Including robustness in multi-criteria optimization for intensity-modulated proton therapy

Abstract

We present a method to include robustness into a multi-criteria optimization (MCO) framework for intensity-modulated proton therapy (IMPT). The approach allows one to simultaneously explore the trade-off between different objectives as well as the trade-off between robustness and nominal plan quality. In MCO, a database of plans each emphasizing different treatment planning objectives, is pre-computed to approximate the Pareto surface. An IMPT treatment plan that strikes the best balance between the different objectives can be selected by navigating on the Pareto surface. In our approach, robustness is integrated into MCO by adding robustified objectives and constraints to the MCO problem. Uncertainties of the robust problem are modeled by pre-calculated dose-influence matrices for a nominal scenario and a number of pre-defined error scenarios. A robustified objective represents the worst objective function value that can be realized for any of the error scenarios. The optimization method is based on a linear projection solver and is capable of handling large problem sizes resulting from a fine dose grid resolution, many scenarios, and a large number of proton pencil beams. A base-of-skull case is used to demonstrate the robust optimization method. It is demonstrated that the robust optimizationmethod reduces the sensitivity of the treatment plan to setup and range errors to a degree that is not achieved by a safety margin approach. A chordoma case is analyzed in more detail to demonstrate the involved tradeoffs between target underdose and brainstem sparing as well as robustness and nominal plan quality. The latter illustrates the advantage of MCO in the context of robust planning. For all cases examined, the robust optimization for each Pareto optimal plan takes less than 5 min on a standard computer, making a computationally friendly interface possible to the planner.

19 pages, 6 figures, to appear on Physics in medicine and biology

Cited by in corpus (11)

• Necessary and sufficient conditions for Pareto efficiency in robust multiobjective optimization
• The clinical target distribution: a probabilistic alternative to the clinical target volume
• Deep-Learning-based Fast and Accurate 3D CT Deformable Image Registration in Lung Cancer
• The scenario-based generalization of radiation therapy margins
• A Convex Optimization Approach to Radiation Treatment Planning with Dose Constraints
• Fast approximate delivery of fluence maps: the VMAT case
• Towards Robust Adaptive Radiation Therapy Strategies
• Does the greater power of pencil beam scanning reduce the need for a proton gantry? A study of head-and-neck and brain tumors
• Scenario-free robust optimization algorithm for IMRT and IMPT treatment planning
• A novel multi-stage multi-scenario multi-objective optimisation framework for adaptive robust decision-making under deep uncertainty
• Guaranteed $\epsilon$-optimal solutions with the linear optimizer ART3+O