Structure of finite sphere packings via exact enumeration: Implications for colloidal crystal nucleation

Abstract

We analyze the geometric structure and mechanical stability of a complete set of isostatic and hyperstatic sphere packings obtained via exact enumeration. The number of nonisomorphic isostatic packings grows exponentially with the number of spheres $N$, and their diversity of structure and symmetry increases with increasing $N$ and decreases with increasing hyperstaticity $H\equiv N_c-N_{ISO}$, where $N_c$ is the number of pair contacts and $N_{ISO}=3N-6$. Maximally contacting packings are in general neither the densest nor the most symmetric. Analyses of local structure show that the fraction $f$ of nuclei with order compatible with the bulk (RHCP) crystal decreases sharply with increasing $N$ due to a high propensity for stacking faults, 5- and near-5-fold symmetric structures, and other motifs that preclude RHCP order. While $f$ increases with increasing $H$, a significant fraction of hyperstatic nuclei for $N$ as small as 11 retain non-RHCP structure. Classical theories of nucleation that consider only spherical nuclei, or only nuclei with the same ordering as the bulk crystal, cannot capture such effects. Our results provide an explanation for the failure of classical nucleation theory for hard-sphere systems of $N\lesssim 10$ particles; we argue that in this size regime, it is essential to consider nuclei of unconstrained geometry. Our results are also applicable to understanding kinetic arrest and jamming in systems that interact via hard-core-like repulsive and short-ranged attractive interactions.

Improved discussion and referencing. Accepted for publication in Phys. Rev. E

References in corpus (6)

• Jamming at Zero Temperature and Zero Applied Stress: the Epitome of Disorder
• Crystallization of hard-sphere glasses
• Deriving Finite Sphere Packings
• The effect of attractions on the local structure of liquids and colloidal fluids
• Gas-solid coexistence of adhesive spheres
• C60: the first one-component gel?

Cited by in corpus (19)

• Numerical calculation of granular entropy
• A geometrical approach to computing free energy landscapes from short-ranged potentials
• Two-Dimensional Clusters of Colloidal Spheres: Ground States, Excited States, and Structural Rearrangements
• Enumerating rigid sphere packings
• From Sticky-Hard-Sphere to Lennard-Jones-Type Clusters
• Sticky-sphere clusters
• Structure and dynamics of model colloidal clusters with short-range attractions
• Free energy of singular sticky-sphere clusters
• Physical interpretation of the partition function for colloidal clusters
• Electronic and magnetic properties of Co_n Mo_m nanoclusters with n+m = x and 2<=x<=6 atoms from DFT calculations
• Arch-based configurations in the volume ensemble of static granular systems
• The Gregory-Newton Problem for Kissing Sticky Spheres
• From canyons to valleys: Numerically continuing sticky hard sphere clusters to the landscapes of smoother potentials
• Diffusion dynamics for an infinite system of two-type spheres and the associated depletion effect
• On Contact Numbers of Finite Lattice Sphere Packings of 20-27 Balls
• Atlasing of Assembly Landscapes using Distance Geometry and Graph Rigidity
• On the Contact Numbers of Ball Packings on Various Hexagonal Grids
• Minimal energy packings of nearly flexible polymers
• Efficient Atlasing and Search of Configuration Spaces of Point-Sets Constrained by Distance Intervals