Do gauge fields really contribute negatively to black hole entropy?
arXiv:1206.5831 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.86.064042
Abstract
Quantum fluctuations of matter fields contribute to the thermal entropy of black holes. For free minimally-coupled scalar and spinor fields, this contribution is precisely the entanglement entropy. For gauge fields, Kabat found an extra negative divergent "contact term" with no known statistical interpretation. We compare this contact term to a similar term that arises for nonminimally-coupled scalar fields. Although both divergences may be interpreted as terms in the Wald entropy, we point out that the contact term for gauge fields comes from a gauge-dependent ambiguity in Wald's formula. Revisiting Kabat's derivation of the contact term, we show that it is sensitive to the treatment of infrared modes. To explore these infrared issues, we consider two-dimensional compact manifolds, such as Euclidean de Sitter space, and show that the contact term arises from an incorrect treatment of zero modes. In a manifestly gauge-invariant reduced phase space quantization, the gauge field contribution to the entropy is positive, finite, and equal to the entanglement entropy.
arXiv comment27 pages
References in corpus (38)
- Black Hole Entropy is Noether Charge
- Some Properties of Noether Charge and a Proposal for Dynamical Black Hole Entropy
- Entropy and Area
- On Geometric Entropy
- Black Hole Entropy in Canonical Quantum Gravity and Superstring Theory
- Entanglement entropy of black holes
- Entropy of Lovelock Black Holes
- Black Hole Entropy and Entropy of Entanglement
- On the Description of the Riemannian Geometry in the Presence of Conical Defects
- Lectures on 2D Yang-Mills Theory, Equivariant Cohomology and Topological Field Theories
- A proof of the generalized second law for rapidly changing fields and arbitrary horizon slices
- Decomposition of entanglement entropy in lattice gauge theory
- Black Hole Entropy without Brick Walls
- Renormalization of Black Hole Entropy and of the Gravitational Coupling Constant
- Increase of Black Hole Entropy in Higher Curvature Gravity
- A Comment on Entropy and Area
- On one-loop renormalization of black-hole entropy
- Dirty black holes: Entropy as a surface term
- Mechanism of Generation of Black Hole Entropy in Sakharov's Induced Gravity
- Black Hole Entropy and Induced Gravity
- One-loop Renormalization of Black Hole Entropy Due to Non-minimally Coupled Matter
- Thermodynamics of Quantum Fields in Black Hole Backgrounds
- Cones, Spins and Heat Kernels
- Black Hole Entropy: Off-Shell vs On-Shell
- Topological deformation of isolated horizons
- Black Hole Entropy in the O(N) Model
- Non-minimal coupling, boundary terms and renormalization of the Einstein-Hilbert action
- A proof of the generalized second law for rapidly-evolving Rindler horizons
- Renormalized black hole entropy in anti-de Sitter space via the "brick wall" method
- Ten Proofs of the Generalized Second Law
- Classical Scalar Fields and the Generalized Second Law
- Second Law Violations in Lovelock Gravity for Black Hole Mergers
- Entropy, Contact Interaction with Horizon and Dark Energy
- Entropy increase during physical processes for black holes in Lanczos-Lovelock gravity
- Renormalized Thermodynamic Entropy of Black Holes in Higher Dimensions
- Non-minimal coupling and quantum entropy of black hole
- A Comment on Black Hole Entropy in String Theory
- Kabat's Surface Terms in the Zeta-Function approach
Cited by in corpus (49)
- Remarks on entanglement entropy for gauge fields
- A Quantum Focussing Conjecture
- Entanglement entropy of electromagnetic edge modes
- Exact results for the entanglement entropy and the energy radiated by a quark
- On The Entanglement Entropy For Gauge Theories
- Proof of the Weak Gravity Conjecture from Black Hole Entropy
- Geometric entropy and edge modes of the electromagnetic field
- Entanglement entropy and nonabelian gauge symmetry
- Local phase space and edge modes for diffeomorphism-invariant theories
- Entanglement between Two Interacting CFTs and Generalized Holographic Entanglement Entropy
- The Generalized Second Law implies a Quantum Singularity Theorem
- Entanglement equilibrium for higher order gravity
- Edge Dynamics from the Path Integral: Maxwell and Yang-Mills
- Area terms in entanglement entropy
- Entanglement entropy of a Maxwell field on the sphere
- Lessons on Eternal Traversable Wormholes in AdS
- Entanglement branes in a two-dimensional string theory
- Topological Casimir effect in Maxwell Electrodynamics on a Compact Manifold
- Notes on Entanglement in Abelian Gauge Theories
- Entanglement Entropy in 2D Non-abelian Pure Gauge Theory
- Perturbative String Thermodynamics near Black Hole Horizons
- Black hole entanglement entropy and the renormalization group
- On the Architecture of Spacetime Geometry
- Newton constant, contact terms and entropy
- Dynamical Edge Modes and Entanglement in Maxwell Theory
- Inflaton as an auxiliary topological field in a QCD-like system
- Electromagnetic Duality and Entanglement Anomalies
- On the logarithmic coefficient of the entanglement entropy of a Maxwell field
- Remarks on effective action and entanglement entropy of Maxwell field in generic gauge
- Black Hole Horizon Edge Partition Functions
- Unitarity of Maxwell theory on curved spacetimes in the covariant formalism
- Revisiting noninteracting string partition functions in Rindler space
- A note on entanglement entropy and quantum geometry
- Strong Coupling Expansion of the Entanglement Entropy of Yang-Mills Gauge Theories
- Maxwell Theory on a Compact Manifold as a Topologically Ordered System
- Entanglement entropy, dualities, and deconfinement in gauge theories
- Instability of Universal Terms in the Entanglement Entropy
- The Edge of Entanglement: Getting the Boundary Right for Non-Minimally Coupled Scalar Fields
- Hagedorn String Thermodynamics in Curved Spacetimes and near Black Hole Horizons
- Entanglement Entropy and Duality
- Dynamical Edge Modes in -form Gauge Theories
- Analysis of the Entanglement with Centers
- Defining entanglement without tensor factoring: a Euclidean hourglass prescription
- Exact Renormalization Group, Entanglement Entropy, and Black Hole Entropy
- Entanglement Entropy in Closed String Theory
- Entanglement Entropy and Thermodynamics of Dynamical Black Holes
- Revision of the brick wall method for calculating the black hole thermodynamic quantities
- De Sitter Horizon Edge Partition Functions
- Gravitons on Nariai Edges