Did Saturn's rings form during the Late Heavy Bombardment ?
arXiv:0809.5073 · doi:10.1016/j.icarus.2008.10.019
Abstract
The origin of Saturn\' s massive ring system is still unknown. Two popular scenarios - the tidal splitting of passing comets and the collisional destruction of a satellite - rely on a high cometary flux in the past. In the present paper we attempt to quantify the cometary flux during the Late Heavy Bombardment (LHB) to assess the likelihood of both scenarios. Our analysis relies on the so-called Nice model of the origin of the LHB (Tsiganis et al., 2005; Morbidelli et al., 2005; Gomes et al., 2005) and on the size distribution of the primordial trans-Neptunian planetesimals constrained in Charnoz & Morbidelli (2007). We find that the cometary flux on Saturn during the LHB was so high that both scenarios for the formation of Saturn rings are viable in principle. However, a more detailed study shows that the comet tidal disruption scenario implies that all four giant planets should have comparable ring systems whereas the destroyed satellite scenario would work only for Saturn, and perhaps Jupiter. This is because in Saturnś system, the synchronous orbit is interior to the Roche Limit, which is a necessary condition for maintaining a satellite in the Roche zone up to the time of the LHB. We also discuss the apparent elimination of silicates from the ring parent body implied by the purity of the ice in Saturn \' s rings. The LHB has also strong implications for the survival of the Saturnian satellites: all satellites smaller than Mimas would have been destroyed during the LHB, whereas Enceladus would have had from 40% to 70% chance of survival depending on the disruption model. In conclusion, these results suggest that the LHB is the sweet moment for the formation of a massive ring system around Saturn.
arXiv comment39 pages, 9 figures, 3 tables. Accepted for publication in ICARUS. New version with figures included in the text
References in corpus (11)
- Catastrophic disruptions revisited
- Origin of the Structure of the Kuiper Belt during a Dynamical Instability in the Orbits of Uranus and Neptune
- The origin of planetary impactors in the inner solar system
- The Size Distribution of Trans-Neptunian Bodies
- The Size Distribution of Kuiper Belt Objects
- Origin of Tidal Dissipation in Jupiter: II. the Value of Q
- The Kuiper Belt Luminosity Function from m(R)=21 to 26
- Gravitational Stirring in Planetary Debris Disks
- The population of propellers in Saturn's A Ring
- Coupling dynamical and collisional evolution of small bodies II : Forming the Kuiper Belt, the Scattered Disk and the Oort Cloud
- The Size-Frequency Distribution of Dormant Jupiter Family Comets
Cited by in corpus (36)
- Cometary Origin of the Zodiacal Cloud and Carbonaceous Micrometeorites
- A Sawtooth-like Timeline for the First Billion Year of Lunar Bombardment
- Capture of Trojans by Jumping Jupiter
- Formation of Regular Satellites from Ancient Massive Rings in the Solar System
- Origin of the Different Architectures of the Jovian and Saturnian Satellite Systems
- Accretion of Saturn's mid-sized moons during the viscous spreading of young massive rings: solving the paradox of silicate-poor rings versus silicate-rich moons
- Constraining the cometary flux through the asteroid belt during the late heavy bombardment
- Long-term & large-scale viscous evolution of dense planetary rings
- Impact bombardment chronology of the terrestrial planets from 4.5 Ga to 3.5 Ga
- Ring Formation around Giant Planets by Tidal Disruption of a Single Passing Large Kuiper Belt Object
- Solar System Physics for Exoplanet Research
- Migration of a moonlet in a ring of solid particles : Theory and application to Saturn's propellers
- Detecting ring systems around exoplanets using high resolution spectroscopy: the case of 51Pegb
- From scattered-light to millimeter emission: A comprehensive view of the Gyr-old system of HD 202628 and its eccentric debris ring
- Compositions and origins of outer planet systems: Insights from the Roche critical density
- Accretion of Saturn's Inner Mid-sized Moons from a Massive Primordial Ice Ring
- Origin and Evolution of Saturn's Ring System
- Tidal disruption of satellites and formation of narrow rings
- Formation of Multiple-Satellite Systems From Low-Mass Circumplanetary Particle Disks
- Planetary Rings
- A recent origin for Saturn's rings from the collisional disruption of an icy moon
- Deciphering the Origin of the Regular Satellites of Gaseous Giants - Iapetus: the Rosetta Ice-Moon
- Collision Probabilities in the Edgeworth-Kuiper belt
- Impact bombardment on the regular satellites of Jupiter and Uranus during an episode of giant planet migration
- Formation of Exomoons: A Solar System Perspective
- Characterising exo-ringsystems around fast-rotating stars using the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect
- Cronomoons: origin, dynamics, and light-curve features of ringed exomoons
- A Pluto--Charon Sonata: Dynamical Limits on the Masses of the Small Satellites
- Constraints on planetesimal disk mass from the cratering record and equatorial ridge on Iapetus
- Saturn's Exploration Beyond Cassini-Huygens
- The Dynamical Viability of an Extended Jupiter Ring System
- Seasonal variation of radial brightness contrast of Saturn's rings viewed in mid-infrared by Subaru/COMICS
- Disruption of Saturn's ring particles by thermal stress
- Neptune's Inner Moons and Rings Are Exposed Icy Body Interiors
- Investigating tidal stripping of a pre-existing moon as the origin of Saturn's young icy rings
- Survival of exomoons around exoplanets