Inability to find justification of a $k_T$-factorization formula by following chains of citations

Abstract

Fundamental to much work in small-x QCD is a k_T-factorization formula. Normal expectations in theoretical physics are that when such a result is used, citations should be given to where the formula is justified. We demonstrate by examining the chains of citations back from current work that violations of this expectation are widespread, to the extent that following the citation chains, we do not find a proof or other justification of the formula. This shows a substantial deficit in the reproducibility of a phenomenologically important area of research. Since the published formulae differ in normalization, we test them by making a derivation in a simple model that obeys the assumptions that are stated in the literature to be the basis of k_T-factorization in the small-$x$ regime. We find that we disagree with two of the standard normalizations.

References in corpus (16)

• Gluon Production from Non-Abelian Weizsäcker-Williams Fields in Nucleus-Nucleus Collisions
• Gluon Production at High Transverse Momentum in the McLerran-Venugopalan Model of Nuclear Structure Functions
• Cronin Effect and High-p_T Suppression in pA Collisions
• Inclusive Gluon Production in DIS at High Parton Density
• Color Glass Condensate at the LHC: hadron multiplicities in $pp$, $pA$ and $AA$ collisions
• Matches and mismatches in the descriptions of semi-inclusive processes at low and high transverse momentum
• Relating high-energy lepton-hadron, proton-nucleus and nucleus-nucleus collisions through geometric scaling
• Classical Gluon Radiation in Ultrarelativistic Nucleus-Nucleus Collisions
• Single Inclusive Hadron Production at RHIC and the LHC from the Color Glass Condensate
• Yang-Mills Radiation in Ultra-relativistic Nuclear Collisions
• QCD saturation at the LHC: comparisons of models to p+p and A+A data and predictions for p+Pb collisions
• Gluon saturation and inclusive hadron production at LHC
• Hadron multiplicity in pp and AA collisions at LHC from the Color Glass Condensate
• A model for gluon production in heavy-ion collisions at the LHC with rcBK unintegrated gluon densities
• Charged particle multiplicities in pA interactions at the LHC from the Color Glass Condensate
• TMD factorization and the gluon distribution in high energy QCD

Cited by in corpus (3)

• Two-Gluon Correlations in Heavy-Light Ion Collisions: Energy and Geometry Dependence, IR Divergences, and $k_T$-Factorization
• Dynamical entropy of dense QCD states
• Photoproduction of three jets in the CGC: gluon TMDs and dilute limit