Comment on "Logarithmic Oscillators: Ideal Hamiltonian Thermostats" [arXiv 1203.5968]

Abstract

Campisi, Zhan, Talkner and Hänggi have recently proposed a novel Hamiltonian thermostat which they claim may be used both in simulations and experiments [arXiv:1203.5968v4]. We show, however, that this is not possible due to the length and time scales involved, which depend exponentially on the total energy of the system. The implementation suggested by Campisi et alii implies equilibration times greater than the age of the universe for systems with more than a few dozen particles.

arXiv comment9 pages, 3 figures (comment including additional information and our reaction to the Reply by Campisi et alii)

References in corpus (5)

• Non-Equilibrium Statistical Mechanics of Classical Lattice ${\varphi }^4$ Field Theory
• Logarithmic oscillators: ideal Hamiltonian thermostats
• Non-Equilibrium Steady States and Transport in the Classical Lattice ${\varphi }^4$ Theory
• Violations of local equilibrium and linear response in classical lattice theories
• On the logarithmic oscillator as a thermostat

Cited by in corpus (4)

• Hamiltonian Thermostats Fail to Promote Heat Flow
• Thermostated Hamiltonian dynamics with log-oscillators
• Failure of Logarithmic Oscillators to Thermostat Small Atomic Clusters
• Violation of the virial theorem and generalized equipartition theorem for logarithmic oscillators serving as a thermostat