Comment on 'Molybdenum at High Pressure and Temperature: Melting from Another Solid Phase'

Abstract

There has been a major controversy over the past seven years about the high-pressure melting curves of transition metals. Static compression (diamond-anvil cell: DAC) experiments up to the Mbar region give very low melting slopes dT_m/dP, but shock-wave (SW) data reveal transitions indicating much larger dT_m/dP values. Ab initio calculations support the correctness of the shock data. In a very recent letter, Belonoshko et al. propose a simple and elegant resolution of this conflict for molybdenum. Using ab initio calculations based on density functional theory (DFT), they show that the high-P/high-T phase diagram of Mo must be more complex than was hitherto thought. Their calculations give convincing evidence that there is a transition boundary between the normal bcc structure of Mo and a high-T phase, which they suggest could be fcc. They propose that this transition was misinterpreted as melting in DAC experiments. In confirmation, they note that their boundary also explains a transition seen in the SW data. We regard Belonoshko et al.'s Letter as extremely important, but we note that it raises some puzzling questions, and we believe that their proposed phase diagram cannot be completely correct. We have calculated the Helmholtz and Gibbs free energies of the bcc, fcc and hcp phases of Mo, using essentially the same quasiharmonic methods as used by Belonoshko et al.; we find that at high-P and T Mo in the hcp structure is more stable than in bcc or fcc.

1 page, 1 figure. submitted to Phys. Rev. Lett

Cited by in corpus (8)

• Simulation and understanding of quantum crystals
• Constraints on the phase diagram of molybdenum from first-principles free-energy calculations
• Insights into the Phase Diagram of Bismuth Ferrite from Quasi-Harmonic Free Energy Calculations
• Sound velocity measurements of tantalum under shock compression in the 10-110 GPa range
• First-Principles Modeling of Quantum Nuclear Effects and Atomic Interactions in Solid 4He at High Pressure
• The elastic constants of solid 4He under pressure: a diffusion Monte Carlo study
• Melting properties of a simple tight-binding model of transition metals: I.The region of half-filled d-band
• First-principles modeling of three-body interactions in highly compressed solid helium