Comments on (super)luminality

Abstract

Recently, in an interesting work arXiv:1106.3972 a solution of the equations of motion of massive gravity was discussed, and it was shown that one of the fluctuations on that solution is superluminal. It was also stated that this rules out massive gravity. Here we find that the solution itself is rather unphysical. For this we show that there is another mode on the same background which grows and overcomes the background in an arbitrarily short period of time, that can be excited by a negligible cost in energy. This solution is triggered by the parameter governing the superluminality. Furthermore, we also show that the solution, if viewed as a perfect fluid, has no rest frame, or that the Lorentz transformation that is needed to boost to the rest frame is superluminal itself. The stress-tensor of this fluid has complex eigenvalues, and could not be obtained from any physically sensible matter. Moreover, for the same setup we find another background solution, fluctuations of which are all stable and subluminal. Based on these results, we conclude that the superluminality found in arXiv:1106.3972 is an artifact of using an inappropriate background, nevertheless, this solution represents an instructive example for understanding massive gravity. For instance, on this background the Boulware-Deser ghost is absent, even though this may naively appear not to be the case.

12 pages. v2: improved and expanded version: certain statements corrected, appendix added; the conclusion unchanged

References in corpus (14)

• Resummation of Massive Gravity
• Theoretical Aspects of Massive Gravity
• Resolving the Ghost Problem in non-Linear Massive Gravity
• On Non-Linear Actions for Massive Gravity
• Ghost free Massive Gravity in the Stückelberg language
• Analytic solutions in non-linear massive gravity
• Strong interactions and exact solutions in non-linear massive gravity
• Cosmic Acceleration and the Helicity-0 Graviton
• Cosmology of the Galileon from Massive Gravity
• Exact Schwarzschild-de Sitter black holes in a family of massive gravity models
• Massive Gravity Simplified: A Quadratic Action
• Vainshtein Mechanism In ${\Lambda }_3$ - Theories
• Stars and Black Holes in Massive Gravity
• All Fierz-Paulian massive gravity theories have ghosts or superluminal modes

Cited by in corpus (18)

• Beyond the Cosmological Standard Model
• Massive Gravity
• Theoretical Aspects of Massive Gravity
• Momentum relaxation in holographic massive gravity
• Nonlinear stability of cosmological solutions in massive gravity
• A non-local theory of massive gravity
• Evidence for and Obstructions to Non-Linear Partially Massless Gravity
• The Self-Accelerating Universe with Vectors in Massive Gravity
• Non-Linear Massive Gravity with Additional Primary Constraint and Absence of Ghosts
• Deconstructing Dimensions and Massive Gravity
• Cosmology and perturbations in massive gravity
• Comments About Hamiltonian Formulation of Non-Linear Massive Gravity with Stuckelberg Fields
• Remark About Hamiltonian Formulation of Non-Linear Massive Gravity in Stuckelberg Formalism
• One-loop divergences in massive gravity theory
• Black hole discharge in massive electrodynamics and black hole disappearance in massive gravity
• Massive spin-2 particle from a rank-2 tensor
• Superluminal Vector in Ghost-free Massive Gravity
• Massive Gravity: A Lorentz-Symmetric Aether