Reply to arXiv:1006.2126 by Giovanni Amelino-Camelia et al
arXiv:1006.4587
Abstract
It was previously shown that models with deformations of special relativity that have an energy-dependent yet observer-independent speed of light suffer from nonlocal effects that are in conflict with observation to very high precision. In a recent preprint it has been claimed that this conclusion is false. This claim was made by writing down expressions for modified Lorentz-transformations the use of which does not reproduce the result. I will show here that the failure to reproduce the result is not a consequence of a novel and improved calculation, but a consequence of repeating the same calculation but making an assumption that is in conflict with the assumptions made to produce the original scenario. I will here explain what the physical meaning of either assumption is and why the original assumption is the physically meaningful one. I will then further explain why even making the differing assumption does not remove but merely shift the problem and why the bound derived by Amelino-Camelia et al is wrong.
arXiv commentUpdate in reply to update of arXiv:1006.2126
References in corpus (16)
- Generalized Lorentz invariance with an invariant energy scale
- Testing Einstein's special relativity with Fermi's short hard gamma-ray burst GRB090510
- Probing quantum gravity using photons from a flare of the active galactic nucleus Markarian 501 observed by the MAGIC telescope
- Lorentz-violation-induced arrival delays of cosmological particles
- Observer-independent quanta of mass and length
- Quantum-Gravity Analysis of Gamma-Ray Bursts using Wavelets
- Prospects for constraining quantum gravity dispersion with near term observations
- Non-Linear Relativity in Position Space
- Taming nonlocality in theories with Planck-scale-deformed Lorentz symmetry
- Bounds on an energy-dependent and observer-independent speed of light from violations of locality
- Quantum Time Uncertainty in a Gravity's Rainbow Formalism
- Modifications to Lorentz invariant dispersion in relatively boosted frames
- Classical paradoxes of locality and their possible quantum resolutions in deformed special relativity
- Doubly Special Relativity: facts and prospects
- The Box-Problem in Deformed Special Relativity
- Comments on Nonlocality in Deformed Special Relativity, in reply to arXiv:1004.0664 by Lee Smolin and arXiv:1004.0575 by Jacob et al
Cited by in corpus (10)
- Minimal Length Scale Scenarios for Quantum Gravity
- Deformed General Relativity
- Kappa Snyder deformations of Minkowski spacetime, realizations and Hopf algebra
- -Minkowski Spacetimes and DSR Algebras: Fresh Look and Old Problems
- The DSR-deformed relativistic symmetries and the relative locality of 3D quantum gravity
- Experimental Search for Quantum Gravity
- Inertial frames without the relativity principle
- On limitations of the extent of inertial frames in non-commutative relativistic spacetimes
- Comment on arXiv:1007.0718 by Lee Smolin
- Quantum superpositions of the speed of light