Is S4 the horizontal symmetry of tri-bimaximal lepton mixing?
arXiv:0906.2689 · doi:10.1088/0954-3899/36/11/115007
Abstract
We determine the symmetry groups under which the charged-lepton and the Majorana-neutrino mass terms are invariant. We note that those two groups always exist trivially, i.e. independently of the presence of any symmetries in the Lagrangian, and that they always have the same form. Using this insight, we re-evaluate the recent claim that, whenever lepton mixing is tri-bimaximal, S_4 is the minimal unique horizontal-symmetry group of the Lagrangian of the lepton sector, with S_4 being determined by the symmetries of the lepton mass matrices. We discuss two models for tri-bimaximal mixing which serve as counterexamples to this claim. With these two models and some group-theoretical arguments we illustrate that there is no compelling reason for the uniqueness of S_4.
arXiv comment18 pages, no figures. Minor changes, version for publication in J. Phys. G
References in corpus (33)
- Tri-Bimaximal Mixing and the Neutrino Oscillation Data
- Status of global fits to neutrino oscillations
- Tri-Bimaximal Neutrino Mixing, A4 and the Modular Symmetry
- Three-flavour neutrino oscillation update
- Global analysis of three-flavor neutrino masses and mixings
- Hints of theta_13>0 from global neutrino data analysis
- Tri-bimaximal Neutrino Mixing and Quark Masses from a Discrete Flavour Symmetry
- Predicting neutrino parameters from SO(3) family symmetry and quark-lepton unification
- The Unique Horizontal Symmetry of Leptons
- The Horizontal Symmetry for Neutrino Mixing
- SU(3) family symmetry and neutrino bi-tri-maximal mixing
- Revisiting Bimaximal Neutrino Mixing in a Model with S4 Discrete Symmetry
- Symmetry of Lepton Mixing
- Fermion Masses and Mixings in a S4 Based Model
- S4 Flavor Symmetry and Fermion Masses: Towards a Grand Unified theory of Flavor
- Neutrino Mass Matrix from S_4 Symmetry
- A model for trimaximal lepton mixing
- Fermion Masses and Mixings from Dihedral Flavor Symmetries with Preserved Subgroups
- Lepton Flavour Violation in Models with A4 Flavour Symmetry
- The Flavor Group Delta(6n^2)
- S4 Flavor Symmetry of Quarks and Leptons in SU(5) GUT
- An SO(10)XS-4 Scenario for Naturally Degenerate Neutrinos
- S_4 Flavor Symmetry Embedded into SU(3) and Lepton Masses and Mixing
- An SO(10) GUT Model with Flavor Symmetry
- Flavor S_4 times Z_2 symmetry and neutrino mixing
- A Supersymmetric D4 Model for mu-tau Symmetry
- A model realizing the Harrison-Perkins-Scott lepton mixing matrix
- Tri-bimaximal lepton mixing from symmetry only
- Type II seesaw mechanism for Higgs doublets and the scale of new physics
- Intermediate left-right gauge symmetry, unification of couplings and fermion masses in SUSY
- Gauge boson families in grand unified theories of fermion masses: E_6^4 x S_4
- A three-parameter neutrino mass matrix with maximal CP violation
- A light pseudoscalar in a model with lepton family symmetry O(2)
Cited by in corpus (84)
- Discrete Flavor Symmetries and Models of Neutrino Mixing
- Lepton mixing and discrete symmetries
- Residual Symmetries for Neutrino Mixing with a Large theta_13 and Nearly Maximal delta_D
- Solar neutrinos and neutrino physics
- S_4 Flavored CP Symmetry for Neutrinos
- Model for T2K indication with maximal atmospheric angle and tri-maximal solar angle
- Finite flavour groups of fermions
- Family Symmetry from SU(5) SUSY GUTs in 6d
- Tri-Bimaximal Neutrino Mixing and Discrete Flavour Symmetries
- Fermion Masses and Flavor Mixings in a Model with Flavor Symmetry
- Neutrino masses and mixing from S4 flavor twisting
- Generalized CP symmetries in Delta(27) flavor models
- Classification of lepton mixing matrices from finite residual symmetries
- An SO(10) Grand Unified Theory of Flavor
- Implications of Flavored CP Symmetry of Leptons
- A_4xSU(5) SUSY GUT of Flavour in 8d
- Principal series of finite subgroups of SU(3)
- Neutrino Mixings and the S4 Discrete Flavour Symmetry
- Neutrino Mixings in SO(10) with Type II Seesaw and theta_{13}
- Phenomenological Study of Residual Z^s_2 and Zbar^s_2 Symmetries
- Simplest Neutrino Mixing from S4 Symmetry
- On the finite subgroups of U(3) of order smaller than 512
- Adjoint SUSY Grand Unified Model with Flavor Symmetry
- Quark and lepton mixing angles with a dodeca-symmetry
- A See-Saw model for fermion masses and mixings
- Natural Vacuum Alignment from Group Theory: The Minimal Case
- Compatibility of theta13 and the Type I Seesaw Model with A4 Symmetry
- Lepton Flavor Violation in Models with and Flavor Symmetries
- Mu-tau symmetry and the Littlest Seesaw
- Flavored Orbifold GUT - an SO(10) x S4 model
- Zeros in the magic neutrino mass matrix
- Discrete symmetries and models of flavor mixing
- Tri-Bimaximal Neutrino Mixing and the Flavor Symmetry
- An S4 model for quarks and leptons with maximal atmospheric angle
- Fermion masses and mixing in flavour model
- Horizontal symmetries of leptons with a massless neutrino
- Generalized Hidden Symmetry of Neutrino Mixing
- Constraints on leptogenesis from a symmetry viewpoint
- Predictivity of models with spontaneously broken non-Abelian discrete flavor symmetries
- Is the tri-bimaximal mixing accidental?
- Super Flavorsymmetry with Multiple Higgs Doublets
- Minimal seesaw model with S_4 flavor symmetry
- Tri-bimaximal Mixing and Cabibbo Angle in S4 Flavor Model with SUSY
- Vacuum misalignment corrections to tri-bimaximal mixing and form dominance
- Discrete symmetries, roots of unity, and lepton mixing
- Neutrino Mixing and Discrete Symmetries
- Dimension-five effective operators in electro-weak SU(4)xU(1) gauge models
- Intrinsic Deviation from the Tri-bimaximal Neutrino Mixing in a Class of A_4 Flavor Models
- Direct and Semi-Direct Approaches to Lepton Mixing with a Massless Neutrino
- Type III seesaw under modular symmetry with leptogenesis
- Admixture of quasi-Dirac and Majorana neutrinos with tri-bimaximal mixing
- Theory of Neutrino Masses and Mixing
- Semidirect Product Groups, Vacuum Alignment and Tribimaximal Neutrino Mixing
- A model of quarks with Delta (6N^2) family symmetry
- Discrete symmetries and mixing of Dirac neutrinos
- S_4 x Z_2 Flavor Symmetry in Supersymmetric Extra U(1) Model
- Towards Minimal S4 Lepton Flavor Model
- Neutrino masses and mixing from flavour antisymmetry
- Neutrino 2012: Outlook - theory
- Hidden flavor symmetries of SO(10) GUT
- Is θ_{13}^{PMNS} correlated with θ_{23}^{PMNS} or not?
- Discrete flavor symmetry and minimal seesaw mechanism
- Neutrino Mass and Flavour Models
- Like-sign dimuon asymmetry of B0 meson and LFV in SU(5) SUSY GUT with S4 flavor symmetry
- Non-vanishing under symmetry
- SO(10) models with flavour symmetries: Classification and examples
- Lepton mixing from the hidden sector
- Lepton Mixing, Residual Symmetries, and Trigonometric Diophantine Equations
- On a possible relationship between lepton mixing and the stability of dark matter
- New textures for the lepton mass matrices
- Symmetries for the 4HDM: extensions of cyclic groups
- (Z_2)^3 Symmetry of the Tripartite Model
- Fermion number conservation and two Higgs doublet models without tree level flavour changing neutral currents
- Fermion Masses and Mixing in General Warped Extra Dimensional Models
- "Hidden" O(2) and SO(2) Symmetry in Lepton Mixing
- Renormalization Group Running of Lepton Mixing Parameters in See-Saw Models with Flavor Symmetry
- Neutrino Mixing and Leptogenesis in Symmetry
- Asymmetric tri-bi-maximal mixing and residual symmetries
- Neutrino mass and grand unification of flavor
- Minimal lepton flavour structures lead to non-maximal 2-3 mixing
- The mixing angle as a function of neutrino mass ratio
- Effects on sinθ_{12} from perturbation of the neutrino mixing matrix with the partially degenerated neutrino masses
- Implications of CP violating 2HDM in B physics
- CKM matrix and flavor symmetries