Assessing the Significance of Apparent Correlations Between Radio and Gamma-ray Blazar Fluxes

Abstract

Whether a correlation exists between the radio and gamma-ray flux densities of blazars is a long-standing question, and one that is difficult to answer confidently because of various observational biases which may either dilute or apparently enhance any intrinsic correlation between radio and gamma-ray luminosities. We introduce a novel method of data randomization to evaluate quantitatively the effect of these biases and to assess the intrinsic significance of an apparent correlation between radio and gamma-ray flux densities of blazars. The novelty of the method lies in a combination of data randomization in luminosity space (to ensure that the randomized data are intrinsically, and not just apparently, uncorrelated) and significance assessment in flux space (to explicitly avoid Malmquist bias and automatically account for the limited dynamical range in both frequencies). The method is applicable even to small samples that are not selected with strict statistical criteria. For larger samples we describe a variation of the method in which the sample is split in redshift bins, and the randomization is applied in each bin individually; this variation is designed to yield the equivalent to luminosity-function sampling of the underlying population in the limit of very large, statistically complete samples. We show that for a smaller number of redshift bins, the method yields a worse significance, and in this way it is conservative in that it does not assign a stronger, artificially enhanced significance. We demonstrate how our test performs as a function of number of sources, strength of correlation, and number of redshift bins used, and we show that while our test is robust against common-distance biases and associated false positives for uncorrelated data, it retains the power of other methods in rejecting the null hypothesis of no correlation for correlated data.

(corrected affiliations) 14 pages, 11 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (7)

• Blazars in the Fermi Era: The OVRO 40-m Telescope Monitoring Program
• Bright AGN Source List from the First Three Months of the Fermi Large Area Telescope All-Sky Survey
• CGRaBS: An All-Sky Survey of Gamma-Ray Blazar Candidates
• On the relation between AGN gamma-ray emission and parsec-scale radio jets
• The radio/gamma-ray connection in Active Galactic Nuclei in the era of the Fermi Large Area Telescope
• Components of the Extragalactic Gamma Ray Background
• The Radio to Gamma Ray Connection of EGRET Blazars: Correlation, Regression and Monte Carlo Analysis

Cited by in corpus (24)

• Time-correlation between the radio and gamma-ray activity in blazars and the production site of the gamma-ray emission
• Connecting radio variability to the characteristics of gamma-ray blazars
• Connection between optical and gamma-ray variability in blazars
• First-Epoch VLBA Imaging of Twenty New TeV Blazars
• Refining the associations of the Fermi Large Area Telescope Source Catalogs
• High-energy sources at low radio frequency: the Murchison Widefield Array view of Fermi blazars
• Beaming Effect in Fermi Blazars
• Population statistics of beamed sources. II: Evaluation of Doppler factor estimates
• Optical and Radio variability of the Northern VHE gamma-ray emitting BL Lac objects
• Optical monitoring of BL Lac object S5 0716+714 and FSRQ 3C273 from 2000 to 2014
• Population statistics of beamed sources. I: A new model for blazars
• Blazars in the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey First Data Release
• The observed radio/gamma-ray emission correlation for blazars with the Fermi-LAT and the RATAN-600 data
• Exploring the connection between radio and GeV-TeV gamma-ray emission in the 1FHL and 2FHL AGN samples
• Multi-Frequency Study of Spectral Indices of BL Lacertae Objects and Flat Spectrum Radio Quasars
• Waveband Luminosity Correlations in Flux-Limited Multiwavelength Data
• Radio spectral properties of cores and extended regions in blazars in the MHz regime
• The Parsec-Scale Structure of the Newer TeV Blazars
• Estimating the distribution of rest-frame timescales for blazar jets: a statistical approach
• On The Relation Between the AGN Jet and Accretion Disk Emissions
• Scheduling and calibration strategy for continuous radio monitoring of 1700 sources every three days
• On the Evolution of Seyfert galaxies, BL Lacertae objects and Flat-spectrum radio quasars
• JD6 - The Connection between Radio Properties and High Energy Emission in AGNs
• The connection between the 15 GHz radio and gamma-ray emission in blazars