Comments on anomaly versus WKB/tunneling methods for calculating Unruh radiation
arXiv:0808.3413 · doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2009.02.022
Abstract
In this Letter we make a critique of, and comparison between, the anomaly method and WKB/tunneling method for obtaining radiation from non-trivial spacetime backgrounds. We focus on Rindler spacetime (the spacetime of an accelerating observer) and the associated Unruh radiation since this is the prototype of the phenomena of radiation from a spacetime, and it is the simplest model for making clear subtle points in the tunneling and anomaly methods. Our analysis leads to the following conclusions: (i) neither the consistent and covariant anomaly methods gives the correct Unruh temperature for Rindler spacetime and in some cases (e.g. de Sitter spacetime) the consistent and covariant methods disagree with one another; (ii) the tunneling method can be applied in all cases, but it has a previously unnoticed temporal contribution which must be accounted for in order to obtain the correct temperature.
arXiv comment13 pages, 0 figures, revtex4, To be published PLB. Critic of detailed balance dropped and reference added which shows how detailed balance works if one correctly takes into account the temporal piece. Discussion added about temporal contribution giving P_abs=1 condition added showing why "complex integration" constant is not needed
References in corpus (37)
- Hawking Radiation as Tunneling
- Particle production and complex path analysis
- Self-Interaction Correction to Black Hole Radiance
- Hawking Radiation as Tunneling for Extremal and Rotating Black Holes
- Relationship between Hawking Radiation and Gravitational Anomalies
- Quantum Tunneling Beyond Semiclassical Approximation
- A Secret Tunnel Through The Horizon
- Hawking temperature in the tunneling picture
- Hawking radiation in different coordinate settings: Complex paths approach
- Quantum Tunneling and Back Reaction
- Noncommutative Black Hole Thermodynamics
- Hawking Radiation as Tunneling through the Quantum Horizon
- Anomalies, Hawking Radiations and Regularity in Rotating Black Holes
- Hawking Radiation from Charged Black Holes via Gauge and Gravitational Anomalies
- Temporal contribution to gravitational WKB-like calculations
- On Hawking Radiation as Tunneling with Back-Reaction
- Hawking Radiation from Rotating Black Holes and Gravitational Anomalies
- Simulation of Panleve-Gullstrand black hole in thin 3He-A film
- Thermal radiation of various gravitational backgrounds
- Hawking temperature from tunnelling formalism
- Hawking Radiation and Covariant Anomalies
- On Hawking Radiation as Tunneling with Logarithmic Corrections
- Two-dimensional gravitational anomalies, Schwinger terms and dispersion relations
- Problems with Tunneling of Thin Shells from Black Holes
- Black Hole Thermodynamics and the Factor of 2 Problem
- Hawking Radiation, Effective Actions and Covariant Boundary Conditions
- Gravitational Anomalies, Hawking Radiation, and Spherically Symmetric Black Holes
- Hawking Radiation as Tunneling: the D-dimensional rotating case
- Hawking radiation as tunneling derived from Black Hole Thermodynamics through the quantum horizon
- Gravitational anomalies: a recipe for Hawking radiation
- Anomalies, effective action and Hawking temperatures of a Schwarzschild black hole in the isotropic coordinates
- On the Mechanism of Hawking Radiation
- Corrections to Unruh effect in tunneling formalism and mapping with Hawking effect
- Factor Two Discrepancy of Hawking Radiation Temperature
- Decay of the cosmological constant by Hawking radiation as quantum tunneling
- Is there analogy between quantized vortex and black hole?
- A Brief Editorial on de Sitter Radiation via Tunneling
Cited by in corpus (75)
- Hawking black body spectrum from tunneling mechanism
- Quantum corrections to the thermodynamics of Schwarzschild-Tangherlini black hole and the generalized uncertainty principle
- Corrections to the thermodynamics of Schwarzschild-Tangherlini black hole and the generalized uncertainty principle
- Quantum tunneling and black hole spectroscopy
- GUP Assisted Hawking Radiation of Rotating Acoustic Black Holes
- Observing remnants by fermions' tunneling
- Effects of quantum gravity on black holes
- Corrections to Hawking-like Radiation for a Friedmann-Robertson-Walker Universe
- Entangled Particles Tunneling From a Schwarzschild Black Hole immersed in an Electromagnetic Universe with GUP
- The Effect of GUP to Massive Vector and Scalar Particles Tunneling From a Warped DGP Gravity Black Hole
- Hawking Radiation, Covariant Boundary Conditions and Vacuum States
- Particle decay in de Sitter spacetime via quantum tunneling
- Tunneling of Massive Vector Particles under the Influence of Quantum Gravity
- Black Hole Entropy with minimal length in Tunneling formalism
- Insights and possible resolution to the information loss paradox via the tunneling picture
- Minimal Length Effects on Tunnelling from Spherically Symmetric Black Holes
- Corrected Entropy of Friedmann-Robertson-Walker Universe in Tunneling Method
- On black hole spectroscopy via adiabatic invariance
- Black hole radiation of massive spin-2 particles in (3+1) dimensions
- Remarks on remnants by fermions' tunnelling from black strings
- Dirac particles' tunnelling from 5-dimensional rotating black strings influenced by the generalized uncertainty principle
- Back reaction, emission spectrum and entropy spectroscopy
- Hawking-like radiation as tunneling from the apparent horizon in a FRW Universe
- A WKB-like approach to Unruh Radiation
- Observer Dependent Horizon Temperatures: a Coordinate-Free Formulation of Hawking Radiation as Tunneling
- Hawking fluxes, Fermionic currents, W(1+infinity) algebra and anomalies
- Tunneling Analysis of Kerr-Newman Black Hole-Like Solution in Rastall Theory
- Quantum Tunneling and Quasinormal Modes in the Spacetime of Alcubierre Warp Drive
- Hawking radiation of scalar and vector particles from 5D Myers-Perry black holes
- Quantum-corrected two-dimensional Horava-Lifshitz black hole entropy
- Anomaly analysis of Hawking radiation from Kaluza-Klein black hole with squashed horizon
- Hawking radiation, chirality, and the principle of effective theory of gravity
- Tunneling across dilaton-axion black holes
- The Unruh thermal spectrum through scalar and fermion tunneling
- On de Sitter radiation via quantum tunneling
- Quantum tunneling and spectroscopy of noncommutative inspired Kerr black hole
- Black Hole Radiation with Modified Dispersion Relation in Tunneling Paradigm: Static Frame
- Eruptive Massive Vector Particles of 5-Dimensional Kerr-Gödel Spacetime
- Modification of Gravitational Anomaly Method in Hawking Radiation
- On the difference between Poincaré and Lorentz gravity
- Hawking radiation of scalars from charged accelerating and rotating black holes with NUT parameter
- New Geometric Transition as Origin of Particle Production in Time-Dependent Backgrounds
- Hawking radiation of Dirac monopoles from the global monopole black hole with quantum gravity effects
- Gravitational anomalies and entropy
- Quantum Tunneling of Spin-1 Particles from a 5D Einstein-Yang-Mills-Gauss-Bonnet Black Hole Beyond Semiclassical Approximation
- Hawking radiation-quasinormal modes correspondence for large AdS black holes
- Black Hole Radiation with Modified Dispersion Relation in Tunneling Paradigm: Free-fall Frame
- Unruh effect and information entropy approach
- Tunneling during Quantum Collapse in AdS Spacetime
- The Bekenstein-Hawking Corpuscular Cascading from the Backreacted Black Hole
- Thermodynamic studies of Different Type of Black Holes: General Uncertainty Principle Approach
- Dirac Particles Tunneling from Black Holes with Topological Defects
- Minimal length effects in black hole thermodynamics from tunneling formalism
- Quasi-classical Hawking Temperatures and Black Hole Thermodynamics
- Minimal Length Effects on Entanglement Entropy of Spherically Symmetric Black Holes in Brick Wall Model
- Reflection and Transmission at the Apparent Horizon during Gravitational Collapse
- Chiral density waves in quarkyonic matter
- De Sitter Invariant Vacuum States, Vertex Operators, and Conformal Field Theory Correlators
- Tunneling and thermodynamics evolution of the magnetized Ernst-like black hole
- "Charged" Particle's Tunneling from Rotating Black Holes
- Composition of fluctuations of different observables
- Particle creation: Schwinger + Unruh + Hawking
- Black Hole Entropy: From Shannon to Bekenstein
- Back reaction, covariant anomaly and effective action
- Hawking Radiation for Scalar and Dirac Fields in Five Dimensional Dilatonic Black Hole via Anomalies
- Hawking Radiation in a Plebanski-Demianski Black Hole
- Tunneling method for Hawking radiation in the Nariai case
- Fermions Tunneling from Higher-Dimensional Reissner-Nordström Black Hole: Semiclassical and Beyond Semiclassical Approximation
- Near-Extremal Kerr AdS2xS2 Solution and Black-Hole/Near-Horizion-CFT Duality
- Hawking Radiation in the Spacetime of White Holes
- Scalar particles tunneling radiation in the Demianski-Newman spacetime with influences of quantum gravity
- Quantum Radiation Properties of General Nonstationary Black Hole
- Thermodynamics of Black Holes: Semi-Classical Approaches and Beyond
- Penguin amplitudes in B^+ to pi^+ K^*0, K^+ \bar{K}^*0 decays
- Alternative Derivations of Hawking Radiation