Comparing the energy spectra of ultra-high energy cosmic rays measured with EAS arrays

Abstract

The energy spectra of ultra-high energy cosmic rays (CRs) measured with giant extensive air shower (EAS) arrays exhibit discrepancies between the flux intensities and/or estimated CR energies exceeding experimental errors. The well-known intensity correction factor due to the dispersion of the measured quantity in the presence of a rapidly falling energy spectrum is insufficient to explain the divergence. Another source of systematic energy determination error is proposed concerning the charged particle density measured with the surface arrays, which arises due to simplifications (namely, the superposition approximation) in nucleus-nucleus interaction description applied to the shower modeling. Making use of the essential correction factors results in congruous CR energy spectra within experimental errors. Residual differences in the energy scales of giant arrays can be attributed to the actual overall accuracy of the EAS detection technique used. CR acceleration and propagation model simulations using the dip and ankle scenarios of the transition from galactic to extragalactic CR components are in agreement with the combined energy spectrum observed with EAS arrays.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (17)

• First Observation of the Greisen-Zatsepin-Kuzmin Suppression
• Energy determination in the Akeno Giant Air Shower Array experiment
• Measurement of the Cosmic Ray Energy Spectrum and Composition from 10^{17} to 10^{18.3} eV Using a Hybrid Fluorescence Technique
• A Study of the Composition of Ultra High Energy Cosmic Rays Using the High Resolution Fly's Eye
• A dip in the UHECR spectrum and the transition from galactic to extragalactic cosmic rays
• Extensive Air Shower Simulations at the Highest Energies
• Measurement of the Flux of Ultra High Energy Cosmic Rays by the Stereo Technique
• Has the GZK suppression been discovered?
• The spectrum features of UHECRs below and surrounding GZK
• Measuring extensive air showers with Cherenkov light detectors of the Yakutsk array: The energy spectrum of cosmic rays
• The Energy Spectrum of Cosmic Rays Above $3\times 10^{17}$ eV as measured with the Haverah Park Array
• Determination of the calorimetric energy in extensive air showers
• Muon content of ultra-high-energy air showers: Yakutsk data versus simulations
• Comparison of AGASA data with CORSIKA simulation
• Astroparticle Physics: Puzzles and Discoveries
• Composition of cosmic rays accelerated in active galactic nuclei
• On UHECR energy estimation algorithms based on the measurement of electromagnetic component parameters in EAS

Cited by in corpus (8)

• Simulations of ultra-high Energy Cosmic Rays in the local Universe and the origin of Cosmic Magnetic Fields
• Angular correlation of cosmic neutrinos with ultrahigh-energy cosmic rays and implications for their sources
• Wide field-of-view Cherenkov telescope for the detection of cosmic rays in coincidence with the Yakutsk extensive air shower array
• Implications of the UHECRs penetration depth measurements
• A minimal width of the arrival direction distribution of ultra-high energy cosmic rays detected with the Yakutsk array
• Large-scale distribution of cosmic rays in right ascension as observed by the Yakutsk array at energies above $10^{18}$ eV
• Zenith angle distribution of cosmic ray showers measured with the Yakutsk array and its application to analysis of arrival directions in equatorial coordinates
• A method to search for correlations of ultra-high energy cosmic ray masses with the large scale structures in the local galaxy density field