Misleading variations in estimated rotational frequency splittings of solar p modes: Consequences for helio- and asteroseismology
arXiv:1204.1168 · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2966.2012.20868.x
Abstract
The aim of this paper is to investigate whether there are any 11-yr or quasi-biennial solar cycle-related variations in solar rotational splitting frequencies of low-degree solar p modes. Although no 11-yr signals were observed, variations on a shorter timescale (~2yrs) were apparent. We show that the variations arose from complications/artifacts associated with the realization noise in the data and the process by which the data were analyzed. More specifically, the realization noise was observed to have a larger effect on the rotational splittings than accounted for by the formal uncertainties. When used to infer the rotation profile of the Sun these variations are not important. The outer regions of the solar interior can be constrained using higher-degree modes. While the variations in the low-l splittings do make large differences to the inferred rotation rate of the core, the core rotation rate is so poorly constrained, even by low-l modes, that the different inferred rotation profiles still agree within their respective 1sigma uncertainties. By contrast, in asteroseismology, only low-l modes are visible and so higher-l modes cannot be used to constrain the rotation profile of stars. Furthermore, we usually only have one data set from which to measure the observed low-l splitting. In such circumstances the inferred internal rotation rate of a main sequence star could differ significantly from estimates of the surface rotation rate, hence leading to spurious conclusions. Therefore, extreme care must be taken when using only the splittings of low-l modes to draw conclusions about the average internal rotation rate of a star.
10 pages, 7 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS
References in corpus (13)
- Fast core rotation in red-giant stars revealed by gravity-dominated mixed modes
- Ensemble Asteroseismology of Solar-Type Stars with the NASA Kepler Mission
- CoRoT reveals a magnetic activity cycle in a Sun-like star
- Rotation speed and stellar axis inclination from p modes: How CoRoT would see other suns
- Accurate p-mode measurements of the G0V metal-rich CoRoT target HD 52265
- Sensitivity of helioseismic gravity modes to the dynamics of the solar core
- Is the current lack of solar activity only skin deep?
- On deriving p-mode parameters for inclined solar-like stars
- solarFLAG hare and hounds: on the extraction of rotational p-mode splittings from seismic, Sun-as-a-star data
- About the p-mode frequency shifts in HD 49933
- Influence of Low-Degree High-Order p-Mode Splittings on the Solar Rotation Profile
- AsteroFLAG: first results from hare-and-hounds Exercise 1
- Sun-as-a-star observations: evidence for degree dependence of changes in damping of low-l p modes along the solar cycle