A Not-So-Fundamental Limitation on Studying Complex Systems with Statistics: Comment on Rabin (2011)

Abstract

Although living organisms are affected by many interrelated and unidentified variables, this complexity does not automatically impose a fundamental limitation on statistical inference. Nor need one invoke such complexity as an explanation of the "Truth Wears Off" or "decline" effect; similar "decline" effects occur with far simpler systems studied in physics. Selective reporting and publication bias, and scientists' biases in favour of reporting eye-catching results (in general) or conforming to others' results (in physics) better explain this feature of the "Truth Wears Off" effect than Rabin's suggested limitation on statistical inference.

4 pages, no figures, 11 references. Commentary on Y. Rabin, Journal of Statistical Physics, 144, 213-216 (2011)