The tetralogy of Birkhoff theorems

Abstract

We classify the existent Birkhoff-type theorems into four classes: First, in field theory, the theorem states the absence of helicity 0- and spin 0-parts of the gravitational field. Second, in relativistic astrophysics, it is the statement that the gravitational far-field of a spherically symmetric star carries, apart from its mass, no information about the star; therefore, a radially oscillating star has a static gravitational far-field. Third, in mathematical physics, Birkhoff's theorem reads: up to singular exceptions of measure zero, the spherically symmetric solutions of Einstein's vacuum field equation with Lambda = 0 can be expressed by the Schwarzschild metric; for Lambda unequal 0, it is the Schwarzschild-de Sitter metric instead. Fourth, in differential geometry, any statement of the type: every member of a family of pseudo-Riemannian space-times has more isometries than expected from the original metric ansatz, carries the name Birkhoff-type theorem. Within the fourth of these classes we present some new results with further values of dimension and signature of the related spaces; including them are some counterexamples: families of space-times where no Birkhoff-type theorem is valid. These counterexamples further confirm the conjecture, that the Birkhoff-type theorems have their origin in the property, that the two eigenvalues of the Ricci tensor of two-dimensional pseudo-Riemannian spaces always coincide, a property not having an analogy in higher dimensions. Hence, Birkhoff-type theorems exist only for those physical situations which are reducible to two dimensions.

26 pages, updated references, minor text changes, accepted by Gen. Relat. Grav

References in corpus (69)

• Dilaton Gravity in Two Dimensions
• General Gauss-Bonnet brane cosmology
• A new cubic theory of gravity in five dimensions: Black hole, Birkhoff's theorem and C-function
• Fourth order gravity: equations, history, and applications to cosmology
• General class of wormhole geometries in conformal Weyl gravity
• Thermodynamics of Black Holes in Two (and Higher) Dimensions
• Shortcuts to high symmetry solutions in gravitational theories
• Reissner-Nordström black holes in extended Palatini theories
• Spherically Symmetric Solutions to Fourth-Order Theories of Gravity
• Static Solutions for 4th order gravity
• Birkhoff's theorem in Lovelock gravity
• The Cauchy problem for metric-affine f(R)-gravity in presence of perfect-fluid matter
• A new framework for studying spherically symmetric static solutions in f(R) gravity
• Dilaton spacetimes with a Liouville potential
• Higher Dimensional Wormhole Geometries with Compact Dimensions
• The Jebsen-Birkhoff theorem in alternative gravity
• The Newtonian limit of fourth and higher order gravity
• Birkhoff's Theorem for Three-Dimensional AdS Gravity
• A general solution in the Newtonian limit of f(R)- gravity
• Birkhoff's Theorem in Higher Derivative Theories of Gravity
• Schwarzschild and Birkhoff a la Weyl
• A simple proof of Birkhoff's theorem for cosmological constant
• Pseudoinstantons in metric-affine field theory
• Birkhoff for Lovelock Redux
• Extended Birkhoff's Theorem in the f(T) Gravity
• The Birkhoff Theorem in Multidimensional Gravity
• The Newtonian limit of metric gravity theories with quadratic Lagrangians
• Gauss-Bonnet black holes with non-constant curvature horizons
• Scalar-tensor representation of $f(R)$ gravity and Birkhoff's theorem
• The Birkhoff theorem for topologically massive gravity
• Group Theoretical Quantization of a Phase Space S^1 x R^+ and the Mass Spectrum of Schwarzschild Black Holes in D Space-Time Dimensions
• Almost Birkhoff Theorem in General Relativity
• Spherical Structures in Conformal Gravity and its Scalar-Tensor Extension
• Graded Poisson-Sigma Models and Dilaton-Deformed 2D Supergravity Algebra
• Birkhoff's Theorem in Higher Derivative Theories of Gravity II: Asymptotically Lifshitz Black Holes
• Spherical Gravitating Systems of Arbitrary Dimension
• The Complete Solution of 2D Superfield Supergravity from graded Poisson-Sigma Models and the Super Pointparticle
• Birkhoff Theorem and Matter
• Ramifications of Lineland
• Observable Quantities in Weyl Gravity
• General solutions of Einstein's spherically symmetric gravitational equations with junction conditions
• Static wormholes in vacuum for conformal gravity
• Rigidity of noncompact complete Bach-flat manifolds
• Two-dimensional higher-derivative gravity and conformal transformations
• Quantum Dilaton Gravity in Two Dimensions with Fermionic Matter
• The strong equivalence principle from gravitational gauge structure
• Cosmology of the Jackiw-Teitelboim model
• Spontaneous breaking of conformal invariance, solitons and gravitational waves in theories of conformally invariant gravitation
• Duality in 2-dimensional dilaton gravity
• Can black holes have Euclidean cores?
• Spherical Non-Abelian Solutions in Conformal Gravity
• Cylindrically-Symmetric Solutions in Conformal Gravity
• On the validity of the 5-dimensional Birkhoff theorem: The tale of an exceptional case
• The Spherically Symmetric Standard Model with Gravity
• Shock waves and Birkhoff's theorem in Lovelock gravity
• Four-dimensional couplings among BF and massless Rarita-Schwinger theories: a BRST cohomological approach
• Exact String-Like Solutions in Conformal Gravity
• The Dirichlet Obstruction in AdS/CFT
• Lukewarm black holes in quadratic gravity
• On the generalized Freedman-Townsend model
• Time (in)dependence in general relativity
• A new conformal duality of spherically symmetric space-times
• An anti-Schwarzshild solution: wormholes and scalar-tensor solutions
• Conformal frames and the validity of Birkhoff's theorem
• A new proof of Birkhoff's theorem
• Second Law of Black Hole Mechanics for all 2d Dilaton Theories
• Actions for the Bosonic String with the Curved Worldsheet
• Black Hole Horizons and Thermodynamics: A Quantum Approach
• Birkhoff's theorem and perturbations in $f(R)$ theories

Cited by in corpus (16)

• Spherically symmetric black holes in $f(R)$ gravity: Is geometric scalar hair supported ?
• Spherical inhomogeneous solutions of Einstein and scalar-tensor gravity: a map of the land
• Generalized Birkhoff theorem in the Poincaré gauge gravity theory
• Exact radial solution in 2+1 gravity with a real scalar field
• The Birkhoff theorem and string clouds
• Constraints on Kaluza-Klein gravity from Gravity Probe B
• Infinitely degenerate exact Ricci-flat solutions in f(R) gravity
• Naked singularities in quadratic f(R) gravity
• Simultaneous baldness and cosmic baldness and Kottler spacetime
• Revisiting the Birkhoff theorem from a dual null point of view
• Global properties of warped solutions in General Relativity with electromagnetic field and cosmological constant
• Evolution of thin shells in D-dimensional General Relativity
• Global properties of warped solutions in General Relativity with an electromagnetic field and a cosmological constant. II
• Multiple Killing Horizons: the initial value formulation for $\Lambda$-vacuum
• Birkhoffs Theorem and Lie Symmetry Analysis
• Symmetry Inheritance and Jebsen-Birkhoff Theorem