Experimental quantum computing without entanglement
arXiv:0807.0668 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.101.200501
Abstract
Entanglement is widely believed to lie at the heart of the advantages offered by a quantum computer. This belief is supported by the discovery that a noiseless (pure) state quantum computer must generate a large amount of entanglement in order to offer any speed up over a classical computer. However, deterministic quantum computation with one pure qubit (DQC1), which employs noisy (mixed) states, is an efficient model that generates at most a marginal amount of entanglement. Although this model cannot implement any arbitrary algorithm it can efficiently solve a range of problems of significant importance to the scientific community. Here we experimentally implement a first-order case of a key DQC1 algorithm and explicitly characterise the non-classical correlations generated. Our results show that while there is no entanglement the algorithm does give rise to other non-classical correlations, which we quantify using the quantum discord - a stronger measure of non-classical correlations that includes entanglement as a subset. Our results suggest that discord could replace entanglement as a necessary resource for a quantum computational speed-up. Furthermore, DQC1 is far less resource intensive than universal quantum computing and our implementation in a scalable architecture highlights the model as a practical short-term goal.
5 pages, 4 figures
References in corpus (19)
- Introducing Quantum Discord
- Distributed Entanglement
- Efficient classical simulation of slightly entangled quantum computations
- Classical, quantum and total correlations
- Quantum discord and the power of one qubit
- Optical Quantum Computing
- Quantum Nonlocality without Entanglement
- Silica-on-Silicon Waveguide Quantum Circuits
- On the Power of One Bit of Quantum Information
- On the role of entanglement in quantum computational speed-up
- Entanglement and the Power of One Qubit
- Demonstration of a simple entangling optical gate and its use in Bell-state analysis
- On the role of entanglement and correlations in mixed-state quantum computation
- Exploring Hilbert Space: accurate characterisation of quantum information
- Exponential speed-up with a single bit of quantum information: Testing the quantum butterfly effect
- Photon statistics characterization of a single photon source
- Parameter Estimation with Mixed-State Quantum Computation
- Characterization of complex quantum dynamics with a scalable NMR information processor
- Demonstrating quantum nonlocality without entanglement
Cited by in corpus (330)
- The classical-quantum boundary for correlations: discord and related measures
- Necessary and sufficient condition for non-zero quantum discord
- Quantum discord for two-qubit X-states
- Unified View of Quantum and Classical Correlations
- Photonic Boson Sampling in a Tunable Circuit
- Robustness of quantum discord to sudden death
- Sudden transition between classical and quantum decoherence
- Classical and quantum correlations under decoherence
- Almost all quantum states have non-classical correlations
- Quantum versus classical correlations in Gaussian states
- Gaussian quantum discord
- Quantum discord as resource for remote state preparation
- Non-Markovian Dynamics of Quantum Discord
- Quantum correlations in spin chains at finite temperatures and quantum phase transitions
- Experimental investigation of classical and quantum correlations under decoherence
- Quantum enhanced measurements without entanglement
- Measures and applications of quantum correlations
- Quantum optics in the phase space - A tutorial on Gaussian states
- Quantum discord for general two--qubit states: Analytical progress
- Can One Trust Quantum Simulators?
- Generating, manipulating and measuring entanglement and mixture with a reconfigurable photonic circuit
- Non-Markovian effect on the quantum discord
- Thermal and Magnetic Quantum Discord in Heisenberg models
- Dynamics of quantum correlations in two-qubit systems within non-Markovian environments
- System-reservoir dynamics of quantum and classical correlations
- Precision Atomic Physics Techniques for Nuclear Physics with Radioactive Beams
- Quantum and classical thermal correlations in the XY spin-1/2 chain
- Quantum discord and its allies: a review
- Operational Significance of Discord Consumption: Theory and Experiment
- Energetics of quantum correlations
- Behavior of Quantum Correlations under Local Noise
- Quantum discord and geometry for a class of two-qubit states
- Conservation law for distributed entanglement of formation and quantum discord
- Are general quantum correlations monogamous?
- Optimal measurements to access classical correlations of two-qubit states
- Quantum cost for sending entanglement
- Verification of quantum computation: An overview of existing approaches
- Comparative investigation of the freezing phenomena for quantum correlations under nondissipative decoherence
- Environment-induced sudden transition in quantum discord dynamics
- Quantum correlations and mutual synchronization
- Negativity of quantumness and its interpretations
- Competitions between quantum correlations in the quantum-memory-assisted entropic uncertainty relation
- Genuine quantum and classical correlations in multipartite systems
- Monogamy properties of quantum and classical correlations
- Quantum and classical correlations in the one-dimensional XY model with Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction
- Geometric quantum discord with Bures distance
- Observable measure of bipartite quantum correlations
- Theoretical and experimental aspects of quantum discord and related measures
- Classical correlation and quantum discord sharing of Dirac fields in noninertial frames
- Conditions for Monogamy of Quantum Discord: Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger versus W states
- Spontaneous synchronization and quantum correlation dynamics of open spin systems
- Dynamics of quantum correlations in colored environments
- Upper bound and shareability of quantum discord based on entropic uncertainty relations
- Quantum correlations in topological quantum phase transitions
- Uncertainty-induced quantum nonlocality
- Experimental detection of non-classical correlations in mixed state quantum computation
- Correlations in Grover search
- Quantum discord and steering in top quarks at the LHC
- Creating quantum correlations through local non-unitary memoryless channels
- Local Detection of Quantum Correlations with a Single Trapped Ion
- Maximally discordant mixed states of two qubits
- Experimentally Witnessing the Quantumness of Correlations
- Witnessing quantum discord in 2 x N systems
- Witnessing entanglement in quantum magnets using neutron scattering
- Entanglement versus Quantum Discord in Two Coupled Double Quantum Dots
- Universal freezing of quantum correlations within the geometric approach
- Non-classical correlations in non-Markovian continuous variable systems
- Nonclassical correlation in NMR quadrupolar systems
- Unified view of correlations using the square norm distance
- Interplay between computable measures of entanglement and other quantum correlations
- Tight lower bound to the geometric measure of quantum discord
- Exploring multipartite quantum correlations with the square of quantum discord
- Dynamics of geometric and entropic quantifiers of correlations in open quantum systems
- Faithful nonclassicality indicators and extremal quantum correlations in two-qubit states
- Quantum correlations between each qubit in a two-atom system and the environment in terms of interatomic distance
- How Discord underlies the Noise Resilience of Quantum Illumination
- Measuring bipartite quantum correlations of an unknown state
- Correlation Dynamics of Qubit-Qutrit Systems in a Classical Dephasing Environment
- Sudden change in quantum and classical correlations and the Unruh effect
- Optical Quantum Computation
- Dynamics of entropic measurement-induced nonlocality in structured reservoirs
- Experimental investigation of the non-Markovian dynamics of classical and quantum correlations
- A comparative study of local quantum Fisher information and local quantum uncertainty in Heisenberg model
- Quantum resources for hybrid communication via qubit-oscillator states
- Long-range quantum discord in critical spin systems
- Quantum correlations and distinguishability of quantum states
- Quantum discord and multipartite correlations
- Experimental cyclic inter-conversion between Coherence and Quantum Correlations
- Homodyne estimation of Gaussian quantum discord
- Experimental Investigation of the Evolution of Gaussian Quantum Discord in an Open System
- Time-evolution of tripartite quantum discord and entanglement under local and non-local random telegraph noise
- Detecting Multipartite Classical States and their Resemblances
- Orthogonal measurements are {\it almost} sufficient for quantum discord of two qubits
- Quantifying quantum coherence and non-classical correlation based on Hellinger distance
- Quantum discord and measurement-induced disturbance in the background of dilaton black holes
- Identifying the quantum correlations in light-harvesting complexes
- Generation of quantum discord between ionic qubits via noisy processes
- Generalized entropic measures of quantum correlations
- Correlation approach to work extraction from finite quantum systems
- Quantum Correlations in Large-Dimensional States of High Symmetry
- Criteria for measures of quantum correlations
- Quantum correlations as precursors of entanglement
- Quantifying quantum discord and entanglement of formation via unified purifications
- Amplification of quantum discord between two uncoupled qubits in a common environment by phase decoherence
- The quantumness of correlations revealed in local measurements exceeds entanglement
- Measurement-induced disturbances and nonclassical correlations of Gaussian states
- Quantum correlation in degenerate optical parametric oscillators with mutual injections
- Quantum discord and remote state preparation
- Experimental entanglement activation from discord in a programmable quantum measurement
- Tunable generation of entangled photons in a nonlinear directional coupler
- Geometric quantum discord with Bures distance: the qubit case
- Entanglement is not a critical resource for quantum metrology
- Quantum correlations in the collective spin systems
- Quantum locking of classical correlations and quantum discord of classical-quantum states
- Necessary and sufficient conditions of freezing phenomena of quantum discord under phase damping
- Experimental analysis of decoherence of quantumness in a continuous variables bi-partite entangled system
- Quantum Discord and Quantum Computing - An Appraisal
- Quantum algorithm for estimating Renyi entropies of quantum states
- Experimental investigation of quantum correlations in a two-qutrit spin system
- To freeze or not to: Quantum correlations under local decoherence
- Exact dynamics of quantum correlations of two qubits coupled to bosonic baths
- Experimental approximation of the Jones polynomial with DQC1
- Measuring geometric quantum discord using one bit of quantum information
- Local-channel-induced rise of quantum correlations in continuous-variable systems
- Quantum correlation and classical correlation dynamics in the spin-boson model
- Quantum discord in spin-cluster materials
- The geometric approach to quantum correlations: Computability versus reliability
- Asymptotic Discord and Entanglement of Non-Resonant Harmonic Oscillators in an Equilibrium Environment
- Quantum discord for a two-parameter class of states in quantum systems
- Sudden transition between classical and quantum decoherence in dissipative cavity QED and stationary quantum discord
- Quantum Correlations and Global Coherence in Distributed Quantum Computing
- Quantifying the Nonclassicality of Operations
- Nonclassical correlations in continuous-variable non-Gaussian Werner states
- Quantum Zeno and anti-Zeno effects on quantum and classical correlations
- Entanglement and coherence in Bernstein-Vazirani algorithm
- Entanglement and quantum discord dynamics of two atoms under practical feedback control
- The power of one qumode for quantum computation
- Classical analog of qubit logic based on a magnon Bose-Einstein condensate
- Magnetic quantum correlation in the 1D transverse-field XXZ model
- Preservation of the geometric quantum discord in noisy environments
- Thermal quantum and classical correlations in two qubit XX model in a nonuniform external magnetic field
- Geometric interpretation of the geometric discord
- A new criteria for zero quantum discord
- Analytical solutions and criteria for the quantum discord of two-qubit X-states
- Necessary and sufficient condition for saturating the upper bound of quantum discord
- Geometric measure of quantum discord for a two-parameter class of states in a qubit-qutrit system under various dissipative channels
- Do Large Number of Parties Enforce Monogamy in All Quantum Correlations?
- Light Cone-Like Behavior of Quantum Monogamy Score and Multisite Entanglement
- Requirement of Dissonance in Assisted Optimal State Discrimination
- Generalized X states of N qubits and their symmetries
- Flow of Quantum Correlations from a Two-Qubit System to its Environment
- Quantum discord evolution of three-qubit states under noisy channels
- Difficulties in analytic computation for relative entropy of entanglement
- Sequential State Discrimination and Requirement of Quantum Dissonance
- Extremal Quantum Correlations: Experimental Study with Two-qubit States
- Local witness for bipartite quantum discord
- Evolution of Quantum Discord and its Stability in Two-Qubit NMR Systems
- Quantifying nonclassicality: global impact of local unitary evolutions
- Quantum Discord for Systems
- Efficient Quantum Compression for Ensembles of Identically Prepared Mixed States
- Verifying commuting quantum computations via fidelity estimation of weighted graph states
- Direct scheme for measuring the geometric quantum discord
- Pulse control of sudden transition for two qubits in XY spin baths and quantum phase transition
- On two-qubit states ordering with quantum discords
- Quantum Discord in the Ground and Thermal States of Spin Clusters
- Discording power of quantum evolutions
- Experimental protection and revival of quantum correlation in open solid systems
- Maximally dense coding capable quantum states
- Experimental characterization of Gaussian quantum discord generated by four-wave mixing
- Creation of quantum correlations between two atoms in a dissipative environment from an initial vacuum state
- Quantum correlations in a system of nuclear s=1/2 spins in a strong magnetic field
- Dynamical quantum correlations after sudden quenches
- Quantum discord dynamical behaviors due to initial system-cavity correlations
- Quantum discord amplification induced by quantum phase transition via a cavity-Bose-Einstein-condensate system
- Decoherence dynamics of geometric measure of quantum discord and measurement-induced nonlocality for noninertial observers at finite temperature
- Overarching framework between Gaussian quantum discord and Gaussian quantum illumination
- Influence of Stark-shift on quantum coherence and non-classical correlations for two two-level atoms interacting with a single-mode cavity field
- Entanglement and quantum discord in optically coupled coherent Ising machines
- Quantum correlation entropy
- Deterministic Quantum Computation With One Photonic Qubit
- Bayes' rule, generalized discord, and nonextensive thermodynamics
- Analytical expression of Genuine Tripartite Quantum Discord for Symmetrical X-states
- Quantum discord induced by white noises
- Of Local Operations and Physical Wires
- On the quantumness of correlations in nuclear magnetic resonance
- Generating entangled quantum microwaves in a Josephson-photonics device
- Qubit Analog with Polariton Superfluid in an Annular Trap
- Entanglement is not a lower bound for geometric discord
- Classicality witness for two-qubit states
- Invariant Quantum Discord in Qubit-Qutrit Systems under Local Dephasing
- Quantum correlation measure in arbitrary bipartite systems
- Quantum Correlation in One-dimensional Extend Quantum Compass Model
- Comparison of different measures for quantum discord under non-Markovian noise
- Entanglement-free certification of entangling gates
- Witnessing quantum resource conversion within deterministic quantum computation using one pure superconducting qubit
- Frozen Gaussian quantum discord in photonic crystal cavity array system
- Local Quantum Uncertainty in Two-Qubit Separable States: A Case Study
- One-way Quantum Deficit and Decoherence for Two-qubit States
- Quantum correlations and least disturbing local measurements
- Geometric measure of quantum discord over two-sided projective measurements
- Quantum Discord for Investigating Quantum Correlations without Entanglement in Solids
- Asymmetry of bipartite quantum discord
- Dynamics of multipartite quantum correlations under decoherence
- Entanglement of formation for a class of -dimensional systems
- Various Correlations in Anisotropic Heisenberg XYZ Model with Dzyaloshinski-Moriya Interaction
- Quantum Otto engine with quantum correlations
- Quantum Correlation with Sandwiched Relative Entropies: Advantageous as Order Parameter in Quantum Phase Transitions
- Quantum Correlation Dynamics in Controlled Two-Coupled-Qubit Systems
- Quantum Correlations Dynamics In Two Coupled Semiconductor InAs Quantum Dots
- On the pseudospectrum of the harmonic oscillator with imaginary cubic potential
- Quantum correlations of identical particles subject to classical environmental noise
- Correlation quantum beats induced by non-Markovian effect
- Quantum optics and frontiers of physics: The third quantum revolution
- Sequential state discrimination with quantum correlation
- Sudden Change of Quantum Discord under Single Qubit Noise
- Entanglement measures of Majorana bound states
- Experimentally freezing quantum discord in a dissipative environment using dynamical decoupling
- Quantum correlation in three-qubit Heisenberg model with Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction
- Thermal quantum correlations and Teleportation in a Graphene Sheet
- Engineering two-qubit mixed states with weak measurements
- Broadcasting of Quantum Correlations: Possibilities & Impossibilities
- Quantum discord of Bell cat-states under amplitude damping
- Geometric global quantum discord of two-qubit X states
- How to observe and quantify quantum-discorded states
- How to observe and quantify quantum-discorded states via correlations
- Tomographic discord for a system of two coupled nanoelectric circuits
- Dual quantum-correlation paradigms exhibit opposite statistical-mechanical properties
- Tuning interaction strength leads to ergodic-nonergodic transition of quantum correlations in anisotropic Heisenberg spin model
- Quantum discord under system-environment coupling: the two-qubit case
- Reducing Computational Complexity of Quantum Correlations
- Excessive distribution of quantum entanglement
- Quantum discord in quantum random access codes and its connection with dimension witness
- A Quantum-Classical Model of Brain Dynamics
- Enhancement of quantum correlations for the system of cavity QED by applying bang-bang pulses
- Quantifying quantumness of correlations using Gaussian Rényi-2 entropy in optomechanical interfaces
- General quantum correlation from nonreal values of Kirkwood-Dirac quasiprobability over orthonormal product bases
- Plasmon-assisted quantum control of distant emitters
- Quantum uncertainty in critical systems with three spins interaction
- Classical extension of quantum-correlated separable states
- A cold-atoms based processor for deterministic quantum computation with one qubit in intractably large Hilbert spaces
- Quantum discord dynamics of two qubits in the single-mode cavities
- Sudden transitions of trace distance discord of dipole-dipole coupled two qubits
- Correlative Capacity of Composite Quantum States
- Quantum correlations in qutrit-qutrit systems under local quantum noise channels
- Protecting quantum correlations of two qubits in independent non-Markovian environments by bang-bang pulses
- Classical memoryless noise-induced maximally discordant mixed separable steady states
- Dynamics of measurement induced nonlocality under decoherence
- Bell violation versus geometric measure of quantum discord and their dynamical behavior
- Benchmarks of Nonclassicality for Qubit Arrays
- Effects of intrinsic decoherence on discord-like correlation measures of two-qubit spin squeezing model
- Promoting quantum correlations in DQC1 model via post-selection
- Quantum Dissonance Is Rejected in an Overlap Measurement Scheme
- Quantum coherence versus quantum discord in two coupled semiconductor double-dot molecules via a transmission line resonator
- The Power of One Clean Qubit in Supervised Machine Learning
- Coherent Averaging
- Characterization of quantum and classical correlations in the Earth curved space-time
- Gaussian Continuous-Variable Isotropic State
- The Dual Roles of Quantum Discord in a Non-demolition Probing Task
- Entangling Power in the Deterministic Quantum Computation with One Qubit
- Geometric measure of quantum discord and total quantum correlations in a N-partite quantum state
- Generation of a non-zero discord bipartite state with classical second-order interference
- Local quantum uncertainty of SU(2) invariant states
- Emergence of metastable pointer states basis in non-Markovian quantum dynamics
- Ancilla-driven instantaneous quantum polynomial time circuit for quantum supremacy
- What can we learn from the dynamics of entanglement and quantum discord in the Tavis-Cummings model?
- Correlation dynamics of a two-qubit system in a Bell-diagonal state under non-identical local noises
- Transverse Ising Model: Markovian evolution of classical and quantum correlations under decoherence
- Dynamics and Quantum correlations in Two independently driven Rydberg atoms with distinct laser fields
- Progress on Quantum Discord of Two Qubit states: Optimization and Upper Bound
- Enhancement of non-equilibrium thermal quantum discord and entanglement of a three-spin XX chain by multi-spin interaction and external magnetic field
- Assisted optimal state discrimination without entanglement
- Generalized approach to quantify correlations in bipartite quantum systems
- Theoretical insights on measuring quantum correlations
- Non-separability of Physical Systems as a Foundation of Consciousness
- Generalizations of Quantum Discord
- Quantum dissonance provide power to deterministic quantum computation with single qubit
- Quantum correlations dynamics under different non-markovian environmental models
- Quantum coherence, correlations and nonclassical states in the two-qubit Rabi model with parametric oscillator
- Thermal effects on bipartite and multipartite correlations in fiber coupled cavity arrays
- DQC1 as an Open Quantum System
- Controlled generation of mixed spatial qudits with arbitrary degree of purity
- A measure of quantum correlations that lies approximately between entanglement and discord
- Black-box estimation of expanding parameter for de Sitter universe
- Quantum Neural Network and Soft Quantum Computing
- Pairwise quantum discord for a symmetric multi-qubit system in different types of noisy channels
- Long-lived entanglement with Pulsed-driven initially entangled qubit pair
- Problem of quantifying quantum correlations with non-commutative discord
- Genuine correlations in finite-size spin systems
- Various correlations in a Heisenberg XXZ spin chain both in thermal equilibrium and under the intrinsic decoherence
- Symmetry in the open-system dynamics of quantum correlations
- Adiabatic freezing of long-range quantum correlations in spin chains
- Multipartite quantum and classical correlations in symmetric n-qubit mixed states
- Flow of quantum correlations in noisy two-mode squeezed microwave states
- Controlling transfer of quantum correlations among bi-partitions of a composite quantum system by combining noisy environments
- Frozen and Invariant Quantum Discord under Local Dephasing Noise
- Contextuality and Quantum Discord
- Local Decoherence-free Macroscopic Quantum states
- Remote transfer of Gaussian quantum discord
- Coherent control of quantum systems as a resource theory
- Metastable decoherence-free subspace and pointer states in mesoscopic quantum systems
- Time-extensive classical and quantum correlations in thermal machines
- Nonclassical correlations in subsystems of globally entangled quantum states
- Classical Optical Analogue of Quantum Discord
- Partitions of Correlated N-Qubit Systems
- Quantum Information Approach to Bose-Einstein Condensate in a Tilted Double-Well System
- Remote control of quantum correlations in two-qubit receiver via three-qubit sender
- Amplifying quantum correlations with quench dynamics in a quantum spin chain: Steady-states versus ground-states
- Quantifying Nonclassicality of Correlations based on the Concept of Nondisruptive Local State Identification
- Quantum Correlations in NMR systems
- Relating quantum coherence and correlations with entropy-based measures
- Visualizing quantum mechanics in an interactive simulation -- Virtual Lab by Quantum Flytrap
- Invariant entanglement and generation of quantum correlations under global dephasing
- Non-commutative measure of quantum correlations under local operations
- Quantum Reactivity: A Measure of Quantum Correlation
- Behavior of quantum correlations under nondissipative decoherence by means of the correlation matrix
- Integer Programming Using A Single Atom
- Generating quantum dissonance via local operations
- Witness to detect quantum correlation of bipartite states in arbitrary dimension
- Channel Discord and Distortion
- Distributing quantum correlations through local operations and classical resources
- Hardness of efficiently generating ground states in postselected quantum computation
- Quantum information transfer using weak measurements and any non-product resource state
- Quantum correlations under the effect of a thermal environment in a triangular optomechanical cavity
- Some aspects of the interplay between bipartite correlations and quantum channels
- Realizing quantum advantage without entanglement in single-photon states
- Any Two Qubit State Has Non Zero Quantum Discord Under Global Unitary Operations
- Non-classical correlation of cascaded photon pairs emitted from quantum dot
- Power of photonic states: from quantum computation to cosmology
- Probing the non-locality of Majorana fermions via quantum correlations
- Generation of phonon quantum states and quantum correlations among single photon emitters in hexagonal boron nitride