Thermal to Nonthermal Energy Partition at the Early Rise Phase of Solar Flares

Abstract

In some flares the thermal component appears much earlier than the nonthermal component in X-ray range. Using sensitive microwave observations we revisit this finding made by Battaglia et al. (2009) based on RHESSI data analysis. We have found that nonthermal microwave emission produced by accelerated electrons with energy of at least several hundred keV, appears as early as the thermal soft X-ray emission indicative that the electron acceleration takes place at the very early flare phase. The non-detection of the hard X-rays at that early stage of the flares is, thus, an artifact of a limited RHESSI sensitivity. In all considered events, the microwave emission intensity increases at the early flare phase. We found that either thermal or nonthermal gyrosynchrotron emission can dominate the low-frequency part of the microwave spectrum below the spectral peak occurring at 3-10 GHz. In contrast, the high-frequency optically thin part of the spectrum is always formed by the nonthermal, accelerated electron component, whose power-law energy spectrum can extend up to a few MeV at this early flare stage. This means that even though the total number of accelerated electrons is small at this stage, their nonthermal spectrum is fully developed. This implies that an acceleration process of available seed particles is fully operational. While, creation of this seed population (the process commonly called `injection' of the particles from the thermal pool into acceleration) has a rather low efficiency at this stage, although, the plasma heating efficiency is high. This imbalance between the heating and acceleration (in favor of the heating) is difficult to reconcile within most of available flare energization models. Being reminiscent of the tradeoff between the Joule heating and runaway electron acceleration, it puts additional constraints on the electron injection into the acceleration process.

arXiv comment11 pages, 12 figures, accepted for ApJ

References in corpus (14)

• The Fermi Gamma-Ray Burst Monitor
• Stochastic Acceleration of Electrons and Protons. I. Acceleration by Parallel Propagating Waves
• The Relationship Between Solar Radio and Hard X-ray Emission
• RHESSI Line and Continuum Observations of Super-hot Flare Plasma
• Observations of conduction driven evaporation in the early rise phase of solar flares
• An Extreme Solar Event of 20 January 2005: Properties of the Flare and the Origin of Energetic Particles
• Cold, tenuous solar flare: acceleration without heating
• A Statistical Survey of Hard X-ray Spectral Characteristics of Solar Flares with Two Footpoints
• Radio Spectral Evolution of an X-ray Poor Impulsive Solar Flare: Implications for Plasma Heating and Electron Acceleration
• Exploring the Connection Between Star Formation and AGN Activity in the Local Universe
• 3D simulations of gyrosynchrotron emission from mildly anisotropic nonuniform electron distributions in symmetric magnetic loops
• Plasma heating in the very early phase of solar flares
• Elementary Energy Release Events in Solar Flares
• Imaging Spectroscopy on Preflare Coronal Nonthermal Sources Associated with the 2002 July 23 Flare

Cited by in corpus (14)

• High-resolution observations of flare precursors in the low solar atmosphere
• Observational Analysis on the Early Evolution of a CME Flux-rope: Pre-flare reconnection and Flux-rope's Footpoint Drift
• Particle-in-cell simulations of particle energization via shock drift acceleration from low Mach number quasi-perpendicular shocks in solar flares
• Energy Partitions and Evolution in a Purely Thermal Solar Flare
• Multi-wavelength Diagnostics of the Precursor and Main phases of an M1.8 Flare on 2011 April 22
• Rapid Variability in the SOL2011-08-04 Flare: Implications for Electron Acceleration
• Spatio-temporal energy partitioning in a non-thermally dominated two-loop solar flare
• Electron distribution and energy release in magnetic reconnection outflow regions during the pre-impulsive phase of a solar flare
• Where is the chromospheric response to conductive energy input from a hot pre-flare coronal loop?
• Sources of Quasi-Periodic Pulses in the 18 August 2012 Flare
• Observations of a Radio-quiet Solar Preflare
• Chromospheric response during the precursor and the main phase of a B6.4 flare on August 20, 2005
• Microwave Imaging Spectroscopy Diagnosis of the Slow-rise Precursor of a Major Solar Eruption
• Implications of Flat Optically Thick Microwave Spectra in Solar Flares for Source Size and Morphology