Which fine-tuning arguments are fine?

Abstract

The argument from naturalness is widely employed in contemporary quantum field theory. Essentially a formalized aesthetic criterion, it received a meaning in the debate on the Higgs mechanism, which goes beyond aesthetics. We follow the history of technical definitions of fine tuning at the scale of electroweak symmetry breaking. It is argued that they give rise to a special interpretation of probability, which we call Gedankenfrequency. By extension of its original meaning, the argument from naturalness is used to compare different models beyond the Standard Model. We show that in this case naturalness cannot be defined objectively. Rather, it functions as socio-historical heuristics in particle physics and it contributes to the advent of a probabilistic version of Popper's falsificationism.

22 pages, 2 figures

References in corpus (9)

• Naturally Speaking: The Naturalness Criterion and Physics at the LHC
• Relaxed fine-tuning in models with non-universal gaugino masses
• Bayesian approach and Naturalness in MSSM analyses for the LHC
• Precision gluino mass at the LHC in SUSY models with decoupled scalars
• Physics Beyond the Standard Model
• A New Measure of Fine Tuning
• Expectations for LHC from Naturalness: Modified vs. SM Higgs Sector
• Quantum Scholasticism: On Quantum Contexts, Counterfactuals, and the Absurdities of Quantum Omniscience
• Little Higgs, Non-standard Higgs, No Higgs and All That

Cited by in corpus (13)

• Criteria for Natural Hierarchies
• Screams for Explanation: Finetuning and Naturalness in the Foundations of Physics
• Naturalness in Nuclear Effective Field Theories
• CMSSM, naturalness and the "fine-tuning price" of the Very Large Hadron Collider
• Two Notions of Naturalness
• Narratives of Quantum Theory in the Age of Quantum Technologies
• The Practice of Naturalness: A Historical-Philosophical Perspective
• Bayesian naturalness, simplicity, and testability applied to the $B-L$ MSSM GUT
• A technique for natural gauge boson masses
• Quantum field theories of relativistic Luttinger fermions
• The Fine-Tuning Argument
• Naturalness as a reasonable scientific principle in fundamental physics
• Superoscillations: a scale physics perspective