Why the Pennington-Wilson expansion with real coefficients is of little use in the analysis of production processes

Abstract

We critically analyse and comment on the claims of M. R. Pennington and D. J. Wilson [arxiv:0711.3521]. Although we generally agree with their obvious algebra, it is clearly not applicable to our equations. Moreover, we argue that the corresponding proposal is not useful for production-data analysis. The advantages of our approach, which involves complex yet purely kinematical coefficients, are summarised.

arXiv comment7 pages plain LaTeX

References in corpus (22)

• J/Ψ\to ϕππ(K \bar{K}) decays, chiral dynamcis and OZI violation
• Dalitz plot analysis of D_s+ and D+ decay to pi+pi-pi+ using the K-matrix formalism
• Unitary chiral dynamics in J/Psi to VPP decays and the role of scalar mesons
• A Study in Depth of f0(1370)
• The radiative decays $\varphi \to \gamma a_0/f_0$ in the molecular model for the scalar mesons
• Probing the structure of $f_0(980)$ through radiative $\varphi$ decays
• Dalitz plot analysis of the D+ to K-pi+pi+ decay in the FOCUS experiment
• Coupling $g_{f_0{K}^{+}{K}^{-}}$ and the structure of $f_0(980)$
• Reconclining phi radiative decays with other data for a0(980), fo(980), pi-pi -> KK and pi-pi -> eta-eta
• $D_s$ decays into $\varphi$ and $f_0(980)$ mesons
• Towards a model independent determination of the phi -> f_0 - gamma coupling
• Relating multichannel scattering and production amplitudes in a microscopic OZI-based model
• $B\to f_0(980)K^{(\ast )}$ decays and final state interactions
• Probing new physics in B -> f_0(980) K decays
• Relation between Scattering and Production Amplitudes - concerning sigma Particle in pi pi System -
• The complex relation between production and scattering amplitudes
• Analysis of nature of phi -> gamma pi0 eta and phi -> gamma pi0 pi0 decays
• Radiative (phi -> f_0(980) gamma) decay in light cone QCD sum rules
• Decay $\varphi (1020)\to \gamma f_0(980)$: analysis in the non-relativistic quark model approach
• S-wave and P-wave pion-pion and kaon-pion contributions to three-body decay processes in the Resonance-Spectrum Expansion
• On existence of the σ(600) - Its physical implications and related problems
• How adding zero to the complex relation between production and scattering amplitudes found by van Beveren and Rupp gives the expected real relation