Modeling the Subsurface Structure of Sunspots
arXiv:0912.4982 · doi:10.1007/s11207-010-9630-4
Abstract
While sunspots are easily observed at the solar surface, determining their subsurface structure is not trivial. There are two main hypotheses for the subsurface structure of sunspots: the monolithic model and the cluster model. Local helioseismology is the only means by which we can investigate subphotospheric structure. However, as current linear inversion techniques do not yet allow helioseismology to probe the internal structure with sufficient confidence to distinguish between the monolith and cluster models, the development of physically realistic sunspot models are a priority for helioseismologists. This is because they are not only important indicators of the variety of physical effects that may influence helioseismic inferences in active regions, but they also enable detailed assessments of the validity of helioseismic interpretations through numerical forward modeling. In this paper, we provide a critical review of the existing sunspot models and an overview of numerical methods employed to model wave propagation through model sunspots. We then carry out an helioseismic analysis of the sunspot in Active Region 9787 and address the serious inconsistencies uncovered by \citeauthor{gizonetal2009}~(\citeyear{gizonetal2009,gizonetal2009a}). We find that this sunspot is most probably associated with a shallow, positive wave-speed perturbation (unlike the traditional two-layer model) and that travel-time measurements are consistent with a horizontal outflow in the surrounding moat.
arXiv comment73 pages, 19 figures, accepted by Solar Physics
References in corpus (64)
- Radiative MHD simulation of sunspot structure
- Magneto-convection in a sunspot umbra
- Local Helioseismology: Three Dimensional Imaging of the Solar Interior
- Penumbral structure and outflows in simulated sunspots
- Magnetic flux emergence in granular convection: Radiative MHD simulations and observational signatures
- Fine structure, magnetic field and heating of sunspot penumbrae
- Origin of the torsional oscillation pattern of solar rotation
- MHD simulations of penumbra fine structure
- Extrasolar Giant Planets and X-ray Activity
- Hot Jupiters and stellar magnetic activity
- Helioseismology of Sunspots: A Case Study of NOAA Region 9787
- The magnetic field of the planet-hosting star Bootis
- Non-linear numerical simulations of magneto-acoustic wave propagation in small-scale flux tubes
- The dynamical disconnection of sunspots from their magnetic roots
- Helioseismology of Sunspots: Confronting Observations with Three-Dimensional MHD Simulations of Wave Propagation
- Magnetostatic penumbra models with field-free gaps
- Properties of sunspots in cycle 23: I. Dependence of brightness on sunspot size and cycle phase
- The horizontal internetwork magnetic field: numerical simulations in comparison to observations with Hinode
- On the fine structure of the sunspot penumbrae. II. The nature of the Evershed flow
- The Three-Dimensional Structure of a Sunspot Magnetic Field
- On the choice of parameters in solar structure inversion
- Turbulent Erosion of Magnetic Flux Tubes
- Convection and the origin of Evershed flows in sunspot penumbrae
- Modeling the Longitudinal Asymmetry in Sunspot Emergence -- the Role of the Wilson Depression
- A 3D MHD model of astrophysical flows: algorithms, tests and parallelisation
- Surface-focused Seismic Holography of Sunspots: I. Observations
- A 3-D sunspot model derived from an inversion of spectropolarimetric observations and its implications for the penumbral heating
- High-resolution mapping of flows in the solar interior: Fully consistent OLA inversion of helioseismic travel times
- Detection of sea-serpent field lines in sunspot penumbrae
- Brightness, distribution, and evolution of sunspot umbral dots
- Seismic Halos Around Active Regions: An MHD Theory
- Numerical simulation of excitation and propagation of helioseismic MHD waves: Effects of inclined magnetic field
- MHS sunspot model from deep sub-photospheric to chromospheric layers
- Spot Sizes on Sun-like Stars
- On the fine structure of the sunspot penumbrae. III The vertical extension of penumbral filaments
- Acoustic wave propagation in the solar sub-photosphere with localised magnetic field concentration: effect of magnetic tension
- Sensitivity of time-distance helioseismic measurements to spatial variation of oscillation amplitudes I. Observations and a numerical model
- Theoretical modeling of propagation of magneto-acoustic waves in magnetic regions below sunspots
- Three dimensional numerical simulations of acoustic wave field in the upper convection zone of the Sun
- Radiative transfer effects on Doppler measurements as sources of surface effects in sunspot seismology
- Sunspot seismic halos generated by fast MHD wave refraction
- Seismic Constraints on Interior Solar Convection
- Numerical Models of Travel-Time Inhomogeneities in Sunspots
- SLiM: a code for the simulation of wave propagation through an inhomogeneous, magnetised solar atmosphere
- Zeeman-Doppler Imaging of Late-Type Stars -- The Surface Magnetic Field of II Peg
- Sunspots: from small-scale inhomogeneities towards a global theory
- On the Moat-Penumbra Relation
- Acoustic oscillations in a field-free cavity under solar small-scale bipolar magnetic canopy
- Time-Distance Modelling In A Simulated Sunspot Atmosphere
- Umbral Fine Structures in Sunspots Observed with Hinode Solar Optical Telescope
- Scattering of acoustic waves by a magnetic cylinder
- The structure of sunspot penumbrae IV. MHS equilibrium for penumbral flux tubes and the origin of dark core penumbral filaments and penumbral grains
- Impact of Locally Suppressed Wave sources on helioseismic travel times
- Magnetic and Thermal Phase Shifts in the Local Helioseismology of Sunspots
- Newly identified properties of surface acoustic power
- Acoustic oscillations in the field-free, gravitationally stratified Acoustic oscillations in the field-free, gravitationally stratified cavities under solar bipolar magnetic canopies
- Penumbral models in the light of Hinode spectropolarimetric observations
- A Wave Scattering Theory of Solar Seismic Power Haloes
- Thick Penumbra in a Magnetostatic Sunspot Model
- An absorbing boundary formulation for the stratified, linearized, ideal MHD equations based on an unsplit, convolutional perfectly matched layer
- Large-scale horizontal flows in the solar photosphere V: Possible evidence for the disconnection of bi-polar sunspot groups from their magnetic roots
- Convection and the Origin of Evershed Flows
- Deep-Focus Diagnostics of Sunspot Structure
- Wave propagation in the magnetic sun
Cited by in corpus (47)
- Subsurface magnetic field and flow structure of simulated sunspots
- The Magnetic Topology of the Weak-Lined T Tauri Star V410 - A Simultaneous Temperature and Magnetic Field Inversion
- Benchmarking Fast-to-Alfven Mode Conversion in a Cold MHD Plasma
- Emergence of magnetic flux generated in a solar convective dynamo. I: Formation of Sunspots and Active regions, and Origin of Their Asymmetries
- Thinning of the Sun's magnetic layer: the peculiar solar minimum could have been predicted
- Validated helioseismic inversions for 3-D vector flows
- Properties of sunspot umbrae observed in Cycle 24
- Constructing semi-empirical sunspot models for helioseismology
- Spot evolution on the red giant star XX Triangulum. A starspot-decay analysis based on time-series Doppler imaging
- Temporal Evolution of Velocity and Magnetic Field in and around Umbral Dots
- Helioseismology of sunspots: how sensitive are travel times to the Wilson depression and to the subsurface magnetic field?
- Local Helioseismology of Sunspots: Current Status and Perspectives (Invited Review)
- Properties of the 15 February 2011 Flare Seismic Sources
- Magnetohydrodynamic waves driven by p-modes
- Local sunspot oscillations and umbral dots
- Flows around Averaged Solar Active Regions
- A Fixed-point Scheme for the Numerical Construction of Magnetohydrostatic Atmospheres in Three Dimensions
- MHD wave refraction and the acoustic halo effect around solar active regions - a 3D study
- Correlations between CME parameters and sunspot activity
- The relationships of solar flares with both sunspot and geomagnetic activity
- Sunspot simulations: penumbra formation and the fluting instability
- Towards Waveform Heliotomography: Observing Interactions of Helioseismic Waves with a Sunspot
- Temporal Evolution of Sunspot Areas and Estimation of Related Plasma Flows
- Directional Time-Distance Probing of Model Sunspot Atmospheres
- Observations of Umbral Dots and their Physical Models
- MHD waves in sunspots
- The rotation rate of solar active and ephemeral regions -- II. Temporal variations of the rotation rates
- On the Seismicity of September 7, 2011 X1.8-class Flare
- Oscillations In The Line-of-Sight Magnetic Field Strength In A Pore Observed By The GREGOR Infrared Spectrograph (GRIS)
- Penumbral thermal structure below the visible surface
- Structure of sunspot light bridges in the chromosphere and transition region
- On Strengthening of the Solar f-mode Prior to Active Region Emergence Using the Fourier-Hankel Analysis
- Structures in compressible magnetoconvection and the nature of umbral dots
- Evolution and motions of magnetic fragments during the active region formation and decay: A statistical study
- Geometric properties of acoustic waves generated by a point source in solar-like interior: effects of acoustic cut-off frequency
- Recent Developments in Helioseismic Analysis Methods and Solar Data Assimilation
- The Sub-Surface Structure of a Large Sample of Active Regions
- Modelling Fast-Alfvén Mode Conversion Using SPARC
- Probabilistic Inversions for Time-Distance Helioseismology
- The Current State-Of-The-Art In Active Region Seismology
- Probing sunspots with two-skip time-distance helioseismology
- A Study of Acoustic Halos in Active Region NOAA 11330 using Multi-Height SDO Observations
- Recipe for inferring sub-surface solar magnetism via local mode-coupling using Slepian basis functions
- Asteroseismic Signature of a Large Active Region
- On the surface structure of sunspots
- Investigation of surface effects of simple flux tubes using numerical simulations
- Exploiting solar visible-range observations by inversion techniques: from flows in the solar subsurface to a flaring atmosphere