Assumptions of IV Methods for Observational Epidemiology

Abstract

Instrumental variable (IV) methods are becoming increasingly popular as they seem to offer the only viable way to overcome the problem of unobserved confounding in observational studies. However, some attention has to be paid to the details, as not all such methods target the same causal parameters and some rely on more restrictive parametric assumptions than others. We therefore discuss and contrast the most common IV approaches with relevance to typical applications in observational epidemiology. Further, we illustrate and compare the asymptotic bias of these IV estimators when underlying assumptions are violated in a numerical study. One of our conclusions is that all IV methods encounter problems in the presence of effect modification by unobserved confounders. Since this can never be ruled out for sure, we recommend that practical applications of IV estimators be accompanied routinely by a sensitivity analysis.

Published in at http://dx.doi.org/10.1214/09-STS316 the Statistical Science (http://www.imstat.org/sts/) by the Institute of Mathematical Statistics (http://www.imstat.org)

References in corpus (2)

• Instrumentality Tests Revisited
• Causal Bounds and Instruments

Cited by in corpus (23)

• On Instrumental Variables Estimation of Causal Odds Ratios
• Regularization Methods for High-Dimensional Instrumental Variables Regression With an Application to Genetical Genomics
• Integrating summarized data from multiple genetic variants in Mendelian randomization: bias and coverage properties of inverse-variance weighted methods
• The GENIUS Approach to Robust Mendelian Randomization Inference
• Half-trek criterion for generic identifiability of linear structural equation models
• Exact parametric causal mediation analysis for a binary outcome with a binary mediator
• Distributional robustness of K-class estimators and the PULSE
• Nonparametric instrumental regression with non-convex constraints
• Selective Machine Learning of the Average Treatment Effect with an Invalid Instrumental Variable
• Mediation analysis with case-control sampling: Identification and estimation in the presence of a binary mediator
• Robustness and efficiency of covariate adjusted linear instrumental variable estimators
• Identifying Causal Effects using Instrumental Time Series: Nuisance IV and Correcting for the Past
• Towards personalized causal inference of medication response in mobile health: an instrumental variable approach for randomized trials with imperfect compliance
• Sensitivity Analysis of G-estimators to Invalid Instrumental Variables
• On falsification of the binary instrumental variable model
• Regression Discontinuity Designs: A Decision Theoretic Approach
• Estimation of the Number Needed to Treat, the Number Needed to be Exposed, and the Exposure Impact Number with Instrumental Variables
• On the physical interpretation of a meta-analysis in the presence of heterogeneity and bias: from clinical trials to Mendelian randomization
• Model-assisted complier average treatment effect estimates in randomized experiments with non-compliance and a binary outcome
• Determinantal Generalizations of Instrumental Variables
• Magnitude of selection bias in road safety epidemiology, a primer
• Causality and Generalizability: Identifiability and Learning Methods
• Causal inference to detect selection bias in road safety epidemiology