Alternatives to standard puncture initial data for binary black hole evolution
arXiv:1205.5502 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.86.064003
Abstract
Standard puncture initial data have been widely used for numerical binary black hole evolutions despite their shortcomings, most notably the inherent lack of gravitational radiation at the initial time that is later followed by a burst of spurious radiation. We study the evolution of three alternative initial data schemes. Two of the three alternatives are based on post-Newtonian expansions that contain realistic gravitational waves. The first scheme is based on a second-order post-Newtonian expansion in Arnowitt, Deser, and Misner transverse-traceless (ADMTT) gauge that has been resummed to approach standard puncture data at the black holes. The second scheme is based on asymptotic matching of the 4-metrics of two tidally perturbed Schwarzschild solutions to a first-order post-Newtonian expansion in ADMTT gauge away from the black holes. The final alternative is obtained through asymptotic matching of the 4-metrics of two tidally perturbed Schwarzschild solutions to a second-order post-Newtonian expansion in harmonic gauge away from the black holes. When evolved, the second scheme fails to produce quasicircular orbits (and instead leads to a nearly head-on collision). This failure can be traced back to inaccuracies in the extrinsic curvature due to low order matching. More encouraging is that the latter two alternatives lead to quasicircular orbits and show gravitational radiation from the onset of the evolution, as well as a reduction of spurious radiation. Current deficiencies compared to standard punctures data include more eccentric trajectories during the inspiral and larger constraint violations, since the alternative data sets are only approximate solutions of Einstein's equations. The eccentricity problem can be ameliorated by adjusting the initial momentum parameters.
arXiv comment11 pages, 11 figures, 1 appendix, typos corrected, removed duplicate reference, matches published version
References in corpus (29)
- Evolution of Binary Black Hole Spacetimes
- Accurate Evolutions of Orbiting Black-Hole Binaries Without Excision
- Gravitational wave extraction from an inspiraling configuration of merging black holes
- On the Numerical Integration of Einstein's Field Equations
- LIGO: The Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory
- Gauge conditions for long-term numerical black hole evolutions without excision
- A simple construction of initial data for multiple black holes
- New Formalism for Numerical Relativity
- Calibration of Moving Puncture Simulations
- A single-domain spectral method for black hole puncture data
- 3rd post-Newtonian higher order Hamilton dynamics for two-body point-mass systems
- Initial Data for Numerical Relativity
- Numerical simulation of orbiting black holes
- Numerical Relativity and Compact Binaries
- How to move a black hole without excision: gauge conditions for the numerical evolution of a moving puncture
- High-spin binary black hole mergers
- Reducing phase error in long numerical binary black hole evolutions with sixth order finite differencing
- Excision without excision: the relativistic turducken
- Binary black hole initial data for numerical general relativity based on post-Newtonian data
- Pseudo-spectral apparent horizon finders: an efficient new algorithm
- Conformally curved binary black hole initial data including tidal deformations and outgoing radiation
- Binary black hole initial data from matched asymptotic expansions
- Test-beds and applications for apparent horizon finders in numerical relativity
- Reducing spurious gravitational radiation in binary-black-hole simulations by using conformally curved initial data
- Black hole puncture initial data with realistic gravitational wave content
- Improved initial data for black hole binaries by asymptotic matching of post-Newtonian and perturbed black hole solutions
- A Simple method to set up low eccentricity initial data for moving puncture simulations
- Post-Newtonian Initial Data with Waves: Progress in Evolution
- Hybrid black-hole binary initial data
Cited by in corpus (17)
- Compact binary evolutions with the Z4c formulation
- Binary Neutron Stars with Generic Spin, Eccentricity, Mass ratio, and Compactness - Quasi-equilibrium Sequences and First Evolutions
- Tidal deformation of a slowly rotating black hole
- The Overlap of Numerical Relativity, Perturbation Theory and Post-Newtonian Theory in the Binary Black Hole Problem
- Tidal heating and torquing of a Kerr black hole to next-to-leading order in the tidal coupling
- Gravitational Wave Flux and Quadrupole Modes from Quasi-Circular Non-Spinning Compact Binaries to the Fourth Post-Newtonian Order
- Conformal Thin-Sandwich Solver for Generic Initial Data
- Initial data for binary neutron stars with adjustable eccentricity
- The initial value problem as it relates to numerical relativity
- Approximate black hole binary spacetime via asymptotic matching
- Numerical relativity simulations of thick accretion disks around tilted Kerr black holes
- Elliptica: a new pseudo-spectral code for the construction of initial data
- Including realistic tidal deformations in binary black-hole initial data
- Parameter control for eccentric, precessing binary black hole simulations with SpEC
- Solving the Hamiltonian constraint for 1+log trumpets
- Extending superposed harmonic initial data to higher spin
- Inspiraling black-hole binary spacetimes: Challenges in transitioning from analytical to numerical techniques