A critical view on transport and entanglement in models of photosynthesis

Abstract

We revisit critically the recent claims, inspired by quantum optics and quantum information, that there is entanglement in the biological pigment protein complexes, and that it is responsible for the high transport efficiency. While unexpectedly long coherence times were experimentally demonstrated, the existence of entanglement is, at the moment, a purely theoretical conjecture; it is this conjecture that we analyze. As demonstrated by a toy model, a similar transport phenomenology can be obtained without generating entanglement. Furthermore, we also argue that even if entanglement does exist, it is purely incidental and seems to plays no essential role for the transport efficiency. We emphasize that our paper is not a proof that entanglement does not exist in light-harvesting complexes - this would require a knowledge of the system and its parameters well beyond the state of the art. Rather, we present a counter-example to the recent claims of entanglement, showing that the arguments, as they stand at the moment, are not sufficiently justified and hence cannot be taken as proof for the existence of entanglement, let alone of its essential role, in the excitation transport.

16 pages, 1 figure, published version; typos corrected

References in corpus (5)

• Entanglement detection
• Highly efficient energy excitation transfer in light-harvesting complexes: The fundamental role of noise-assisted transport
• Femtosecond Coherence and Quantum Control of Single Molecules at Room Temperature
• On the Equivalence of Quantum and Classical Coherence in Electronic Energy Transfer
• Quantum entanglement phenomena in photosynthetic light harvesting complexes

Cited by in corpus (23)

• A quantitative theory of coherent delocalization
• Device-independent entanglement quantification and related applications
• Heat transport through lattices of quantum harmonic oscillators in arbitrary dimensions
• Cooperativity in light scattering by cold atoms
• Quantum transport efficiency and Fourier's law
• Certification and Quantification of Multilevel Quantum Coherence
• Hierarchies of multi-partite entanglement
• Quantum transport in quantum networks and photosynthetic complexes at the steady state
• Entanglement in helium
• Highly-efficient noise-assisted energy transport in classical oscillator systems
• Excitation energy transfer efficiency: equivalence of transient and stationary setting and the absence of non-Markovian effects
• Stationary quantum coherence and transport in disordered networks
• Toward quantum simulations of biological information flow
• A Method of Developing Analytical Multipartite Delocalization Measures for Mixed W-like States
• Classification scheme of pure multipartite states based on topological phases
• Tailoring many-body entanglement through local control
• Accessible quantification of multiparticle entanglement
• Coherent delocalization: Views of entanglement in different scenarios
• Global coherence of quantum evolutions based on decoherent histories: theory and application to photosynthetic quantum energy transport
• Functional quantum biology in photosynthesis and magnetoreception
• Photosynthetic properties assisted by the quantum entanglement in two adjacent pigment molecules
• Quantum metrology and its application in biology
• An excitation-dependent four-level model for quantum entanglement in photosynthetic systems