Are Scattering Properties of Graphs Uniquely Connected to Their Shapes?
arXiv:1207.6221 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.109.040402
Abstract
The famous question of Mark Kac "Can one hear the shape of a drum?" addressing the unique connection between the shape of a planar region and the spectrum of the corresponding Laplace operator can be legitimately extended to scattering systems. In the modified version one asks whether the geometry of a vibrating system can be determined by scattering experiments. We present the first experimental approach to this problem in the case of microwave graphs (networks) simulating quantum graphs. Our experimental results strongly indicate a negative answer. To demonstrate this we consider scattering from a pair of isospectral microwave networks consisting of vertices connected by microwave coaxial cables and extended to scattering systems by connecting leads to infinity to form isoscattering networks. We show that the amplitudes and phases of the determinants of the scattering matrices of such networks are the same within the experimental uncertainties. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the scattering matrices of the networks are conjugated by the, so called, transplantation relation.
arXiv comment3 figures; Physical Review Letters, 2012
References in corpus (14)
- Periodic Orbit Theory and Spectral Statistics for Quantum Graphs
- Quantum Graphs: Applications to Quantum Chaos and Universal Spectral Statistics
- Experimental simulation of quantum graphs by microwave networks
- Can One Hear the Shape of a Graph?
- Experimental and numerical investigation of the reflection coefficient and the distributions of Wigner's reaction matrix for irregular graphs with absorption
- Experimental investigation of Wigner's reaction matrix for irregular graphs with absorption
- The Isospectral Fruits of Representation Theory: Quantum Graphs and Drums
- Experimental Test of a Trace Formula for a Chaotic Three Dimensional Microwave Cavity
- Experimental investigation of nodal domains in the chaotic microwave rough billiard
- Investigation of nodal domains in the chaotic microwave ray-splitting rough billiard
- Linear Representations and Isospectrality with Boundary Conditions
- Scattering from isospectral quantum graphs
- Isospectrality in Chaotic Billiards
- Experimental investigation of electric field distributions in a chaotic 3D microwave rough billiard
Cited by in corpus (37)
- Power spectrum analysis and missing level statistics of microwave graphs with violated time reversal invariance
- Non-universality in the spectral properties of time-reversal invariant microwave networks and quantum graphs
- Random Matrix Theory Approach to Chaotic Coherent Perfect Absorbers
- Perfect Absorption in Complex Scattering Systems with or without Hidden Symmetries
- Spectral properties of microwave graphs with local absorption
- Nodal portraits of quantum billiards: Domains, lines, and statistics
- Non-Weyl Microwave Graphs
- Partial time-reversal invariance violation in a flat, superconducting microwave cavity with the shape of a chaotic Africa billiard
- Distribution of zeros of the S-matrix of chaotic cavities with localized losses and Coherent Perfect Absorption: non-perturbative results
- Generalization of Wigner Time Delay to Sub-Unitary Scattering Systems
- Green's function approach for quantum graphs: an overview
- Hearing Euler characteristic of graphs
- Universality of the momentum band density of periodic networks
- Statistics of Complex Wigner Time Delays as a counter of S-matrix poles: Theory and Experiment
- Missing-level statistics in classically chaotic quantum systems with symplectic symmetry
- GSE statistics without spin
- Non-abelian Quantum Statistics on Graphs
- Distributions of the Wigner reaction matrix for microwave networks with symplectic symmetry in the presence of absorption
- Missing level statistics and the power spectrum of level fluctuations analysis of three-dimensional chaotic microwave cavities
- Experimental investigation of distributions of the off-diagonal elements of the scattering and the Wigner's matrices for networks with broken time reversal invariance
- Resonances and poles in isoscattering microwave networks and graphs
- Experimental investigation of the elastic enhancement factor in a transient region between regular and chaotic dynamics
- The edge switch transformation in microwave networks
- Simple quantum graphs proposal for quantum devices
- Long-range correlations in rectangular cavities containing point-like perturbations
- A Physical Interpretation of Imaginary Time Delay
- Experimental study of closed and open microwave waveguide graphs with preserved and partially violated time-reversal invariance
- Quantum graphs and microwave networks as narrow band filters for quantum and microwave devices
- Missing level statistics in a dissipative microwave resonator with partially violated time-reversal invariance
- Superuniversal Statistics of Complex Time-Delays in Non-Hermitian Scattering Systems
- Closed and open superconducting microwave waveguide networks as a model for quantum graphs
- Investigation of the enhancement factor in the regime of semi-Poisson statistics in a singular microwave cavity
- Coupled unidirectional chaotic microwave graphs
- Families of isospectral and isoscattering quantum graphs
- Time Domain Generalization of the Random Coupling Model and Experimental Verification in a Complex Scattering System
- Discovering hidden layers in quantum graphs
- Experimental study of the distributions of off-diagonal scattering-matrix elements of quantum graphs with symplectic symmetry