Depletion potentials in highly size-asymmetric binary hard-sphere mixtures: Comparison of accurate simulation results with theory

Abstract

We report a detailed study, using state-of-the-art simulation and theoretical methods, of the depletion potential between a pair of big hard spheres immersed in a reservoir of much smaller hard spheres, the size disparity being measured by the ratio of diameters q=σ_s/σ_b. Small particles are treated grand canonically, their influence being parameterized in terms of their packing fraction in the reservoir, η_s^r. Two specialized Monte Carlo simulation schemes --the geometrical cluster algorithm, and staged particle insertion-- are deployed to obtain accurate depletion potentials for a number of combinations of q\leq 0.1 and η_s^r. After applying corrections for simulation finite-size effects, the depletion potentials are compared with the prediction of new density functional theory (DFT) calculations based on the insertion trick using the Rosenfeld functional and several subsequent modifications. While agreement between the DFT and simulation is generally good, significant discrepancies are evident at the largest reservoir packing fraction accessible to our simulation methods, namely η_s^r=0.35. These discrepancies are, however, small compared to those between simulation and the much poorer predictions of the Derjaguin approximation at this η_s^r. The recently proposed morphometric approximation performs better than Derjaguin but is somewhat poorer than DFT for the size ratios and small sphere packing fractions that we consider. The effective potentials from simulation, DFT and the morphometric approximation were used to compute the second virial coefficient B_2 as a function of η_s^r. Comparison of the results enables an assessment of the extent to which DFT can be expected to correctly predict the propensity towards fluid fluid phase separation in additive binary hard sphere mixtures with q\leq 0.1.

16 pages, 9 figures, revised treatment of morphometric approximation and reordered some material

References in corpus (5)

• Density functional theory for hard-sphere mixtures: the White-Bear version Mark II
• Depletion force between two large spheres suspended in a bath of small spheres: Onset of the Derjaguin limit
• Equilibrium route to colloidal gellation: mixtures of hard sphere-like colloids
• Pair interactions between complex mesoscopic particles from Widom's particle-insertion method
• Selective-pivot sampling of radial distribution functions in asymmetric liquid mixtures

Cited by in corpus (25)

• Colloidal Hard Spheres: Triumphs, Challenges and Mysteries
• Yielding of binary colloidal glasses
• Simulating the Entropic Collapse of Coarse-Grained Chromosomes
• Phase coexistence of active Brownian particles
• Structural and Thermodynamic Properties of Hard-Sphere Fluids
• Coarse-Grained Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Depletion-Induced Interactions for Soft Matter Systems
• On the decay of the pair correlation function and the line of vanishing excess isothermal compressibility in simple fluids
• Bulk fluid phase behaviour of colloidal platelet-sphere and platelet-polymer mixtures
• Three-body interactions in complex fluids: virial coefficients from simulation finite-size effects
• The effective colloid interaction in the Asakura-Oosawa model. Assessment of non-pairwise terms from the virial expansion
• Quantifying the effects of neglecting many-body interactions in coarse-grained models of complex fluids
• Depletion force in the infinite-dilution limit in a solvent of nonadditive hard spheres
• Correction of coarse-graining errors by a two-level method: application to the Asakura-Oosawa model
• Coarse-grained depletion potentials for anisotropic colloids: application to lock-and-key systems
• Virial coefficients and demixing in the Asakura-Oosawa model
• Determining depletion interactions by contracting forces
• Communication: Virial coefficients and demixing in highly asymmetric binary additive hard-sphere mixtures
• The solvent mediated interaction potential between solute particles: Theory and applications
• Monte Carlo methods for estimating depletion potentials in highly size-asymmetrical hard sphere mixtures
• Solvent mediated forces in critical fluids
• Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Binary Sphere Mixtures
• Many-body correlations from integral geometry
• Effective one-body interactions due to the presence of a liquid-vapor interface
• Multilevel simulation of hard-sphere mixtures
• Critical point for de-mixing of binary hard spheres