Comparing scalar-tensor gravity and f(R)-gravity in the Newtonian limit

Abstract

Recently, a strong debate has been pursued about the Newtonian limit (i.e. small velocity and weak field) of fourth order gravity models. According to some authors, the Newtonian limit of $f(R)$-gravity is equivalent to the one of Brans-Dicke gravity with ${\omega }_{BD}=0$, so that the PPN parameters of these models turn out to be ill defined. In this paper, we carefully discuss this point considering that fourth order gravity models are dynamically equivalent to the O'Hanlon Lagrangian. This is a special case of scalar-tensor gravity characterized only by self-interaction potential and that, in the Newtonian limit, this implies a non-standard behavior that cannot be compared with the usual PPN limit of General Relativity. The result turns out to be completely different from the one of Brans-Dicke theory and in particular suggests that it is misleading to consider the PPN parameters of this theory with ${\omega }_{BD}=0$ in order to characterize the homologous quantities of $f(R)$-gravity. Finally the solutions at Newtonian level, obtained in the Jordan frame for a $f(R)$-gravity, reinterpreted as a scalar-tensor theory, are linked to those in the Einstein frame.

9 pages

References in corpus (7)

• Extended Theories of Gravity and their Cosmological and Astrophysical Applications
• Solar System constraints to general f(R) gravity
• The Newtonian Limit of F(R) gravity
• Solar System tests DO rule out 1/R gravity
• The Newtonian limit of metric gravity theories with quadratic Lagrangians
• Equilibrium hydrostatic equation and Newtonian limit of the singular f(R) gravity
• Solar system tests of scalar field models with an exponential potential

Cited by in corpus (22)

• Hydrostatic equilibrium and stellar structure in f(R)-gravity
• Physical non-equivalence of the Jordan and Einstein frames
• On the 1/c Expansion of f(R) Gravity
• On the gravitational seesaw in higher-derivative gravity
• Galaxy rotation curves in $f(R,\varphi )$-gravity
• Post-Newtonian parameters gamma and beta of scalar-tensor gravity with a general potential
• The Cauchy problem for metric-affine f(R)-gravity in presence of a Klein-Gordon scalar field
• Sub-millimeter Spatial Oscillations of Newton's Constant: Theoretical Models and Laboratory Tests
• $f(R)$ global monopole revisited
• Scalar-tensor representation of $f(R)$ gravity and Birkhoff's theorem
• Post-Newtonian parameter $\gamma$ for multiscalar-tensor gravity with a general potential
• A no-hair theorem for spherically symmetric black holes in $R^2$ gravity
• Weak-field limit of f(R)-gravity in three and more spatial dimensions
• Pressure effects in the weak-field limit of f(R) = R + alpha R^2 gravity
• Phase-space of flat Friedmann-Robertson-Walker models with both a scalar field coupled to matter and radiation
• Wormholes and Naked Singularities in Brans-Dicke cosmology
• Gravitation Astrometric Measurement Experiment
• Light bending in $F\left[g(\square )R\right]$ extended gravity theories
• Strong and weak gravitational field in $R+{\mu }^4/R$ gravity
• Constraining the attractive fifth force in the general free scalar-tensor gravity with solar system experiments
• Self-gravitating systems in Extended Gravity
• Scalar tachyonic instabilities in gravitational backgrounds: Existence and growth rate