Heterogeneous bounds of confidence: Meet, Discuss and Find Consensus!

Abstract

Models of continuous opinion dynamics under bounded confidence show a sharp transition between a consensus and a polarization phase at a critical global bound of confidence. In this paper, heterogeneous bounds of confidence are studied. The surprising result is that a society of agents with two different bounds of confidence (open-minded and closed-minded agents) can find consensus even when both bounds of confidence are significantly below the critical bound of confidence of a homogeneous society. The phenomenon is shown by examples of agent-based simulation and by numerical computation of the time evolution of the agents density. The result holds for the bounded confidence model of Deffuant, Weisbuch and others (Weisbuch, G. et al; Meet, discuss, and segregate!, Complexity, 2002, 7, 55--63), as well as for the model of Hegselmann and Krause (Hegselmann, R., Krause, U.; Opinion Dynamics and Bounded Confidence, Models, Analysis and Simulation, Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation, 2002, 5, 2). Thus, given an average level of confidence, diversity of bounds of confidence enhances the chances for consensus. The drawback of this enhancement is that opinion dynamics becomes suspect to severe drifts of clusters, where open-minded agents can pull closed-minded agents towards another cluster of closed-minded agents. A final consensus might thus not lie in the center of the opinion interval as it happens for uniform initial opinion distributions under homogeneous bounds of confidence. It can be located at extremal locations. This is demonstrated by example. This also show that the extension to heterogeneous bounds of confidence enriches the complexity of the dynamics tremendously.

14 pages, 12 figures, large parts rewritten and improved

References in corpus (8)

• Continuous Opinion Dynamics under Bounded Confidence: A Survey
• A stabilization theorem for dynamics of continuous opinions
• The role of network topology on extremism propagation with the Relative Agreement opinion dynamics
• Bifurcations and Patterns in Compromise Processes
• Vector Opinion Dynamics in a Bounded Confidence Consensus Model
• About the Power to Enforce and Prevent Consensus by Manipulating Communication Rules
• Continuous Opinion Dynamics: Insights through Interactive Markov Chains
• Fixed points in models of continuous opinion dynamics under bounded confidence

Cited by in corpus (26)

• Statistical physics of social dynamics
• A Tutorial on Modeling and Analysis of Dynamic Social Networks. Part I
• A Tutorial on Modeling and Analysis of Dynamic Social Networks. Part II
• Opinion dynamics: models, extensions and external effects
• Game-Theoretic Analysis of the Hegselmann-Krause Model for Opinion Dynamics in Finite Dimensions
• Recent advances in opinion propagation dynamics: A 2020 Survey
• Dynamics of bounded confidence opinion in heterogeneous social networks: concord against partial antagonism
• Mass media and heterogeneous bounds of confidence in continuous opinion dynamics
• From classical to modern opinion dynamics
• The noisy Hegselmann-Krause model for opinion dynamics
• Opinion formation and distribution in a bounded confidence model on various networks
• The role of noise and initial conditions in the asymptotic solution of a bounded confidence, continuous-opinion model
• Scaling limits for continuous opinion dynamics systems
• Social Judgment Theory Based Model On Opinion Formation, Polarization And Evolution
• Modeling Social Dynamics in a Collaborative Environment
• The bridges to consensus: Network effects in a bounded confidence opinion dynamics model
• Clusters and the entropy in opinion dynamics on complex networks
• When open mindedness hinders consensus
• Dynamical phase transitions in Hegselmann-Krause model of opinion dynamics and consensus
• Collective effects of the cost of opinion change
• Exploring the foundation of social diversity and coherence with a novel attraction-repulsion model framework
• Inertial Hegselmann-Krause Systems
• Opinion formation in multiplex networks with general initial distributions
• Dynamics of Opinions with Bounded Confidence in Social Cliques: Emergence of Fluctuations
• Hydrodynamic limit of a coupled Cucker-Smale system with strong and weak internal variable relaxation
• Heterogeneous Hegselmann-Krause Dynamics with Environment and Communication Noise