Anomalous behavior of q-averages in nonextensive statistical mechanics

Abstract

A generalized definition of average, termed the q-average, is widely employed in the field of nonextensive statistical mechanics. Recently, it has however been pointed out that such an average value may behave unphysical under specific deformations of probability distributions. Here, the following three issues are discussed and clarified. Firstly, the deformations considered are physical and may experimentally be realized. Secondly, in view of thermostatistics, the q-average is unstable in both finite and infinite discrete systems. Thirdly, a naive generalization of the discussion to continuous systems misses a point, and a norm better than the $L^1$-norm should be employed for measuring the distance between two probability distributions. Consequently, stability of the q-average is shown not to be established in all the cases.

14 pages, no figures. Accepted for publication in J. Stat. Mech.

References in corpus (3)

• Generalized molecular chaos hypothesis and H-theorem: Problem of constraints and amendment of nonextensive statistical mechanics
• Is the Tsallis entropy stable?
• On the robustness of q-expectation values and Renyi entropy

Cited by in corpus (6)

• Nonadditive Entropies Yield Probability Distributions with Biases not Warranted by the Data
• The maximization of Tsallis entropy with complete deformed functions and the problem of constraints
• Time evolution of Renyi entropy under the Lindblad equation
• Specific heat and entropy of $N$-body nonextensive systems
• Tsallis statistics generalization of non-equilibrium work relations
• The entropy in finite $N$-unit nonextensive systems: the ordinary average and $q$-average