI) to asses whether correct reconstruction of magnetic fields is at all possible without taking temperature into account for stars in which magnetic and temperature inhomogeneities are spatially correlated. Methods: We used a modern ZDI code employing a physically realistic treatment of the polarized radiative transfer in all four Stokes parameters. We generated artificial observations of isolated magnetic spots and of magnetic features coinciding with cool temperature spots and then reconstructed magnetic and temperature distributions from these data. Results: Using Stokes I and V for simultaneous magnetic and temperature mapping for the star with a homogeneous temperature distribution yields magnetic field strengths underestimated by typically 10-15% relative to their true values. When temperature is kept constant and Stokes I is not used for magnetic mapping, the underestimation is 30-60%. At the same time, the strength of magnetic field inside cool spots is underestimated by as much as 80-95% and the spot geometry is also poorly reconstructed when temperature variations are ignored. On the other hand, the inversion quality is greatly improved when temperature variations are accounted for in magnetic mapping. When using all four Stokes parameters the reconstructed field strength inside cool spots is underestimated by 30-40% but the spot geometry can be recovered very accurately compared to the experiments with circular polarization alone. Conclusions: Reliable magnetic field reconstruction for a star with high-contrast temperature spots is essentially impossible if temperature inhomogeneities are ignored. A physically realistic line profile modeling method, which simultaneously accounts for both types of inhomogeneities, is required for meaningful ZDI of cool active stars.

References in corpus (8)

• A grid of MARCS model atmospheres for late-type stars I. Methods and general properties
• The surprising magnetic topology of tauSco: fossil remnant or dynamo output?
• Toroidal versus poloidal magnetic fields in Sun-like stars: a rotation threshold
• The magnetic field of the planet-hosting star $\tau$ Bootis
• Magnetic Doppler imaging of alpha^2 Canum Venaticorum in all four Stokes parameters. Unveiling the hidden complexity of stellar magnetic fields
• Magnetic topology and surface differential rotation on the K1 subgiant of the RS CVn system HR 1099
• Magnetic Doppler imaging of the roAp star HD 24712
• Magnetic Doppler imaging considering atmospheric structure modifications due to local abundances: a luxury or a necessity?

Cited by in corpus (22)

• Magnetic fields of M dwarfs
• Hidden magnetic fields of young suns
• First Zeeman Doppler imaging of a cool star using all four Stokes parameters
• Magnetic fields on young, moderately rotating Sun-like stars - I: HD~35296 and HD~29615
• Magnetic fields of young solar twins
• Magnetic fields on young, moderately rotating Sun-like stars II. EK Draconis (HD 129333)
• Magnetic field topology of the RS CVn star II Pegasi
• Stokes $IQUV$ Magnetic Doppler Imaging of Ap stars II: Next Generation Magnetic Doppler Imaging of ${\alpha }^2$ CVn
• Three-dimensional simulations of near-surface convection in main-sequence stars. IV. Effect of small-scale magnetic flux concentrations on centre-to-limb variation and spectral lines
• Surface magnetism of cool stars
• The magnetic field topology and chemical abundance distributions of the Ap star HD 32633
• Magnetic field topology of tau Sco. The uniqueness problem of Stokes V ZDI inversions
• Zeeman-Doppler imaging of active young solar type stars
• Strong variable linear polarization in the cool active star II Peg
• Magnetic field topology of the cool, active, short-period binary system ${\sigma }^2$ Coronae Borealis
• Starspot activity of HD 199178. Doppler images from 1994--2017
• Diagnostic of stellar magnetic fields with cumulative circular polarisation profiles
• Topological changes in the magnetic field of LQ Hya during an activity minimum
• Observing dynamos in cool stars
• Warm and cool starspots with opposite polarities. A high-resolution Zeeman-Doppler-Imaging study of II Pegasi with PEPSI
• Magnetic field of the eclipsing binary UV Piscium
• Long period modulation of the classical T Tauri star CI Tau: evidence for an eccentric close-in massive planet at 0.17 au