Critical Differences and Clues in Eta Car's 2009 Event

Abstract

We monitored Eta Carinae with HST WFPC2 and Gemini GMOS throughout the 2009 spectroscopic event, which was expected to differ from its predecessor in 2003 (Davidson et al. 2005). Here we report major observed differences between events, and their implications. Some of these results were quite unexpected. (1) The UV brightness minimum was much deeper in 2009. This suggests that physical conditions in the early stages of an event depend on different parameters than the "normal" inter-event wind. Extra mass ejection from the primary star is one possible cause. (2) The expected He II 4687 brightness maximum was followed several weeks later by another. We explain why this fact, and the timing of the 4687 maxima, strongly support a "shock breakup" hypothesis for X-ray and 4687 behavior as proposed 5-10 years ago. (3) We observed a polar view of the star via light reflected by dust in the Homunculus nebula. Surprisingly, at that location the variations of emission-line brightness and Doppler velocities closely resembled a direct view of the star; which should not have been true for any phenomena related to the orbit. This result casts very serious doubt on all the proposed velocity interpretations that depend on the secondary star's orbital motion. (4) Latitude-dependent variations of H I, He I and Fe II features reveal aspects of wind behavior during the event. In addition, we discuss implications of the observations for several crucial unsolved problems.

45 pages, 9 figures, submitted to ApJ

References in corpus (11)

• Chemical evolution of galaxies. I. A composition-dependent SPH model for chemical evolution and cooling
• A multispectral view of the periodic events in eta Carinae
• The Early Spectra of Eta Carinae 1892 to 1941 and the Onset of Its High Excitation Emission Spectrum
• The Chrysalis Opens? Photometry from the Eta Carinae HST Treasury Project, 2002-2006
• He II 4686 in eta Carinae: collapse of the wind-wind collision region during periastron passage
• Long-Term Optical Monitoring of Eta Carinae. Multiband light curves for a complete orbital period
• Accretion onto the Companion of Eta Carinae During the Spectroscopic Event: III. the He II 4686 Line
• The Eta Carinae optical 2009.0 event, a new "eclipse-like" phenomenon
• The Orientation of the Eta Carinae Binary System
• Explaining the Early Exit of Eta Carinae from its 2009 X-Ray Minimum with the Accretion Model
• N II 5668-5712, a New Class of Spectral Features in Eta Carinae

Cited by in corpus (24)

• Constraining the Absolute Orientation of Eta Carinae's Binary Orbit: A 3-D Dynamical Model for the Broad [Fe III] Emission
• Constraints on decreases in Eta Carinae's mass loss from 3D hydrodynamic simulations of its binary colliding winds
• On the influence of the companion star in Eta Carinae: 2D radiative transfer modeling of the ultraviolet and optical spectra
• He II $\lambda$4686 emission from the massive binary system in $\eta$ Car: constraints to the orbital elements and the nature of the periodic minima
• He II 4686 in eta Carinae: collapse of the wind-wind collision region during periastron passage
• Secular Changes in Eta Carinae's Wind 1998-2011
• X-ray Emission from Eta Carinae near Periastron in 2009 I: A Two State Solution
• Eta Carinae's 2014.6 Spectroscopic Event: Clues to the Long-term Recovery from its Great Eruption
• 3D radiative transfer simulations of Eta Carinae's inner colliding winds - I. Ionization structure of helium at apastron
• A Lighthouse Effect in Eta Carinae
• Eta Carinae's 2014.6 Spectroscopic Event: The Extraordinary He II and N II Features
• VLTI-AMBER velocity-resolved aperture-synthesis imaging of Eta Carinae with a spectral resolution of 12000. Studies of the primary star wind and innermost wind-wind collision
• Uncovering the orbital dynamics of stars hidden inside their powerful winds: application to $\eta$ Carinae and RMC 140
• Orbital Parameters for the $250M_{\odot }$ Eta Carinae Binary System
• The Wolf-Rayet + Black Hole Binary NGC 300 X-1: What is the Mass of the Black Hole?
• 3D Radiative Transfer in $\eta$ Carinae: Application of the SimpleX Algorithm to 3D SPH Simulations of Binary Colliding Winds
• Near-Infrared Evidence for a Sudden Temperature Increase in Eta Carinae
• 3D radiative transfer simulations of Eta Carinae's inner colliding winds - II: Ionization structure of helium at periastron
• The Optical Wind Line Variability of $\eta$ Carinae During the 2009.0 Event
• Eta Carinae's Declining Outflow Seen in the UV, 2002-2015
• The orbital kinematics of eta Carinae over three periastra with a possible detection of the elusive secondary's motion
• Eta Carinae -- Physics of the Inner Ejecta
• Changes in the Na D${}_1$ Absorption Components of $\eta$ Carinae Provide Clues on the Location of the Dissipating Central Occulter
• The orientation of Eta Carinae and the powering mechanism of intermediate luminosity optical transients (ILOTs)